August 15, 2009

Smells like a trade-off

The GCB and the South African board may have kissed and made up, but quite a few questions remain unanswered

Jo'burg thunderstorms shimmer and shake with a brand of violence that is brutal and beautiful in equal measure. Cricket lovers here are all too well acquainted with the pyrotechnics, which are a summer phenomenon. But an unseasonal storm of a more vicious nature erupted over the Wanderers this winter. It rent not the sky but the game itself day and night for several weeks in the form of a dispute between Cricket South Africa (CSA) and the Gauteng Cricket Board (GCB).

At issue were the GCB's allegations of CSA's mismanagement in the country's hosting of the Indian Premier League (IPL) this year. Apologise, or you won't host England this summer, said CSA. Not a damn, came the GCB's retort.

The acrimony flew back and forth like windblown gunsmoke, until mediators were appointed to try and resolve the issue. It was, this week, and the Wanderers now has its lucrative England fixtures back. "Sanity has prevailed," was the tone of much of the reaction among Johannesburg's chattering classes. But has it?

"We felt as if we had lost control of our stadium and we wanted it back," was how GCB president Barry Skjoldhammer summed up his organisation's grievances in a radio interview.

The IPL certainly did swagger through the country like a padded-up porn star. Trouble is, the men who control the GCB have cast themselves in that role since the days of the Mean Machine, the Transvaal team that swept all before it in the 1970s and 80s. Not surprisingly, they took none too well to the younger, sexier kid strutting on their block. But public opinion was firmly on the side of the GCB during the impasse. Take the England tour away from Jo'burg - who the hell did CSA think they were? In Johannesburg, unlike elsewhere, arrogance is admired.

"People inside cricket know that the people who run the GCB aren't very nice, but people outside cricket don't know that," a CSA official said.

With few exceptions, the Johannesburg media threw their weight behind the GCB. This could be because they were forced to reflect their consumers' concerns. Perish the thought that it's because reporters are welcome to drink free of charge in the Long Room bar at the Wanderers. The stadium also serves perhaps the most sumptuous press-box lunch in the country.

The controversy took on racial undertones. CSA is a product of democratic South Africa, and as such is a black-led, black-run organisation. The loudest voices in the GCB are white and hark back to the apartheid era. Those facts stood out like a swastika tattoo on a sun-starved forehead when the GCB was forced to fight on a second front by a group of black clubs, the Concerned Cricket Fraternity (CCF), which highlighted the province's woeful record of producing and contracting quality black players.

The IPL certainly did swagger through the country like a padded-up porn star. Trouble is, the men who control the GCB have cast themselves in that role since the days of the Mean Machine, the Transvaal team that swept all before it in the 1970s and 80s

From a broader perspective, the Wanderers itself stands tall and imposing in one of Johannesburg's most affluent areas. It is a concrete symbol of how little South African cricket has really changed since racial segregation was ended. Sadly, CSA missed a gilt-edged opportunity to take cricket to the masses when it declared the Wanderers stadium-non-grata. Why are South Africans who want to watch international cricket compelled to go to the same arenas that were once graced by all-white teams representing the apartheid state? Almost without exception, these venues are located firmly in what used to be whites-only areas. For most black South Africans, a trip to the cricket remains a journey to another world. Test matches and one-day internationals are played in far from grand arenas in other parts of the world. Why not a Test match in Soweto?

The GCB tried to keep the IPL and transformation issues separate, and the theory surfaced in pro-GCB quarters that the latter was a smokescreen thrown up by CSA.

Why did the CCF put the boot in when it did? The only valid answer to that question is another: why has the GCB not made meaningful progress on the transformation front for 15 years? If the issues were indeed separate, why was the news that the GCB had agreed to redraft a flawed constitution that gave disproportionate power to Premier League clubs - which tend to be historically white - and adopt a transformation charter made public at the press conference called to announce that England would play at the Wanderers? The smell of a trade-off was too pungent to ignore.

It wasn't the only compromise in this saga. The Wanderers' return to the roster was preceded by a teleconference involving the stakeholders in South African cricket. "We needed everybody's buy-in, including those provinces who had been awarded matches when the fixtures were changed," said a CSA source. "The guys in Port Elizabeth [which was to have hosted the Test scheduled for Johannesburg] didn't kick up too much of a fuss, but Bloemfontein [which had an ODI fall into its lap and then back out] wasn't happy. They're crying out for international cricket there, and we had to make promises for the future."

Let's hope that's a future based on tolerance. Any offenders should be pointed in the direction of a particular Rolling Stones album, Let It Bleed. Specifically side two, track nine. It's called "You Can't Always Get What You Want."

