Kaneria wants an open appeal

Alan Gardner

June 26, 2012

Text size: A | A

Danish Kaneria with his lawyer Steve Haurigan, Karachi, January 8, 2010
Steven Hourigan, lawyer for Danish Kaneria, has accused the ECB of reaching a "pre-determined" verdict about the guilt of his client © AFP

The lawyer acting for the Pakistan bowler, Danish Kaneria, has called for his appeal against a life ban from cricket imposed by the ECB to take the form of an open hearing on the grounds that it increases the prospect of a fair trial.

Kaneria was last week found guilty on two charges of corruption with relation to the Mervyn Westfield spot-fixing case but denies any involvement, claiming instead that he has been made a scapegoat.

Kaneria faces the end of his career in cricket if the ban is upheld. He is allowed a 14-day window from the point of receiving the ECB's final judgement in which to lodge an appeal - something he has already indicated that he will do.

Steven Hourigan, who represented Kaneria at the ECB tribunal, described the outcome of the five-day hearing as "pre-determined". Westfield provided testimony against his former Essex team-mate but Kaneria's legal team contend that the legspinner was not given a fair hearing. They also indicated that a further legal appeal - potentially to the Court of Arbitration for Sport - could be pursued in order to clear Kaneria's name.

"We've got nothing to hide about this. It's not sour grapes that we lost a fair hearing," Hourigan said. "We lost a hearing where it was pre-determined what the result was going to be. We're going to have an appeal. What we want is an independent observer to sit in and listen to the evidence. What we want is a fair hearing in front of an independent panel. We would want the press to sit in on the appeal and hear every word."

The ECB disciplinary panel, consisting of Gerard Elias QC, David Gabbitass and the former England allrounder Jamie Dalrymple, was critical of Kaneria in its judgement on the case, delivered on Friday. In the written summary of their findings they also concluded that Westfield, despite inconsistencies in his evidence, "was plainly telling the truth".

When contacted about the request for an open hearing, the ECB said that it would not be making any comment until an official appeal had been lodged.

Kaneria, who is Pakistan's fourth-highest wicket-taker in Tests, has previously called the verdict against him "unfair", based on Westfield's word against his, and Hourigan suggested that it was in the ECB's interests to pin the blame on someone from outside the domestic game in England.

"It's been suggested that what the ECB wanted to do and needed to do was, in order to present English cricket as being clean, that this one incident of corruption was caused by a foreign player coming to the UK and corrupting a young, English player," he said. "The fact Danish was an outsider and from Pakistan is easily believed and therefore he must be corrupt. If we'd had a fair hearing, that wouldn't have been the result."

Kaneria maintained that the case against him was motivated by Westfield's desire to minimise his own involvement in fixing. Westfield, who received a four-month prison sentence after pleading guilty to spot-fixing charges earlier this year, was given a five-year ban from cricket, though he will be able to resume playing club cricket after three years.

"He wanted to reduce his sentence." Kaneria said. "He's ruining my career to reduce his sentence."

Hourigan said: "Westfield picked on Danish because he was an easy target. Because he was an outside in the team, he's not a local player, because he comes from Pakistan it's easy to assume he must know about corruption."

Alan Gardner is an assistant editor at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: Alan Gardner

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Email Feedback Print
Alan GardnerClose
Country Fixtures Country Results
1st Test: Australia v Pakistan at Dubai (DSC) - Oct 22-26
Pakistan 454 & 286/2d Australia 303 & 59/4
Group II: Falcons v State B of P at Abbottabad - Oct 24-27
Falcons 219 State B of P 213/6
Group II: Wolves v Habib Bank at Faisalabad - Oct 24-27
Habib Bank 332 Wolves 166 & 10/1 (f/o)
Leopards v National Bnk at Islamabad - Oct 24-27
National Bnk 96/3
K Dolphins v ZTBL at Karachi - Oct 24-27
K Dolphins 222 & 217/2 ZTBL 118
Group I: Zebras v Khan RL at Karachi - Oct 24-27
Zebras 83 & 175/3 Khan RL 268
Group I: L Eagles v PIA at Lahore - Oct 24-27
L Eagles 206 PIA 239/9
Lahore Lions v Sui Gas at Lahore - Oct 24-27
Lahore Lions 232 Sui Gas 318/5
Tigers v WAPDA at Multan - Oct 24-27
WAPDA 185 Tigers 279/9
P Panthers v United Bank at Peshawar - Oct 24-27
P Panthers 98 United Bank 315/5
Group I: Quetta Bears v Pakistan TV at Islamabad - Oct 24-27
Quetta Bears 194 Pakistan TV 88/2
R Rams v Port Qasim A at Rawalpindi
Oct 24-27, 2014 (10:00 local | 05:00 GMT | 01:00 EDT | 00:00 CDT | 22:00 PDT)
Group II: S Stallions v Sui Sthn Gas at Sialkot - Oct 24-27
Sui Sthn Gas 210 & 261/3 S Stallions 81
3rd unofficial ODI: U.A.E. v Pakistan A at Dubai (CA) - Oct 25
Pakistan A won by 54 runs
Complete fixtures » | Download Fixtures »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days