Indian Premier League January 7, 2011

Franchises unhappy over uncapped player rules

20

As the IPL gears up for the mammoth two-day auction over the weekend, there are rumblings of dissatisfaction among five of its franchises regarding the rules governing players who will not be part of the auction - the "uncapped" Indians, who form the base of any IPL squad. The problem stems from a rule change in December that, the franchises believe, has tilted the balance in favour of the wealthier and influential teams in the competition, a charge the IPL denies.

The players who come under this rule include Manish Pandey, the IPL's first Indian centurion, former India under-19 captain Ambati Rayadu and Ranji Trophy performers Sidharth Trivedi, Abhishek Jhunjhunwala and R Satish.

In September 2010, it was decided that domestic players who had played 75% of their teams' matches in IPL 3 would be part of the auction, along with their senior colleagues and overseas players. In November, however, the IPL governing council received a list of suggestions from Mumbai Indians, which included the contentious issue of retaining uncapped players and not putting them in the auction. It was confirmed by an IPL governing council member that, after some deliberation, the league had finally altered the original conditions set for uncapped players and, following a council meeting, formally changed the rule in December. The new rule removed uncapped players from the auction and allowed franchises to sign players of their choice through a three-way agreement involving player, franchise and the IPL. In late December, franchises were instructed to not approach the uncapped players until notified to do so by the Board.

The issue has raised the alarm among some franchises who, in mails to the IPL, said they believed the new rules would leave the uncapped player 'market' open to under-the-table deals. "It is a simple problem, the quality of uncapped domestic players is limited," a franchise insider said, "these are rules that are just encouraging illegality."

The squad rules state that franchises can sign a minimum of 20 Indians and no more than 10 foreign players. That's 200 Indian players who need to be on board. The auction list features only 48 Indians while seven others have been retained by their franchises, leaving 145 players who have to be signed up by the franchises from the list of uncapped players. That's what sparked fear among some franchises, who believe players like Pandey and Rayudu will be most sought after and thus open to being offered unofficial 'perks' of signing up with a particular franchise.

In their mails seeking a change in the rules about uncapped India players, the franchises had offered the IPL several solutions: to either put the uncapped players into the auction (with the excess amount outside their salary slab being given to the BCCI) or to have franchises make a bid for them and draw lots to decide who gets the most sought-after player or restrict the players to their catchment areas. All options were turned down.

The system is fair, BCCI president Shashank Manohar told ESPNcricinfo. "Those [uncapped] players can only be taken after the auction. Before the auction nobody can enter an agreement with the uncapped players. It will have to be a tripartite agreement between the player, the franchise and the board."

The decision to keep the cricketers who had not represented India out of the auction was, Manohar said, logistical given the large numbers involved. "We can't put all the uncapped players in the auction because that would mean having more than 1000 players in the auction". The most sought after players Manohar said, "can be approached by everyone."

Manohar, whose term as BCCI chief ends in September 2011 after which N Srinivasan - the owner of the Chennai franchise - will take over, said the unbalanced supply-demand equation among the uncapped players was not an issue. "There would be seven to eight capped players in every team, and the balance remaining is 10-11 players. So that is how it would work. According to me, nobody would pay huge amounts to uncapped players. Which capped player would be paid a large sum? Everyone is a capped player ... Saurabh Tiwary, Cheteshwar Pujara, they are also capped players. Even Abhishek Nayar has become a capped player."

The IPL chief executive, Sundar Raman, told ESPNcricinfo that the argument that it was only the wealthier clubs who would be able to promise more and that too outside the system was, "not valid." Raman said, "All uncapped players have been out of the auction even in the past. They get a fixed fee of Rs 30, 20 or 10 lakhs and the contract process is managed by BCCI."

The system, Manohar said, could not benefit any franchise on the basis of either money or influence. "Finally it depends on how much money you have at the end of the auction. Mumbai and Chennai have lost half their purse due to the retention rule. At the bidding process they are going to face problems. Because a total of $9m is for everyone, capped, uncapped, everyone." The pressures on players from the bigger franchises would mean little he said, "because likewise others can also approach them." He said the BCCI would look into any complaints about illegality in the signing process.

Members of the franchises who had protested about the auction rules were not willing to speak on record, while others like Kochi, Kings XI Punjab and Rajasthan Royals had spent the last few months caught in legal disputes with the BCCI. A King's XI Punjab spokesman told EPSNcricinfo said his team had not raised the issue of uncapped players because, "we did not belong in the IPL at the time. Right now we are happy to live with whatever is there. We cannot possibly comment on who can or who can't be in the auction." He also confirmed that the franchise had paid up all their dues to their players.

Sharda Ugra is senior editor at Cricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Abhimanyu on January 10, 2011, 21:51 GMT

    All the credit should go to Ambanis for using their power and money to influence BCCI into making this very unfair rule for the Indian uncapped players. I use to support MI but now I don't after finding reading this article.

