The Surfer

Maurice Holmes, the unlucky mystery spinner

Bowling the 'doosra', though proved a legal delivery, is being discouraged in countries like England and Australia due to their orthodox views on the perception of the proper bowling action

Bowling the 'doosra', though proved a legal delivery, is being discouraged in countries like England and Australia due to their orthodox views on the perception of the proper bowling action. Andy Bull, writing in The Spin, points out the particular case of English mystery spinner Maurice Holmes, on whom the England cricketing system has given up on despite his precious talent.
In Australia national selector John Inverarity has said the decision about whether or not the doosra should be taught to young bowlers is "a question of integrity", because he is not sure it can be bowled legally. Many people in England, it seems, would agree with him, though they haven't come out and said it. Holmes is not one of them. "It is proven that you can bowl the doosra within the limits; that is a scientific fact, there is no morality about it. I have proven that I can bowl it within the limits." It feels as though a confederacy of conservatives is at work against him.
Full post
Questions remain over India's new selectors' picks

It is still not clear is why some performers are repeatedly ignored by India's selectors, regardless of the change in guard, says WV Raman in Wisden India

The case of Manoj Tiwary is rather strange, as not only did he get runs against the visiting Englishmen but he has also done well in limited-overs international cricket in his sporadic appearances. The lack of "X factor" was cited as the reason for S Badrinath's indifferent treatment when he was getting runs as regularly as a batsman possibly could. Rahane deserves to be picked no doubt, but at the same time Tiwary cannot be the soft target eternally.
On the same site, Anjali Doshi says Duncan Fletcher is the invisible man of Indian cricket. While the buzz around England's arrival, the Indian team selection, and the tour games is well and truly underway, there is no sign of the coach, she says.
Unlike John Wright, the former India coach who could put the selectors to shame with his propensity to watch domestic cricket, Fletcher has chosen not to visit any Ranji matches. Ranji cricket apart, he has been conspicuously absent for England's two tour games in India. And while he is expected to show up for the three-day camp just days before the first Test begins in Ahmedabad on November 15, India's preparations for the forthcoming Tests seem insipid and lacking in direction. Compare this to the kind of homework England are putting in, having arrived three weeks early, and there is some cause for concern.
Full post
Australia should help New Zealand

New Zealand's low standard of domestic cricket, writes Andy Roo in The Roar, has been a hindrance to their rise in international cricket

New Zealand's low standard of domestic cricket, writes Andy Roo in The Roar, has been a hindrance to their rise in international cricket. If Australia could allow them to participate in the Big Bash League and the Sheffield Shield, their standards could improve.
Perhaps there is still the opportunity for teams from New Zealand to join the Big Bash League? Who knows where the T20 game will be in a few years time, given the changing nature of cricket. If New Zealand teams were to join the Australian competition, then perhaps this would lead to them also joining the Sheffield Shield.
Unlike other international examples, the rivalry has usually been a well natured one. Perhaps it is time to show some brotherly love and follow the compelling example of our netballing sisters.
Full post
Approval of day-night Tests a welcome move

ICC's approval of the idea of playing day-night Tests was the right way forward, believes Suresh Menon, writing in espnstar.com

ICC's approval of the idea of playing day-night Tests was the right way forward, believes Suresh Menon, writing in espnstar.com. It gives the fans a chance to engage into some cricket after work, and the issue of fiddling with the age-old "summer game" wouldn't hold much value after, say, ten years.
Cricket is a summer game, played in the the sun (which is why players rush to the pavilion as soon as it begins to rain in the neighbouring state), and should remain so. But - and this is the question to be asked - is it better to play to relatively bigger crowds at night or to play in the sun before the proverbial three men and a dog? Over the years, the game has evolved. Bats have changed, the height of the stumps too; the laws were different from what they are today, and the unstated aim has been to make it more competitive, more attractive and more gasp-worthy.
Yes, Test cricket ought to be played in the sun with a red ball but Test cricket at night is an idea whose time has come.
Full post
Taufel will be missed

