October 1, 2013

For the love of Brijesh Patel

You aren't always drawn to the game by superstars. Sometimes players who couldn't quite make it are the ones who turn you into a lifelong fan
15

Brijesh Patel dismissed for 5 in his debut innings, at Old Trafford, 1974
Brijesh Patel dismissed for 5 in his debut innings, at Old Trafford, 1974 © PA Photos

Every cricket fan comes of age at a certain point in time: a match or series that captures your imagination and renders you a cricket lover for ever after. More often than not, however, it's a particular player who triggers the transformation into a passionate aficionado of the game. For me, as a schoolboy in Bangalore and Madras in the 1970s, there was one player who epitomised everything I loved about the game, and who showed me that it also had a cruel and merciless side: Brijesh Patel.

Brijesh was a dashing batsman and electric fielder at cover-point. With his lithe physique, improbably light eyes, and a Zapata moustache that would have been the envy of any self-respecting pirate in the Caribbean, Brijesh was a contrast to many of his rotund Karnataka and South Zone team-mates who looked exactly what they were - bank officers.

Even as a high-school player in Bangalore, Brijesh was marked for bigger things. People spoke with awe of towering sixes hit with a nonchalant flick of deceptively slim forearms; of flat throws rifled in from the boundary, scattering stumps and bails with direct hits; of a sense of timing that was unreal - forward-defensive pushes that raced to the long-on fence.

When Tony Lewis' visiting MCC side played South Zone, Brijesh burst onto the national scene with a breathtaking 93. His partner that day, Mansur Ali Khan Pataudi, who was making a comeback after a self-imposed exile, got a century. As the Noob and (in my fervid imagination) his heir-apparent cut the English attack to ribbons, the future seemed limitless and bright. Brijesh was destined for greatness, and I would follow in that wonderful slipstream with my collection of photographs and statistics.

Brijesh was selected for the tour to England in the summer of 1974. He began with a hundred that included two sixes and umpteen boundaries, against Derrick Robins' XI. As the first Test neared, I could barely contain my anticipation. A century on debut seemed to be there for the taking. I could already hear John Arlott, Brian Johnston and Trevor Bailey rhapsodise (well, as much as their English reserve would permit) about this new star.

In his first four Test innings Brijesh scored 5, 3, 1 and 1. The first half of an exceptionally cold and dank English summer, and the swing and seam of Geoff Arnold, Chris Old, Mike Hendrick and Tony Greig was too much for the Indians. It turned out that my hero, like most of his team-mates, lacked the technique to counter such conditions. Brijesh was dropped for the third Test and the Indians returned home after having "copped a mother and father of a hiding" as the ebullient Greig put it at the end of the 3-0 shellacking.

Back in India, as Clive Lloyd's West Indians arrived, my hopes resurged. Surely Brijesh would triumph in home conditions? It was not to be, and by the third Test he had been dropped again. He returned for the final match, at the Wankhede, and in the fourth innings of a Test that was already as good as lost, he smacked a couple of sixes on the way to an unbeaten 73. When he reached his 50, a young saree-clad woman from the stands outran policemen to reach the wicket and plant a kiss on a blushing Brijesh. More than an augury of things to come, it soon came to be a sad reminder of what could have been.

The rest of Brijesh's brief Test career remained stuck in mediocrity. A single century (in a drawn Test on a slow wicket), a few dashing fifties (mainly at home), and a brisk 49 not out as India chased down 403 in Port-of-Spain, stood as glimmers of light. A career of 21 Tests with an average under 30 speaks for itself. Perhaps even sadder is the fact that he hit seven sixes in his entire Test career; I had hoped for as many in his debut innings.

My final memory of Brijesh's brief Test career is poignant. I remember watching a recorded telecast of the infamous Sabina Park Test of 1976 (the one that followed the historic win in Port-of-Spain), where Lloyd's all-pace attack battered the Indians to a crushing defeat. As Michael Holding and Wayne Daniel (with support from Bernard Julien and Vanburn Holder) peppered the Indians, a helmetless Brijesh kept edging away towards square leg, taking his eyes off the ball. Soon enough, a delivery caught the edge of his hanging bat and crashed into his upper lip. As Brijesh dropped his bat and frantically waved to the dressing room for help, I realised, rather sadly, that physical courage was not my hero's strong suit. The contrast to the efforts of Gaekwad, Amarnath, Vengsarkar, Vishy and Gavaskar in the same conditions was too obvious to ignore, even for a wide-eyed schoolboy. Though he played another ten Tests (eight of them at home), and his final two Tests were in Brisbane and Perth, the promise that had been Brijesh came to an end at Sabina Park.

