Peter English
Peter English Peter EnglishRSS FeedFeeds  | Archives
Former Australasia editor, ESPNcricinfo

Goodbye to the summer of spite

Some lessons for India and Australia following three months of controversy and drama that overshadowed some wonderful cricket

Peter English

March 7, 2008

Comments: 35 | Text size: A | A


The seriousness of some - but not all - of Harbhajan Singh's exploits during India's tour were exaggerated © Getty Images
Enlarge
 

The comedian Billy Connolly jokes the Queen must think the world smells of fresh paint because everything is new wherever she visits. Until the first week in January, Australia also felt they were adored throughout their country. Crowds always roar when they play, spectators crowd them for autographs and they are pestered for interviews and corporate deals. So they were stunned when the opinions of many dissenters emerged after the dramatic and spectacular Sydney Test victory.

Following issues involving umpiring, race, catching, walking, ungracious celebrations and Anil Kumble's claim only one side was playing in the spirit of the game, the shock self-analysis began. Australia thought about their behaviour and their results started stuttering. Ricky Ponting, who nobody seriously believed should have been sacked after the second Test, has a delicate period ahead as he balances a win-at-all-costs outlook with his desire for the universal acclaim of his nation.

Lesser of two evils
India celebrated when Harbhajan Singh was finally cleared of racially abusing Andrew Symonds during the SCG Test. Instead he was only found guilty of swearing something at Symonds that was so insulting, an embarrassed Sachin Tendulkar struggled to define it during the Adelaide hearing. When Harbhajan's verdict was announced there was collective joy in India for the saving of a hero's reputation. Whatever the outcome, there should have been mourning for the public decline of player standards on both sides. Through the entire situation, from the moment Symonds argued with Harbhajan after he touched Brett Lee's bottom, none of those closely involved could have been proud of their actions.

Stupid ... or worse?
The final controversial act in a summer when the seriousness of some - but not all - of Harbhajan's exploits were exaggerated, particularly in Australia, was his ape-like gestures at a section of the SCG crowd last Sunday. If Harbhajan, who was originally reported during the Sydney Test for calling Symonds a monkey, did make the moves toward the predominately white spectators - he denies it, of course, and the ICC did not rule it worthy of a hearing - does this eliminate the race aspect of the original claim? A man who behaves the same to people of all colours might be classed an idiot, but not a racist.

D is for Denial
As the world's financial powerhouse - a feat they may soon match on the field - India must start taking responsibility. A culture of denial seems to operate from top to bottom. Senior officials say there are no racism problems in the country, they never discussed a boycott of the tour, and a plane wasn't chartered to fly them straight home after the second Harbhajan hearing. Quotes coming from board figures or team managers were often only a day from being disregarded as nonsense, and the players' claims that their words were misheard because they were said in another language were tiring. There is no longer room for India's poor-little-rich-kid act.

Turn up the volume
Australia's line when challenged about their mental disintegration - "What is sledging anyway?" - falls into the same category as India's denials. After forming a document on the spirit of cricket, the Australians consider themselves the game's moral guardians, a stance which opposition teams would find hilarious if it didn't make them so angry. Indian board officials want sledging banned, which contrasts with its team's desire to become as good as the Australians, who struggle to understand why other sides are offended by their words. Arjuna Ranatunga's suggestion to turn up the microphones will allow everyone to judge every team's spirit.


Due to the problems with technology, the on-field umpires need to deal with low catches instead of relying on the word of the players © Getty Images
Enlarge
 

Not very appealing
The most outrageous leg-before-wicket appeal was conducted by Anil Kumble, who shouted for Brad Hogg's wicket in Sydney even though he hit the ball to cover and ran two. Australians believe India yell for anything and after watching Harbhajan regularly turn to the umpire after balls pitched a long way outside leg, it was tempting to wonder if he knew the rules.

The frequency of Australia's requests have dropped since Shane Warne retired, but they are still well - or cleverly or sneakily, depending on your view - orchestrated. Rahul Dravid rediscovered this when he went courtesy of an "edge" behind to a ball that brushed his pad on the final day at the SCG. With the officials, Mark Benson and Steve Bucknor, already flustered from a hectic Test, the Australians leaned on them throughout the final day and ultimately won. (A lot of skill was involved as well, but a couple of controversial calls certainly helped.) India learned quickly and their appeal against Michael Clarke in the first CB Series final, when Rudi Koertzen gave him out off his pad, was an excellent case of imitation.