Simon Taufel, who has retired as an international umpire, was so good at umpiring that he went unnoticed throughout his career, writes Osman Samiuddin in The National

Simon Taufel, who has retired as an international umpire, was so good at umpiring that he went unnoticed throughout his career, writes Osman Samiuddin in The National. His professionalism, which included not just making the right decisions but also sharing a level of trust with the players as an umpire, went a long way in defining him as a role model.
One thing, which became clearer over time, was how gently the weight of the position rested with him. He found just that right space between authority and friendliness and settled into it, which is the secret of all management really.
This came out best in the smile he offered the bowler after turning down an appeal; a little patronising sure with those pursed lips, but a little sympathetic too in those eyes. It was as expert and finely tuned as the steady hands that defuse bombs.
Full post
Negligence to first-class cricket dangerous

Many of the Indian players who are a part of the squad for the first Test against England are trying to get match practice through the Ranji Trophy

Many of the Indian players who are a part of the squad for the first Test against England are trying to get match practice through the Ranji Trophy. That's a welcome move, says Dileep Premachandran in The National. He points out that five cricketers who were voted Widen's Cricketers of the 20th Century spent most of their careers playing domestic first-class cricket, unlike today's players. The case of Pat Cummins, who has played just four first-class games and has suffered a few injuries in his short career, is testimony to the fact that negligence to first-class cricket is a dangerous trend.
Change is inevitable, but it is hard to overstate just how much upcoming players may have lost out by being deprived of the chance to play first-class cricket with the stalwarts.
The alarm bells have begun to ring in Australia with Pat Cummins, the 19-year-old fast bowler, set to miss another full season through injury. Cummins has played just four first-class games, while representing Australia and others in as many as 28 Twenty20 matches. Trying to run without perfecting the walk is risky business.
Venkat Ananth, writing in Yahoo Cricket, believes Ranji Trophy isn't "dying the tiger's death." Though it is a colourless tournament devoid of excitement, its charm lies in that very nature, and in its usefulness to the mundane cricketer who doesn't dream of representing the country one day.
Full post
The long goodbyes begin

Sachin Tendulkar, Ricky Ponting and Jacques Kallis bestride Test cricket - but how much longer will the magic spell last?

We will be intrigued by three players, who share 510 Test caps, 41,520 Test runs and 113 years between them: Sachin Tendulkar, Ricky Ponting and Jacques Kallis. But will we be marvelling at their immortality or wincing as they vainly seek to recapture the magic of their earlier years? It could be enthralling; it could be very painful.
Tendulkar and Ponting are now accustomed to queries about their future but somehow retirement has not been an issue with Kallis recently. It may be that his recent form has been so impressive; it can't just be that the new batch of hair upon Kallis's head creates an impression of youthfulness, which deflects any interrogators.
Full post
Understanding Buchanan

It has been 18 months since John Buchanan became NZC's director of cricket, and with New Zealand's consistent defeats and the resignation of coach John Wright, his tenure hasn't been altogether productive

Buchanan is playing the long game. His is a numbers plan based around performance. A holistic plan encompassing everything cricket, judging New Zealand cricketers on the world's best players' numbers. Plenty of paper work, plenty of assessment.
Wright's was more on instinct and hard work. In general Wright was seen as "old school" and wanted the right people with the right attitudes. His belief was that hard work and the best people were what was needed.
Full post
Scheduling at its worst

In the New Zealand Herald, David Leggat writes that the endless rain in Sri Lanka begs the question as to why the series was scheduled in among the wettest months of the year

In the New Zealand Herald, David Leggat writes that the endless rain in Sri Lanka begs the question as to why the series was scheduled in among the wettest months of the year. Young players wanting to make an impression before the South Africa tour will not enjoy sitting around watching the skies.
Yesterday's forecast had the encouraging word "thunder-showers" and one of those large lightning bolts sandwiched between angled rain lines. Now look at Sri Lanka's rainfall rates. This is the second inter-monsoon season over there. One month has a mean total rainfall of 414.4 millimetres, by a distance the wettest month of the year. Go on, have a guess which month it is?
Full post

Showing 1171 - 1180 of 9201