As I remember those sun-dappled early days when he would walk out to bat for Karnataka or South Zone, take his time to get his eye in, and announce his readiness for battle with a straight drive for four, or an effortless pull over midwicket for six, it is hard not to treasure that sense of anticipation, of good things to come, of brilliance unfolding. It is a sense of possibility that Brijesh once represented. That it was not to be is as much our loss as his. There is, after all, no love quite like your first one.

Sankaran Krishna is a professor of political science at the University of Hawaii, in Honolulu

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • on October 1, 2013, 13:50 GMT

    Wonderful article indeed, took me down memory lane. As a 6 year old watching Grieg's Englishmen play Bedi's Indians in 1977 at Bombay, I recall Patel hitting a memorable hundred. He, as you say Mr Krishnan, lacked physical courage of a Dilip or Jimmy who took blows to their body and seldom sold their wickets cheap. SMG and Vishy were far too classy and technically masterful to cop body blows to begin with! Brijesh is one of those unfortunate guys who with the advent of helmets would have been a wonderful batsmen. I have spoken to Bombay old timers (test players) about him and a lot of them compared him to a modern day Yuvi, such was the similarity apparently. Brijesh was shell shocked after the Jamaican hospitality poor chap, what you have not mentioned here is that he also was the "proud" recipient of a Mikey Holding special beamer, similar to Anshuman who actually got hit by it. Today's sagely Mikey may sound and appear very avuncular but trust me in 1976 was a different beast!

  • on October 2, 2013, 23:11 GMT

    Let's not forget the four consecutive fours off Andy Roberts at Wankhede with Chandrasekhar at the non-striker's end. We lost the test, but he did cast the spell, like the writer says.

  • Peterincanada on October 2, 2013, 15:19 GMT

    @Kedar Pandit You are absolutely right. He was called Whispering Death for good reason.

  • on October 2, 2013, 9:26 GMT

    I remember a headline (I think it was The Hindu) after that 93 against MCC. "A star is born!"! Alas it was a shooting star...

    KS Pillai

  • on October 2, 2013, 8:06 GMT

    Arguably the greatest domestic batsman of his era below Test level. For sheer flair, I'd place him ahead of Ashok Mankad or Parthasarathy Sharma. Led Karnataka to a title triumph in the Ranji Trophy though refusing to attempt a doable fourth innings target against Bombay in the final and settling for a win by virtue of the first innings lead. Would probably have done much better in international cricket with the aid of helmets and bowling machines. Outstanding coverpoint.

  • indianpunter on October 2, 2013, 7:21 GMT

    wow! that was brilliant. much before my time, but a fascinating read nevertheless. thank you.

  • on October 2, 2013, 7:11 GMT

    Alongwith Brijesh Patel, here are a few more batsmen who captured our imaginations with the way they batted, some delivering some not delivering -

    Sandeep Patil, Vinod Kambli, Azhar, David Gower, Kim Hughes, Greame Hick, Srinivasan (70's, TN), Ashok Mankad, Kirti Azad.....

  • glen1 on October 2, 2013, 1:34 GMT

    Helmet should have become mandatory after the Nari Contractor episode. Those were days when cricket rules were made elsewhere and Indians hardly had a say. Many a great skilled artist like Brijesh were made to look wimpy without helmets. Yes, the fear factor got the better of his skills and he would duck sometimes even to bale height balls; a rather unfortunate sight. In the helmetless days, the shorter guys like Gavaskar and Vishwanath were better suited to face fast bowling, in fact, Vishwanath was the best player of fast bowling.

  • Mittaraghava on October 1, 2013, 19:09 GMT

    I felt happy that the author reminded us of B.Patel.I rate B.Patel among the great attacking batsmen India had produced.They are C.K.Naidu,S.Durrani,F.Engineer,B.Patel,Kapil Dev.S.Patil,K.Srikanth,V.Sehwag,Yuvaraj Singh and indeed S.Tendulker during his early part of his career(world cup 1992 is one example)and D.Vengsarkar to some extent.Even if some of them have scored well only in few matches their brilliant batting style remains memorable.Spectators get excited when they come to bat as batting fireworks are expected sooner or later.

  • sportofpain on October 1, 2013, 18:54 GMT

    I also used to fervently hope that Brijesh would do well. Was a fan of his fielding and batting. I remember one innings of 80 odd against the Kiwis where he smashed everything to the fence. This was in the 1976 series I think.

    That he didn't succeed is true only in comparison to the others who became greats. However he played for India many times and even scored a century against the WI at Port of Spain - those are things that as we grow older we come to realize are tremendous accomplishments. The guy didn't fail. He was a tremendous success.

