England v Australia, 1st Investec Test, Trent Bridge, 4th day

Starc begins with a car crash

ESPNcricinfo presents the plays of the day from the fourth day at Trent Bridge

George Dobell and Dan Brettig at Trent Bridge

July 13, 2013

Comments: 11 | Text size: A | A

Mitchell Starc's massive wide off the first ball of the fourth day, England v Australia, 1st Investec Test, Trent Bridge, 4th day, July 13, 2013
Whoops: Mitchell Starc's first ball of the day © Hawk-Eye
Enlarge
Related Links

Slip of the day
There are many ways to start the day's play. Mitchell Starc picked the car crash option. He delivered a head high full toss that almost killed his captain at first slip and cost his side five runs. If you looked at the day's balls on Hawkeye, you'd assume they had a bug in the system for the first delivery. Eventually Hawk Eye gave up and the path ends as a shadow. Steve Harmison's infamous ball in Brisbane might have been more high profile, but at least he hit the pitch and made it easy for his captain to handle catch it.

Key moment of the day
The dismissal of Michael Clarke - caught behind off the thinnest of outside edges - might be one of the defining moments of this game. Aleem Dar checked the ball had carried to Matt Prior cleanly before giving Clarke out but, having confirmed that with the TV umpire, Clarke utilised Australia's final review. Hot Spot showed the tinniest of marks. With Phil Hughes dismissed in the next over, after England used the DRS to show that more than half of the ball had, by a millimetre or two, pitched inside the line of leg stump. Australia could be justified in feeling that a series of marginal calls had gone against them in this game.

Misfield of the day
Only if England had been rolled over by a steamroller could they have looked more flat than when Shane Watson and Chris Rogers were together. The bowlers looked unthreatening; well Finn would have, if he got a bowl. In the field they lacked their usual energy and hunger. At no stage was this better illustrated than when two fielders got in each other's way, the ball was rebounded loose, and after a second or two they suddenly realised that there could actually be two runs there so for the first time they showed real intent.

Let off of the day
Ed Cowan was on a pair when Steven Finn started to bowl at him. Not just that but Cowan has spent a considerable period of this game in his hotel bathroom due to illness and knew his position was under threat. He was as close to "there for the taking" as a No. 3 batsman gets in Test cricket. But Finn, bowling without pace or control, gifted the most delicious long-hop - wide and outside off stump - to allow Cowan to cut a boundary and release the pressure. An over of similar deliveries followed, forcing Alastair Cook to post a sweeper on the cover boundary which meant there was an easy single through point to allow Cowan and Chris Rogers any easy release stroke. It underlined the sense that Finn, whether due to form or fitness, is currently struggling to fulfil his holding role in this England bowling attack. But he did improve in his second spell.

Celebration of the day
Ian Bell had scored Test centuries before - 17 times before - but the jump for joy, the punch of the air and the sustained celebrations upon reaching three figures betrayed his emotion on achieving this one. Perhaps relief was the primary emotion: Bell's form has not been great of late - he has averaged 30 since the start of 2012 - and he knew the murmurs about his place in the side and the old canard about him only scoring "soft" runs were returning. But here, with an Ashes Test at stake, his team in trouble and an Australian attack bowling well, he had delivered the innings required.

Umpiring error of the day
This has not been a game that either of these two well-respected umpires will reflect on with a great deal of fondness. On the fourth day it was the turn of Kumar Dharmasena to see one of his decisions overturned: having adjudged Rogers caught behind to a delivery from Graeme Swann, Australia utilised the review system and were rewarded when replays showed no edge. Rogers took one look at the replay, and went straight back to his crease to mark his guard. He clearly has more faith in Marius Erasmus than most of us.

Lapse of the day
In Joe Root's first over as tea ticked near, Chris Rogers had a careful look at the part-time offspinner before late cutting the final ball to the boundary. In his second, Rogers clipped a single first ball to leave Ed Cowan facing up to the final over of the afternoon session. Like Rogers, Cowan was initially circumspect. But unlike Rogers, he was unable to contain himself until the end of the over. The fourth ball was tossed up and Cowan leaned out to drive through cover. Root had barely spun a ball in his previous nine, but this one gripped out of the rough and took the edge to slip. Cowan crouched, motionless, before departing. It was not the sort of lapse Australia, or Cowan, can afford.