  • on January 9, 2011, 11:38 GMT

    Need to include manish,ambati rayudu in auction,even though they are uncapped!

  • on January 8, 2011, 12:33 GMT

    @batbhai- try webcric.com, they normally show international matches, but im not sure about domestic ones.

  • on January 8, 2011, 6:36 GMT

    yea a draft...and we could have 6 or 7 rounds like the NFL... its better the higher you get drafted the more u get paid....

  • batbhai on January 8, 2011, 5:05 GMT

    Hi everybody! I am excited about the IPL-4 auction. As I don't have access to TV, can anybody inform me how can I watch it live in internet.

    Thanking you.

  • on January 7, 2011, 22:01 GMT

    Why not just a have draft lottery like NBA, NHL, NFL in USA? Worst team gets the 1st pick and champions get the last pick.

  • gr8ravi on January 7, 2011, 20:14 GMT

    @aqua leo, IPL is business cum entertainment cum Cricket, so they always thinks about their profit than the Country, The Indian Player think twice and thrice to play for Team India's all Matches but they never thinks so quitting these IPL matches bcoz they earn more than what they earn from Playing for Team India. Prime example is Our so called Captain MSD, he wants Leave/Rest from Playing for India and as I'm not forgetting he plays all the matches for CSK in all 3 previous Editions[I know he was/is the Captain of the Team as he is the same for Team India]

  • vinodnevgi on January 7, 2011, 19:28 GMT

    well all said & done ..All the Indian audience are all left confused at the moment and the only reason being the current IPL4 auction list features only India capped & India discarded players, where as on the other hand uncapped players from all the other countries are being drafted ....The IPL was started with the motive to promote Indian Players from all levels and were promised a dream to be given a better platform...what happened to players coming from smaller states in India and others ....i hope as audience are not fooled emotionally

    --

  • Dhrumil_17 on January 7, 2011, 15:58 GMT

    Will cricinfo provide live updates on the ipl auction? what time will the auction start in india and on cricinfo? and does any one know if we can watch live auction on tv channels? thank you in advance

  • indianzen on January 7, 2011, 14:01 GMT

    Give a severe warning and bring back Modi...

  • Abhimanyu on January 10, 2011, 21:51 GMT

    All the credit should go to Ambanis for using their power and money to influence BCCI into making this very unfair rule for the Indian uncapped players. I use to support MI but now I don't after finding reading this article.

  • on January 9, 2011, 11:38 GMT

    Need to include manish,ambati rayudu in auction,even though they are uncapped!

  • on January 8, 2011, 12:33 GMT

    @batbhai- try webcric.com, they normally show international matches, but im not sure about domestic ones.

  • on January 8, 2011, 6:36 GMT

    yea a draft...and we could have 6 or 7 rounds like the NFL... its better the higher you get drafted the more u get paid....

  • batbhai on January 8, 2011, 5:05 GMT

    Hi everybody! I am excited about the IPL-4 auction. As I don't have access to TV, can anybody inform me how can I watch it live in internet.

    Thanking you.

  • on January 7, 2011, 22:01 GMT

    Why not just a have draft lottery like NBA, NHL, NFL in USA? Worst team gets the 1st pick and champions get the last pick.

  • gr8ravi on January 7, 2011, 20:14 GMT

    @aqua leo, IPL is business cum entertainment cum Cricket, so they always thinks about their profit than the Country, The Indian Player think twice and thrice to play for Team India's all Matches but they never thinks so quitting these IPL matches bcoz they earn more than what they earn from Playing for Team India. Prime example is Our so called Captain MSD, he wants Leave/Rest from Playing for India and as I'm not forgetting he plays all the matches for CSK in all 3 previous Editions[I know he was/is the Captain of the Team as he is the same for Team India]

  • vinodnevgi on January 7, 2011, 19:28 GMT

    well all said & done ..All the Indian audience are all left confused at the moment and the only reason being the current IPL4 auction list features only India capped & India discarded players, where as on the other hand uncapped players from all the other countries are being drafted ....The IPL was started with the motive to promote Indian Players from all levels and were promised a dream to be given a better platform...what happened to players coming from smaller states in India and others ....i hope as audience are not fooled emotionally

    --

  • Dhrumil_17 on January 7, 2011, 15:58 GMT

    Will cricinfo provide live updates on the ipl auction? what time will the auction start in india and on cricinfo? and does any one know if we can watch live auction on tv channels? thank you in advance

  • indianzen on January 7, 2011, 14:01 GMT

    Give a severe warning and bring back Modi...

  • on January 7, 2011, 12:47 GMT

    Auction starts at 10 am indian time tommorow

  • chilkan on January 7, 2011, 12:30 GMT

    @Aaroncricket: I just saw a press note that SETMAX a sports Channel in India is telecasting live... Not sure if NZ has access to the channel

  • on January 7, 2011, 12:12 GMT

    The auction starts at 10 AM IST, saturday the 8th of January 2011.