  • on October 1, 2013, 13:50 GMT

    Wonderful article indeed, took me down memory lane. As a 6 year old watching Grieg's Englishmen play Bedi's Indians in 1977 at Bombay, I recall Patel hitting a memorable hundred. He, as you say Mr Krishnan, lacked physical courage of a Dilip or Jimmy who took blows to their body and seldom sold their wickets cheap. SMG and Vishy were far too classy and technically masterful to cop body blows to begin with! Brijesh is one of those unfortunate guys who with the advent of helmets would have been a wonderful batsmen. I have spoken to Bombay old timers (test players) about him and a lot of them compared him to a modern day Yuvi, such was the similarity apparently. Brijesh was shell shocked after the Jamaican hospitality poor chap, what you have not mentioned here is that he also was the "proud" recipient of a Mikey Holding special beamer, similar to Anshuman who actually got hit by it. Today's sagely Mikey may sound and appear very avuncular but trust me in 1976 was a different beast!

  • on October 2, 2013, 23:11 GMT

    Let's not forget the four consecutive fours off Andy Roberts at Wankhede with Chandrasekhar at the non-striker's end. We lost the test, but he did cast the spell, like the writer says.

  • Peterincanada on October 2, 2013, 15:19 GMT

    @Kedar Pandit You are absolutely right. He was called Whispering Death for good reason.

  • on October 2, 2013, 9:26 GMT

    I remember a headline (I think it was The Hindu) after that 93 against MCC. "A star is born!"! Alas it was a shooting star...

    KS Pillai

  • on October 2, 2013, 8:06 GMT

    Arguably the greatest domestic batsman of his era below Test level. For sheer flair, I'd place him ahead of Ashok Mankad or Parthasarathy Sharma. Led Karnataka to a title triumph in the Ranji Trophy though refusing to attempt a doable fourth innings target against Bombay in the final and settling for a win by virtue of the first innings lead. Would probably have done much better in international cricket with the aid of helmets and bowling machines. Outstanding coverpoint.

  • indianpunter on October 2, 2013, 7:21 GMT

    wow! that was brilliant. much before my time, but a fascinating read nevertheless. thank you.

  • on October 2, 2013, 7:11 GMT

    Alongwith Brijesh Patel, here are a few more batsmen who captured our imaginations with the way they batted, some delivering some not delivering -

    Sandeep Patil, Vinod Kambli, Azhar, David Gower, Kim Hughes, Greame Hick, Srinivasan (70's, TN), Ashok Mankad, Kirti Azad.....

  • glen1 on October 2, 2013, 1:34 GMT

    Helmet should have become mandatory after the Nari Contractor episode. Those were days when cricket rules were made elsewhere and Indians hardly had a say. Many a great skilled artist like Brijesh were made to look wimpy without helmets. Yes, the fear factor got the better of his skills and he would duck sometimes even to bale height balls; a rather unfortunate sight. In the helmetless days, the shorter guys like Gavaskar and Vishwanath were better suited to face fast bowling, in fact, Vishwanath was the best player of fast bowling.

  • Mittaraghava on October 1, 2013, 19:09 GMT

    I felt happy that the author reminded us of B.Patel.I rate B.Patel among the great attacking batsmen India had produced.They are C.K.Naidu,S.Durrani,F.Engineer,B.Patel,Kapil Dev.S.Patil,K.Srikanth,V.Sehwag,Yuvaraj Singh and indeed S.Tendulker during his early part of his career(world cup 1992 is one example)and D.Vengsarkar to some extent.Even if some of them have scored well only in few matches their brilliant batting style remains memorable.Spectators get excited when they come to bat as batting fireworks are expected sooner or later.

  • sportofpain on October 1, 2013, 18:54 GMT

    I also used to fervently hope that Brijesh would do well. Was a fan of his fielding and batting. I remember one innings of 80 odd against the Kiwis where he smashed everything to the fence. This was in the 1976 series I think.

    That he didn't succeed is true only in comparison to the others who became greats. However he played for India many times and even scored a century against the WI at Port of Spain - those are things that as we grow older we come to realize are tremendous accomplishments. The guy didn't fail. He was a tremendous success.

  • InsideHedge on October 1, 2013, 18:30 GMT

    Lovely read, Sankaran, thank you for that. My first glimpse of Brijesh was at the opening match of the 1979 World Cup against West Indies at Edgbaston. In fact, it was my first glimpse of all the Indians, what a thrill even if the result was an almighty tonking from the defending champions.

    I remember a couple of memorable boundaries from Gaekwad (off Holding) and Brijesh. In those days, it didn't take much to please us! But the standout innings was from Vishy, even today I would say it's one of the best ODI innings that I've ever seen. There was a particular backcut that he played off one knee (off Holding) that left the spectators gasping. He was on a different plane to the rest of the Indian batters that day.

    Brijesh was run out that day, it was another brief innings that promised much - mirroring his career that you describe so well in your article.

