Who are the next best things?
Apart from Rahul Dravid, the rest of India's batsmen have endured a torrid tour of England so far
Akash Lal (North Zone representative on the selection panel that picked Sachin Tendulkar): Domestic cricket must still be given the highest priority. If I had to pick someone to replace the top order, I would look for correctness of play. When Sachin was picked he was technically very assured. Nowadays I am aghast to see that we are facing the same traditional problems against the ball leaving the off stump, and the rising delivery. I personally think that Rohit Sharma has been given a rough deal by the selectors. He first got a chance in Australia and he performed really well on surfaces that were really difficult to bat on. I think the selectors have forgotten about him.
Ajit Wadekar (The chairman of selectors when Harbhajan Singh made his debut for India in 1998): For now with Harbhajan struggling the way he is, the selectors should definitely go for R Ashwin. Ashwin has shown his class and temperament with the ball every time he’s gotten a chance. I don’t agree with people who tag him as a limited-overs specialist. Ashwin possesses a very deceptive action and always looks focussed on improving himself with every outing. He never seems short of ideas, and I am sure that he will be a valuable addition to the Indian Test team. I think the selectors should draft him into the Test set-up right away.
Akhila Ranganna is assistant editor (Audio) at ESPNcricinfo