Telford Vice is a freelance cricket writer in South Africa

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Mr.Hobbs on August 18, 2009, 8:23 GMT

    Hmmm, I thought that this is was cricket website, not a site to vent personal political issues (again). I agree with Mr. Vice on one thing. Having read the "article" something sure smells!

    Couple of facts: Diepsloot, a black township, is no more than 10 minutes taxi drive away from Wanderers, so too is Thembisa, Alexandra, Olievenhoutsbosh and Jhb CBD. Between them they house a couple of million black people. To use Soweto, which doesn't have a stadium, as the only shining example is therefore misleading.

    Secondly, Mr. Vice, all the international stadia in SA are in previously white areas and on all the fields white teams played during apartheid. Please suggest alternative venues where CSA can host the upcoming England tour. Ill throw in 10 lawn chairs if that will assist.

  • edgedfor4 on August 17, 2009, 13:58 GMT

    After reading Gary Boshoff on the news24.com playing the race card in his article and now coming on here to read about your over inflated ideas. As South African journalists you are actually slowing down transformation - please tell me how your ideas and your articles are at all helping to promote any good done in South African cricket. Your previous article on 2 June 2009 who's talking about colour now, is a prime example of feeding the pessimists the fodder they need. I am not saying that Cricket in South Africa is perfect but there must be some real genuine stories of hope that you could bring to the table as I think all to often the race card is played and quite frankly not all of us see colour and some of us want a side made up of players of all colours from SA and are quite frankly really bored of reading about the racial divides!!!! Give us some good news like how we have come so far as the most diverse team across the globe and world beaters in all formats of the game

  • SaveCricketSupport2020 on August 16, 2009, 21:07 GMT

    This "padded-up porn star" has been donating REAL money across schools in ZA, but of course mentioning that fact does not go well with the author's story / motive, whatevere that might be. . . .

  • amp64 on August 15, 2009, 10:14 GMT

    Another Vice article low on hard fact and high on speculation. It would be good to be informed of interesting new facts, rather than the author's sketchy opinions.

  • VishyKnight on August 15, 2009, 9:11 GMT

    Interesting article. Looking at it as a standalone issue related to the IPL matches, to me, as an outside neutral observer, it looked like the CSA was trying to bully GCB by demanding an apology for GCB criticizing CSA officials in an internal draft report and threatening to withhold future international matches. I feel that healthy criticism should be welcome and the CSA should encourage it rather than armtwisting people who criticize it. If it employs armtwisting techniques, it would only result in more 'Yes-Men' around, and real issues would be swept below the carpet. In the present case it seems the organization of the IPL did pose issues to the GCB and the CSA should analyse the issues rather than sweep them below the carpet. The CSA should learn more from the ECB (England Cricket Board) in encouraging democracy within its affliliated units rather than go the way of the ZCB (Zimbabwe Cricket Board). Bullying is easy. Democracy is hardwork.

  • akc5247 on August 15, 2009, 5:55 GMT

    Beautiful article. Never can we tell if the IPL has been a boon or a bane; Looks like it's a catch-22. Not many of us here (via Cricinfo) have heard about Soweto. It'd be good if there is more info about that, and the feasibilty of cricket facilities there.

  • Mr.Hobbs on August 18, 2009, 8:23 GMT

    Hmmm, I thought that this is was cricket website, not a site to vent personal political issues (again). I agree with Mr. Vice on one thing. Having read the "article" something sure smells!

    Couple of facts: Diepsloot, a black township, is no more than 10 minutes taxi drive away from Wanderers, so too is Thembisa, Alexandra, Olievenhoutsbosh and Jhb CBD. Between them they house a couple of million black people. To use Soweto, which doesn't have a stadium, as the only shining example is therefore misleading.

    Secondly, Mr. Vice, all the international stadia in SA are in previously white areas and on all the fields white teams played during apartheid. Please suggest alternative venues where CSA can host the upcoming England tour. Ill throw in 10 lawn chairs if that will assist.

  • edgedfor4 on August 17, 2009, 13:58 GMT

    After reading Gary Boshoff on the news24.com playing the race card in his article and now coming on here to read about your over inflated ideas. As South African journalists you are actually slowing down transformation - please tell me how your ideas and your articles are at all helping to promote any good done in South African cricket. Your previous article on 2 June 2009 who's talking about colour now, is a prime example of feeding the pessimists the fodder they need. I am not saying that Cricket in South Africa is perfect but there must be some real genuine stories of hope that you could bring to the table as I think all to often the race card is played and quite frankly not all of us see colour and some of us want a side made up of players of all colours from SA and are quite frankly really bored of reading about the racial divides!!!! Give us some good news like how we have come so far as the most diverse team across the globe and world beaters in all formats of the game

  • SaveCricketSupport2020 on August 16, 2009, 21:07 GMT

    This "padded-up porn star" has been donating REAL money across schools in ZA, but of course mentioning that fact does not go well with the author's story / motive, whatevere that might be. . . .