  • on October 1, 2013, 14:40 GMT

    One of my favourite too…Dashing Batsman!! Very popular especially the innings he played against Clive Lloyd's invincible West Indies team of the late 70's…in Mumbai!(Bombay)

  • on October 1, 2013, 13:44 GMT

    i reciprocate the writer's anguish one hundred per cent

  • CricketChat on October 1, 2013, 12:27 GMT

    He was primarily good batsman against spin and slow to medium pace bowling. True fast bowling and swing bowling exposed his short comings in technique as was the occasion of big stage. AV Mankad of Bombay also belonged to this category in the 70s. These two used to score big in side games, but when tests came along, they would fall by way side.

  • vaidyar on October 1, 2013, 8:53 GMT

    Why doesn't his profile in cricinfo have a pic? For 21 tests, he surely deserves one, no?

    Thanks for pointing that out vaidyar. A profile photo has been uploaded.

    ESPNcricinfo staff

  • vaidyar on October 1, 2013, 8:53 GMT

    Why doesn't his profile in cricinfo have a pic? For 21 tests, he surely deserves one, no?

    Thanks for pointing that out vaidyar. A profile photo has been uploaded.

    ESPNcricinfo staff

  • CricketChat on October 1, 2013, 12:27 GMT

    He was primarily good batsman against spin and slow to medium pace bowling. True fast bowling and swing bowling exposed his short comings in technique as was the occasion of big stage. AV Mankad of Bombay also belonged to this category in the 70s. These two used to score big in side games, but when tests came along, they would fall by way side.

  • on October 1, 2013, 13:44 GMT

    i reciprocate the writer's anguish one hundred per cent

  • on October 1, 2013, 14:40 GMT

    One of my favourite too…Dashing Batsman!! Very popular especially the innings he played against Clive Lloyd's invincible West Indies team of the late 70's…in Mumbai!(Bombay)

  • InsideHedge on October 1, 2013, 18:30 GMT

    Lovely read, Sankaran, thank you for that. My first glimpse of Brijesh was at the opening match of the 1979 World Cup against West Indies at Edgbaston. In fact, it was my first glimpse of all the Indians, what a thrill even if the result was an almighty tonking from the defending champions.

    I remember a couple of memorable boundaries from Gaekwad (off Holding) and Brijesh. In those days, it didn't take much to please us! But the standout innings was from Vishy, even today I would say it's one of the best ODI innings that I've ever seen. There was a particular backcut that he played off one knee (off Holding) that left the spectators gasping. He was on a different plane to the rest of the Indian batters that day.

    Brijesh was run out that day, it was another brief innings that promised much - mirroring his career that you describe so well in your article.

  • sportofpain on October 1, 2013, 18:54 GMT

    I also used to fervently hope that Brijesh would do well. Was a fan of his fielding and batting. I remember one innings of 80 odd against the Kiwis where he smashed everything to the fence. This was in the 1976 series I think.

    That he didn't succeed is true only in comparison to the others who became greats. However he played for India many times and even scored a century against the WI at Port of Spain - those are things that as we grow older we come to realize are tremendous accomplishments. The guy didn't fail. He was a tremendous success.

  • Mittaraghava on October 1, 2013, 19:09 GMT

    I felt happy that the author reminded us of B.Patel.I rate B.Patel among the great attacking batsmen India had produced.They are C.K.Naidu,S.Durrani,F.Engineer,B.Patel,Kapil Dev.S.Patil,K.Srikanth,V.Sehwag,Yuvaraj Singh and indeed S.Tendulker during his early part of his career(world cup 1992 is one example)and D.Vengsarkar to some extent.Even if some of them have scored well only in few matches their brilliant batting style remains memorable.Spectators get excited when they come to bat as batting fireworks are expected sooner or later.

  • glen1 on October 2, 2013, 1:34 GMT

    Helmet should have become mandatory after the Nari Contractor episode. Those were days when cricket rules were made elsewhere and Indians hardly had a say. Many a great skilled artist like Brijesh were made to look wimpy without helmets. Yes, the fear factor got the better of his skills and he would duck sometimes even to bale height balls; a rather unfortunate sight. In the helmetless days, the shorter guys like Gavaskar and Vishwanath were better suited to face fast bowling, in fact, Vishwanath was the best player of fast bowling.

  • on October 2, 2013, 7:11 GMT

    Alongwith Brijesh Patel, here are a few more batsmen who captured our imaginations with the way they batted, some delivering some not delivering -

    Sandeep Patil, Vinod Kambli, Azhar, David Gower, Kim Hughes, Greame Hick, Srinivasan (70's, TN), Ashok Mankad, Kirti Azad.....

  • indianpunter on October 2, 2013, 7:21 GMT

    wow! that was brilliant. much before my time, but a fascinating read nevertheless. thank you.