Drop the catching pact
One of Ponting's most treasured ideas is an honesty system over low-to-the-ground catches, but in the current technological climate it is impossible for a player's word to be accepted. It is a shame that the inconclusiveness of the television replay creates so much conjecture over dismissals that are more obvious live than in slow-motion replays. If a player claims one that looks suspicious on television his ethics are challenged, which Clarke realised in Sydney. Wonderful catches - the view of Australia - taken by Andrew Symonds and Michael Hussey during the CB Series were doubted by much of India despite the certainty of the umpires. This is one area where the on-field officials should be handed more power even if it means they are occasionally incorrect.

Hooray for Sri Lanka
It slipped the notice of many, but there was a third team in Australia over the past five months and they are welcome any time. Sri Lanka struggled on the field and had their usual unfortunate batch of Muttiah Muralitharan-related incidents - including an unorthodox one when he was part of a group hit by egg throwers in Hobart. Despite the issues there were no complaints and their gentlemanly representatives were fine ambassadors. At the moment there isn't a spot on the Future Tours Program for their next visit to Australia, but please come back soon.

And then there was cricket
Stripped of all the controversy, it was an incredibly fulfilling summer on the field. Ishant Sharma's bowling to Ponting in Perth was the spell of the season and he is so talented that he should leave the sledging and sendoffs to the mortals. Lee's bowling was immense throughout both series and Matthew Hayden's three centuries were crucial to Australia's 2-1 Test win. And it will be hard to forget Clarke's three wickets in the final over at the SCG and VVS Laxman's flicked and driven boundaries earlier in the game. Or the joy of India's celebrations when the Test victory was sealed in Perth and the CB Trophy was collected in Brisbane.

However, the most memorable moments were the receptions given to Tendulkar and Adam Gilchrist whenever they entered or exited a ground. The heartwarming events can be forgotten easily in the emotional haze generated by the heat between the teams. India host Australia in October and an eight-month break might not be long enough.

Peter English is the Australasia editor of Cricinfo

RSS Feeds: Peter English

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by dcrowle on (March 9, 2008, 22:34 GMT)

This 'ungracious celebrations' thing has to be put to bed too. Australia won a close game in Sydney and went nuts. I noticed the Indians did a startingly similar (more imitation?) thing afte rthe second CB final while James Hopes was almost in tears on the pitch without an Indian handshake in sight. You win the close ones, of course you celebrate...

Posted by Thirumalai on (March 9, 2008, 19:06 GMT)

Peter, Your article is nothing but a case of "Kettle calling the Pot black". I am no great fan of Harbajan Singh when it comes to his antics on the field but one must think hard as to why players behave the way they behave only in Australia. Its a simple case of offence being the best form of defence. Whenever there is onfield misbehaviour between teams, Sledging on the field why is it that Australians are common denominators. India or for that matter no Team has complained of "ungentlemanly" behaviour nor have any team indulged in such behaviour while playing in England, South Africa or any other "White" country not even while playing in the other Down Under country the NZ. Even between so called arch rivals that is India & Pakistan the matches are held in a very cordial environment.I think Oz has to start behaving themselves if they have to be welcomed in other countries. In fact in my opinion India should Ban them from entering in October 2008.

Posted by IsDon on (March 9, 2008, 18:56 GMT)

Fantastic summer of contests, yes contests, not boring massacres of inferior opposition as has been the norm most other summers.Finally a team challenegs the Aussies and unfortunately they did not handle it at all well. Always adopting the moral high ground, the Aussies, or some of them at least, were found wanting in the integrity department. I refer in particular to the annointed future captain ,Michael Clarke. In 2 separate examples of his dishonesty were shown for all to see. He claimed a catch in Sydney which clearly bounced in front of him and then he edges to first slip, one of the most obvious dismissals of the summer, akin to stumps cartwheeling out of the ground, yet he stands his ground and makes the umpire give him out! This man is not worthy of the Aussie captaincy, not now and not ever. Forget about bringing 'weak' opposition to Australia to be served up on a platter so the Aussies can inflate their batting averages. Just bring India out here every year.

Posted by tgevans on (March 9, 2008, 18:21 GMT)

This article is delusional and unprofessional. First, Harbhajan's behavior was unpalatable but it would've been horrible if he'd been charged with racism based on thoroughly flimsy evidence. What evidence there is actually points at entrapment. Second, there is a big difference between losing your composure on the field, particularly when batting, and keeping up the abuse off the field. Third, there is a difference between appealing for an LBW when you think there is a possible pad-bat, where the umpire can exercise good judgement, and systematically exploiting umpiring bias in the worst way possible. The latter is cheating. Raising untenable moral equivalences is poor logic and shabby journalism. In the end, the Australian team were both sore winners and sore losers, and I can well understand why we're seeing this sort of defeatist rhetoric.

