Indian Premier League 2010

BCCI raps Modi over Kochi revelations on Twitter

Cricinfo staff

April 13, 2010

Comments: 77 | Text size: A | A

Shashi Tharoor, a minister in the Indian government, chats with Lalit Modi, Delhi Daredevils v Kolkata Knight Riders, IPL, Feroz Shah Kotla, March 29, 2010
Lalit Modi and Shashi Tharoor at an IPL game in Delhi © Indian Premier League

The controversy over the revelation of the Kochi franchise's ownership details has taken a new, and possibly more serious, twist with ramifications beyond the IPL and the BCCI. In the past 24 hours Shashank Manohar, the BCCI president, has written a strongly worded letter to the IPL commissioner Lalit Modi criticising his decision to make public the ownership details, while Shashi Tharoor, a minister in the Congress-led federal government and a moving force behind the Kochi bid, has responded to charges of a conflict of interest by calling it an "extraordinary breach of all propriety" by Modi designed to discredit the franchise and disqualify the ownership.

For his part, Modi is reported to have responded to Manohar's letter by saying his revelations on Twitter were "in no way a breach of confidentiality". He went on to say that the Kochi franchise had "a lot to hide and as such have lied about who are the actual owners of the shares."

The story so far

  • March 7: IPL franchise auction is called off after objections over stiff financial clauses
  • March 21: Auction re-staged; Sahara wins Pune bid, Rendezvous group wins Kochi for $333.33 million. Shashi Tharoor, an MP from Kerala and junior foreign minister in the Congress government, plays facilitating role.
  • Interim: Reports suggest Rendezvous' surprise win has upset bigger players. Tharoor reportedly meets Congress leaders, asks them to ensure pressure eases on Kochi owners, says he has no personal material stake in franchise.
  • April 9: Media reports say BCCI has raised questions over shareholding pattern, asked Rendezvous to clarify its ownership structure.
  • April 10: Kochi owners meet Modi in Bangalore, sign formal agreement to be part of IPL, disclose ownership structure.
  • April 11: Modi, in response to questions on his Twitter feed, reveals Kochi shareholding pattern. One shareholder is a woman whom Tharoor says he "knows well".
  • April 12: Kochi complain to BCCI over Modi's revelations. BCCI chief Manohar criticises Modi for his action. Modi defends himself, saying no breach of propriety.
  • April 12-13: Tharoor issues statement denying any personal stake in Kochi and alleging Modi wants the franchise moved out.

"I have minutes of what they [Kochi franchise] said at the meeting. And, in fact, when I questioned who the shareholders were, they had no answer," Modi wrote. "They said they would revert back. Within minutes of me asking the same, I got a call from Shashi Tharoor asking me not to ask about who these shareholders are. You [Manohar] had mentioned that we should ignore who this owner is, but our condition requires us to authenticate who they are.

"I am happy to disclose all the facts at the next governing council meeting. As regards not raising it at the time of the tender - we didn't have the foresight to go through the voluminous documents attached to verify each and every shareholder. As regards many other things I have said on my Twitter account, they have actually not been any classified information. It's factual and only something we have or would have put into the public domain."

The BCCI's only official response to the developments was an announcement, made through a vice-president, Rajeev Shukla, that a meeting of the IPL Governing Council would be convened within 10 days to "discuss all the issues and take a decision".

In his letter, as reported in the Times of India, Manohar chided Modi for revealing the stakes of Kochi's owners, saying the BCCI was a body that "functions in accordance with its constitution" and not through the media.

"The issue, if any, could have been discussed at the governing council meeting and that action on your part of raising it on Twitter is unbecoming of you as a chairman of the a sub-committee of the board. Your action is in serious breach of the confidentiality clause in the agreement," Manohar wrote. "Till date, you have made public statements about a lot of issues which were not even discussed in the meetings of the governing council when it is the governing council which has the authority to take decisions with regard to each and every issue related to IPL."

Tharoor's part in the story stems from his relationship with Sunanda Pushkar, one of those listed by Modi as having free equity in the Kochi franchise. While media reports suggest they have plans to marry, Tharoor in his statement referred to her as someone he knew well but said there was no material gain from it. He said he had "neither invested nor received a rupee for my mentorship of the team… Whatever my personal relationships with any of the consortium members, I do not intend to benefit in any way financially from my association with the team now or at a later stage."