  • on January 7, 2011, 12:11 GMT

    i reallly dont care i want good players playing and good cricket played

  • pozx on January 7, 2011, 11:48 GMT

    Whatever the franchises say about under table deals, they forget that auction will not be held every 3 years. this time it happened only because two new teams are being added. after this year the transfer window will open in January and every one can lure anyone. So if they are afraid of under table deals then they can only be competitive for max one year, cause after this the rich teams will again buy their players, whether under table or upper table.

  • givemefood on January 7, 2011, 11:38 GMT

    ... and the ridiculous rules of IPL continues. Ever since they trounced the founder, it has only gotten worse. I wonder if IPL4 will be a set of games or a circus show.

  • Aaroncricket on January 7, 2011, 10:40 GMT

    Can someone please tell me what time in India the auction begins on Saturday and what the format for it is? I'm in New Zealand and want to follow it from here but don't know the time. Is Cricinfo going to be providing live updates? Thanks for your help.

  • on January 7, 2011, 9:06 GMT

    I wish IPL will change it format, Instead of playing all the matches in a cramped schedule, instead why can't we have matches only on weekend, one on friday and two each on saturday and sunday and teams can field the best possible players available for the matches and we can see lot of uncapped domestic and foreign players in the matches and the capped players can fulfill their national commitments and when they are free can represent their respective franchies.

  • on January 7, 2011, 7:31 GMT

    I never understood the rule that the excess amount a team bids for a player (outside their salary slab) being given to the BCCI. Like Pollard - i believe the cap is 750k, but he was 'bought' for 2.25 Mn or some such. Why did the excess money go to the BCCI? Shouldnt the franchises be paying the player for his talent? And as for tilting the balance in favour of the wealthier and influential teams in the competition - If you can;t afford to be competitive int he IPL, you shouldnt be in it. Lets face it - this is a business. Everyone is in it with a profit motive. Imagine if one company wanted a law saying that the other company can't use its wealth to build infrastructure for its business. Preposterous!

  • jammyisgreat on January 7, 2011, 6:51 GMT

    Hope pandey remains with RCB.. thats where he belong..thats where we his fans wants him to be...

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • jammyisgreat on January 7, 2011, 6:51 GMT

    Hope pandey remains with RCB.. thats where he belong..thats where we his fans wants him to be...

  • on January 7, 2011, 7:31 GMT

    I never understood the rule that the excess amount a team bids for a player (outside their salary slab) being given to the BCCI. Like Pollard - i believe the cap is 750k, but he was 'bought' for 2.25 Mn or some such. Why did the excess money go to the BCCI? Shouldnt the franchises be paying the player for his talent? And as for tilting the balance in favour of the wealthier and influential teams in the competition - If you can;t afford to be competitive int he IPL, you shouldnt be in it. Lets face it - this is a business. Everyone is in it with a profit motive. Imagine if one company wanted a law saying that the other company can't use its wealth to build infrastructure for its business. Preposterous!

  • on January 7, 2011, 9:06 GMT

    I wish IPL will change it format, Instead of playing all the matches in a cramped schedule, instead why can't we have matches only on weekend, one on friday and two each on saturday and sunday and teams can field the best possible players available for the matches and we can see lot of uncapped domestic and foreign players in the matches and the capped players can fulfill their national commitments and when they are free can represent their respective franchies.

  • Aaroncricket on January 7, 2011, 10:40 GMT

    Can someone please tell me what time in India the auction begins on Saturday and what the format for it is? I'm in New Zealand and want to follow it from here but don't know the time. Is Cricinfo going to be providing live updates? Thanks for your help.

  • givemefood on January 7, 2011, 11:38 GMT

    ... and the ridiculous rules of IPL continues. Ever since they trounced the founder, it has only gotten worse. I wonder if IPL4 will be a set of games or a circus show.

  • pozx on January 7, 2011, 11:48 GMT

    Whatever the franchises say about under table deals, they forget that auction will not be held every 3 years. this time it happened only because two new teams are being added. after this year the transfer window will open in January and every one can lure anyone. So if they are afraid of under table deals then they can only be competitive for max one year, cause after this the rich teams will again buy their players, whether under table or upper table.

  • on January 7, 2011, 12:11 GMT

    i reallly dont care i want good players playing and good cricket played

  • on January 7, 2011, 12:12 GMT

    The auction starts at 10 AM IST, saturday the 8th of January 2011.

  • chilkan on January 7, 2011, 12:30 GMT

    @Aaroncricket: I just saw a press note that SETMAX a sports Channel in India is telecasting live... Not sure if NZ has access to the channel

  • on January 7, 2011, 12:47 GMT

    Auction starts at 10 am indian time tommorow