  • amp64 on August 15, 2009, 10:14 GMT

    Another Vice article low on hard fact and high on speculation. It would be good to be informed of interesting new facts, rather than the author's sketchy opinions.

  • VishyKnight on August 15, 2009, 9:11 GMT

    Interesting article. Looking at it as a standalone issue related to the IPL matches, to me, as an outside neutral observer, it looked like the CSA was trying to bully GCB by demanding an apology for GCB criticizing CSA officials in an internal draft report and threatening to withhold future international matches. I feel that healthy criticism should be welcome and the CSA should encourage it rather than armtwisting people who criticize it. If it employs armtwisting techniques, it would only result in more 'Yes-Men' around, and real issues would be swept below the carpet. In the present case it seems the organization of the IPL did pose issues to the GCB and the CSA should analyse the issues rather than sweep them below the carpet. The CSA should learn more from the ECB (England Cricket Board) in encouraging democracy within its affliliated units rather than go the way of the ZCB (Zimbabwe Cricket Board). Bullying is easy. Democracy is hardwork.

  • akc5247 on August 15, 2009, 5:55 GMT

    Beautiful article. Never can we tell if the IPL has been a boon or a bane; Looks like it's a catch-22. Not many of us here (via Cricinfo) have heard about Soweto. It'd be good if there is more info about that, and the feasibilty of cricket facilities there.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • akc5247 on August 15, 2009, 5:55 GMT

    Beautiful article. Never can we tell if the IPL has been a boon or a bane; Looks like it's a catch-22. Not many of us here (via Cricinfo) have heard about Soweto. It'd be good if there is more info about that, and the feasibilty of cricket facilities there.

  • VishyKnight on August 15, 2009, 9:11 GMT

    Interesting article. Looking at it as a standalone issue related to the IPL matches, to me, as an outside neutral observer, it looked like the CSA was trying to bully GCB by demanding an apology for GCB criticizing CSA officials in an internal draft report and threatening to withhold future international matches. I feel that healthy criticism should be welcome and the CSA should encourage it rather than armtwisting people who criticize it. If it employs armtwisting techniques, it would only result in more 'Yes-Men' around, and real issues would be swept below the carpet. In the present case it seems the organization of the IPL did pose issues to the GCB and the CSA should analyse the issues rather than sweep them below the carpet. The CSA should learn more from the ECB (England Cricket Board) in encouraging democracy within its affliliated units rather than go the way of the ZCB (Zimbabwe Cricket Board). Bullying is easy. Democracy is hardwork.

  • amp64 on August 15, 2009, 10:14 GMT

    Another Vice article low on hard fact and high on speculation. It would be good to be informed of interesting new facts, rather than the author's sketchy opinions.

  • SaveCricketSupport2020 on August 16, 2009, 21:07 GMT

    This "padded-up porn star" has been donating REAL money across schools in ZA, but of course mentioning that fact does not go well with the author's story / motive, whatevere that might be. . . .

  • edgedfor4 on August 17, 2009, 13:58 GMT

    After reading Gary Boshoff on the news24.com playing the race card in his article and now coming on here to read about your over inflated ideas. As South African journalists you are actually slowing down transformation - please tell me how your ideas and your articles are at all helping to promote any good done in South African cricket. Your previous article on 2 June 2009 who's talking about colour now, is a prime example of feeding the pessimists the fodder they need. I am not saying that Cricket in South Africa is perfect but there must be some real genuine stories of hope that you could bring to the table as I think all to often the race card is played and quite frankly not all of us see colour and some of us want a side made up of players of all colours from SA and are quite frankly really bored of reading about the racial divides!!!! Give us some good news like how we have come so far as the most diverse team across the globe and world beaters in all formats of the game

  • Mr.Hobbs on August 18, 2009, 8:23 GMT

    Hmmm, I thought that this is was cricket website, not a site to vent personal political issues (again). I agree with Mr. Vice on one thing. Having read the "article" something sure smells!

    Couple of facts: Diepsloot, a black township, is no more than 10 minutes taxi drive away from Wanderers, so too is Thembisa, Alexandra, Olievenhoutsbosh and Jhb CBD. Between them they house a couple of million black people. To use Soweto, which doesn't have a stadium, as the only shining example is therefore misleading.

    Secondly, Mr. Vice, all the international stadia in SA are in previously white areas and on all the fields white teams played during apartheid. Please suggest alternative venues where CSA can host the upcoming England tour. Ill throw in 10 lawn chairs if that will assist.