RSS Feeds: George Dobell

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by   on (July 14, 2013, 9:43 GMT)

Not only have Australia gained 149 runs on one umpiring error, Broad and Trott got about as much bat on their errors as each other, and I'd much rather have Trott out and Broad reprieved wrongly if I was an Aussie.

Posted by dave89 on (July 14, 2013, 9:34 GMT)

If it's marginal aracer - as it was it your own words - then benefit goes to the batsman. Not too difficult to understand one of the time tested tenets of the games. Whereas if you absolutely belt the cover off the ball, and it gets caught, well surprising as that may be to you - not marginal.

Posted by   on (July 14, 2013, 7:46 GMT)

"Australia could be justified in feeling that a series of marginal calls had gone against them in this game." - We haven't forgotten Andrew Symond's nick behind fellows...

Posted by   on (July 14, 2013, 7:42 GMT)

Incidently hawkeye in general seems to be a malfunction

Posted by jmcilhinney on (July 14, 2013, 1:50 GMT)

There are obviously renewed calls to replace Ed Cowan, which is understandable under the circumstances. I wonder whether the selectors will take his illness into account and give him another chance. If they do and he fails again then there will be calls for the selectors' heads as well as Cowan's. If they don't then it's possible, even probable, that this will be Cowan's last Test. I wonder whether Cowan felt that he needed to be more aggressive because he was batting at #3. Maybe he did and maybe he was right but maybe he should have settled a bit more first and maybe he should have been more patient so close to tea.

Posted by Chris_Howard on (July 14, 2013, 1:37 GMT)

"Australia could be justified in feeling that a series of marginal calls had gone against them in this game."

Wha? We got he Agar stumping one which has kept us in the game in the first place. We haven't got anything to complain about.

Posted by electric_loco_WAP4 on (July 14, 2013, 1:15 GMT)

Nothing beats the famous 'Harmy', about as harmless as any batsmen can expect of a cricket ball is propelled at 87mph! Well, that 1 ball got as much world fame - as well as its 'creator', as also pride of place in the Ashes hall of 'fame'! -as the 5-0 drubbing England were dealt at the hands of the Mighty Aussies - :)

Posted by ollie99 on (July 14, 2013, 0:57 GMT)

Regardless of the number of runs Ed Cowan scored, he looked as nervous, tentative and out of form as I have ever seen him - even more so than Hughes, which is saying something. Ed will be very lucky to hold on to his spot for the 2nd test.

Posted by aracer on (July 14, 2013, 0:22 GMT)

I'm not sure how justified Australia would be in feeling they'd been the wrong side of the marginal calls - not when a marginal call which most people seem to agree should have gone the other way gave them 149 more runs.

Posted by   on (July 13, 2013, 22:38 GMT)

The umpire's name is Marais Erasmus, not Marius.

Posted by Batmanian on (July 13, 2013, 21:59 GMT)

I don't think Australia can complain too much about technology augmenting a few decisions - given how streaky Watson and Rogers were early on, the opening partnership could easily have failed. Then there's Agar's stumping in the first innings. The game is still alive; they said Hughes came of age in the first innings, let's hope that Haddin can turn it on exactly when his country needs it; not performing when needed being his rather gaping foible in the past.

Comments have now been closed for this article

TopTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
George DobellClose
Tour Results
England v Australia at Southampton - Sep 16, 2013
Australia won by 49 runs
England v Australia at Cardiff - Sep 14, 2013
England won by 3 wickets (with 3 balls remaining)
England v Australia at Birmingham - Sep 11, 2013
No result
England v Australia at Manchester - Sep 8, 2013
Australia won by 88 runs
England v Australia at Leeds - Sep 6, 2013
Match abandoned without a ball bowled
More results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days