New Zealand v Australia, 5th ODI, Napier

Unbearably too good

Australia should be removed from all official championships and only allowed to defend their World Cup title

Commentary by Andrew McLean

March 5, 2005

Text size: A | A

The victorious Australians: another series, another whitewash © Getty Images

David Houghton wants Zimbabwe out of mainstream international cricket, and there's been plenty of talk of dumping Bangladesh as well. One should probably add Australia to that list: they are simply too good, and are ruining the game.

Australia should be removed from all official championships and only allowed to defend their World Cup title. They can play Australia A for practice, and take on World XI selections to make some money. Only then will world cricket become an even playing field.

This might sound ridiculous, but so were New Zealand and those before them who were hammered each time they encountered Australia. In the last 12 months Australia has won 12 of 14 Tests and 19 of 22 one-dayers. In Tests they have won 3-0 in Sri Lanka, out-thought India in their own backyard, thrashed New Zealand by an innings and 156 and then by 213 runs, before handing out a few cricket lessons to Pakistan. The carnage culminated today, when New Zealand were handed their first 5-0 ODI whitewash at home.

England's prospects of being competitive in the Ashes in a few months have been talked up but, frankly, even the dodgiest of bookmakers could not expect anything other than a crushing series victory to Australia.

In sporting terms, cricket is a virtually a religion in Australia. Christmas Day is as much about the obligatory game of backyard cricket as it is about turkey and presents. Michael Slater went so far as to say on television today that the Australian captaincy was the second most important job in the country after the Prime Minister's.

Despite this, there have been signs that the total world dominance of Ricky Ponting's men is bad for cricket in Australia. There has been speculation that Aussie fans are frustrated at the predictability of the result each time Australia take the field, and there was also the ABC's decision not to broadcast all of the current tour on the radio.

Rather than kick Australia out of world cricket, perhaps they could donate some of their outstanding first-class but non-international cricketers to teams like New Zealand and Zimbabwe. Then everyone would be happy. Cricket would return to Australian radio, fans would go to games in greater numbers ... and Australia losing might be a possibility again.

For the moment, though, the status quo remains, and New Zealand were the latest victims. If Zimbabwe were criticised for lacking players of international standard then the same could be said of New Zealand's attack today - Kyle Mills, Lance Hamilton, Tama Canning, Daniel Vettori, Craig McMillan and Craig Cumming. It must be the worst combination Stephen Fleming has been presented with in his eight-year tenure as captain.

When you consider that Shane Bond, Ian Butler, Andre Adams, and Michael Mason were unavailable for selection, Jeff Wilson was ruled out prior to the game and Chris Cairns was injured three overs into it, it would be easy to lay the blame on the spate of injuries. However, by his own admission this week, depleted bowling ranks have become the norm for Fleming rather than full first-choice complements.

The time has come for change. If Australia is not willing to share its resources then official championships should be scrapped and backyard rules introduced. At the start of the next match, New Zealand and Australia should line up, and Fleming and Ponting would toss a coin to see who gets first pick.

Adam Gilchrist would no doubt be in the highest demand, and deciding between Shane Warne and Glenn McGrath as the next pick would be a tough decision. Stupid as it may sound, it would be an interesting exercise and we'd at least finally get a competitive contest.

Let us know what you think

Andrew McLean is a presenter of The Cricket Club, New Zealand's only national radio cricket show.

RSS Feeds: Andrew McLean

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Email Feedback Print
Andrew McLeanClose
Related Links

Chanderpaul, the coach's nightmare

Modern Masters: He developed a rhythm that worked for him and gave him better balance at the crease

    'I spent 95% of my career bowling the same ball'

Angus Fraser talks about his workmanlike bowling, playing second fiddle, his stop-start career, and England in the '90s

    'A coach earns respect by working as hard as the players'

Sanjay Bangar talks about his quick transition from player to coach, his philosophy and the reasons behind Kings XI Punjab's turnaround

    'Swann could bowl length blindfolded'

Erapalli Prasanna on a thoroughbred professional whose basics were extraordinarily strong

The mathematician who loved cricket

Haider Riaz Khan: GH Hardy, a regular at Cambridge, ranked mathematicians and physicists on the 'Bradman class'

News | Features Last 7 days

Champions League T20 still battling for meaning

The thrills are rather low-octane, the skills are a bit lightweight, and the tournament overly India-centric

From Constantine to Chanderpaul

As West Indies play their 500th Test, here's an interactive journey through their Test history

'My kind of bowling style is gone now'

Former New Zealand seamer Gavin Larsen talks about wobbly seam-up bowling, the 1992 World Cup, and his role in the next tournament

Busy keepers, and Waqar's bowleds

Also, high scores and low averages, most ducks in international cricket, and the 12-year-old Test player

Soaring in the 1980s, slumping in the 2000s

In their pomp, West Indies had a 53-13 win-loss record; in their last 99, it is 16-53. That, in a nutshell, shows how steep the decline has been

News | Features Last 7 days