Posted by Dom23 on (March 9, 2008, 16:49 GMT)

I am an Australian who is embarrassed that our current cricket team (irreparably arrogant and boorish)is a reflection of the culture I live in.sport reflects life and from the top down,Ponting,Hayden,Clarke and symonds in particular reflect bad attitudes and behaviours that are accepted and at times glorified in Australian society (selfishness,one-upmanship,egotism,intolerance).I think many Australians are racist but Im unconvinced this is the underlying motivation of these men. Rather, they have demonstrated classic Australian alpha-male responses to being challenged by a worthy,competent and at times antagonistic(and at times better) opponent (India)who themselves seemed to lack integrity in some of there behaviours (I stop short of judging a culture Ive never lived in and hence may misrepresent). This Aussie team's lack of insight is staggering and motivates me to distance myself from their behaviour and reputation when I return to English cricket pitches later this year.

Posted by vkrg on (March 9, 2008, 16:14 GMT)

Sutherland's comments today stating "provocative comments in public should not have personal abuse" is funny. Looks like a brazen attempt, to keep the door of legitamacy open for Aussie team to indulge in "mental disintegration".

Posted by vinal on (March 9, 2008, 15:44 GMT)

Peter, you overlooked an observation... Take sledging out of aussies and they lose! It was evident in both the finals after they were gagged and told to behave themselves that they bacame mortals.

Posted by vkrg on (March 9, 2008, 15:43 GMT)

This article: A one-sided view, with an attempt to camaflouge it as a two-sided view. It was bad to support allegations against BCCI and India, without any proof. It is not as if people actually heard someone in BCCI chartering a plane, and everything is based on hearsay. Like I said, I think Aus players, public, and media need to give some respect to the concept of "decent behaviour" and to be gracious losers&hosts.

Posted by JasontheBray on (March 9, 2008, 11:50 GMT)

When India won that last one day game in Brisbane i thought "thank god that summer is over!" I don't care who is right or wrong any more or even who wins or loses. All I know is that journalists in Aust (and probably all over the world) have feasted like vultures on this summer and the cricketers have been stupid enough to give them plenty of meat on the bone. No longer can it be said what happens on the field stays on the field. The field is everywhere. Time for the football season to start where you can deck players legitimately whether they are naked of not.

Posted by sarfrazhaan on (March 9, 2008, 7:12 GMT)

Fair for everyone, Australians, Indians, Sri Lankans, even minnows like Namibia will be happy to settle on it. If an Australian calls Harbhajan a weed, the weed must have a right to sue the Australian for giving it a bad name. The way Harbhajan behaves on the field, is no joy to watch, but the foul-mouthing Aussies are no pretty sight.

Peter, start accepting the greetings from India in the same vein as you send. There is a huge possibility that the ICC will lose its hold over the game if it continues to function the way it has been till now. It knows what its been upto till now and if does not mends it ways, the IPLs and ICLs will be enough to wipe it out. Mind you, its not a threat, but a real possibility!

Are there other lessons the two teams must learn from the tour?
Comments have now been closed for this article

FeedbackTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Peter EnglishClose

Walking up the down escalator

2014 in review: Player strikes, defeats against fellow minnows, and mountains of debt for the board marked another grim year for Zimbabwe

    The first Boxing Day classic

Ashley Mallett: Nearly 150 years ago, the MCG saw the start of a much-loved tradition, with a match starring Aboriginal players

Hangovers and headaches

2014 in review: Embarrassing defeats, a beleaguered captain, a bitter former star, alienating administrators - England's year was gloomy. By George Dobell

Ten years later

Gallery: Efforts by Surrey have helped transform a coastal village in Sri Lanka devastated by the December 26 tsunami

Going for glory and falling just short

Anantha Narayanan: An anecdotal account of close finishes similar to the recent Adelaide Test

News | Features Last 7 days

Watson's merry-go-round decade

In January 2005, Shane Watson made his Test debut. What does he have to show for a decade in the game?

Power to Smithy, trouble for Dhoni

Australia's new captain admirably turned things around for his side in Brisbane, leading in more departments than one

Why punish the West Indies players when the administration is to blame?

As ever, the West Indies board has taken the short-term view and removed supposedly troublesome players instead of recognising its own incompetence

Gilchrist's conscientious moment

In the semi-final against Sri Lanka in 2003, Adam Gilchrist walked back to the pavilion despite being given not out by the on-field umpire

Australia's 50-50 lifelines

Three Australia players made half-centuries on day one at the MCG; for each of them, the innings' meant different things

News | Features Last 7 days