Tharoor said the consortium's successful bid in the March 21 auction "upset the plans of a lot of powerful people, who had wanted the franchise to go elsewhere". He said "attempts were made by Modi and others to pressure the consortium members to abandon their bid in favour of another city in a different state".

He also denied Modi's charge that he had called the IPL commissioner and asked him not to probe the ownership structure. He had called Modi, he conceded, but "only to ask why he was further delaying the approval of the franchise when all the legal requirements had been fulfilled".

"I called Mr Modi to ask why he was further delaying the approval of the franchise when all the legal requirements had been fulfilled.. Mr Modi had held up approval by the IPL of the franchisee agreement earlier in the day, by insisting on the reversal of a change in the document that he himself had earlier suggested.

"This change was made, the consortium members flew to Bangalore and met with Mr Modi after that night's IPL game for what they had been told would be a routine exercise. Instead they were submitted to a barrage of questions which led some to suspect that Mr Modi was seeking a further excuse to delay approval. This was the reason for my intervention with Mr Modi. Had he conducted himself in good faith throughout, no call would have been necessary."

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by SettingSun on (April 15, 2010, 14:56 GMT)

Actually, forget Benny Hill. Maybe Mr Modi might want to try a great song by The Kinks called Sunny Afternoon instead. The lyrics just about sum up current events perfectly, I'd say.

Posted by vkishore on (April 15, 2010, 7:56 GMT)

As a passionate and true indian cricket fan I urge the ICC to immediately investigate the BCCI and IPL. It is being run by the biggest fraudsters in the world. Kindly save the indian public from these thieves. The BCCI and IPL have no moral authority to run cricket in india. People like Mr.Kapil Dev should be allowed to run cricket in india.

Posted by ajay_sensible on (April 15, 2010, 6:57 GMT)

For the few Modi supporters here, how come Modi just singled out Kochi????

What about Rajasthan, Punjab, Kolkata and other franchises...

This talentt promotion is just a hog wash, its about making millions/billions by playing with Indian people's sentiments

Karban kamal cathc, city moment, mrf....damn is that cricket???

Compare it wath an ashes see the difference in Class

Modi has a criminal background, check wikipedia and he's showing the same traits again by bringing illegal money in India, which could prove to be disastrous for our Country. Remember so many attacks happening in different Countries due to dishonest people who fund illegal money for wrong activities. This could really turn out to be the place where it all began when we think of it 4 years down the line. It has to be stopped right away!

Posted by Bruce_Cool on (April 15, 2010, 6:16 GMT)

I hope that this controversy does not affect current or any future IPLs...

Posted by Rake1 on (April 14, 2010, 22:57 GMT)

Kochi franchise: "We were offered $50m to quit - investors thought that since they had worked hard for the last six-seven months to get this bid, they did not agree." Surely $50m for 6-7 months work is not bad unless!!!

Posted by Rajesh. on (April 14, 2010, 20:41 GMT)

Whoever is speaking the truth, this was bound to happen..........with all the money involved with the IPL these things were bound to happen some day or the other...............

Posted by   on (April 14, 2010, 19:21 GMT)

"Modi's brother-in-law Suresh Chelaram apparently holds the maximum 44.1 percent stake in Rajasthan Royals while Gaurav's brother Mohit is the co-owner of Kings XI Punjab". Modi should think twice before talking about nepotism!

Posted by rohan024 on (April 14, 2010, 18:11 GMT)

I say let Modi tweet, let Tharoor mentor others, let Sunanda get equity, let SRK dance nude, let thugs/underworld buy teams, let it become the biggest issue in media and in parliament, let Yuvraj singh sulk, let Gambhir walk the talk....but for god's sake please please ask Sharad Pawar to resign from BCCI and look after his ministry of agriculture. I am shocked that this issue is never raised when agriculture still forms the backbone of more than 50% of our population...Why is Sharad Pawar spending time on cricket when he should be spending time in his office in Delhi ? Who will ever ask Sharad Pawar to resign from BCCI ?

Posted by SettingSun on (April 14, 2010, 16:03 GMT)

Oh, Lalit. Ever thought of adopting the Benny Hill music as your theme?

Posted by Southindian28 on (April 14, 2010, 15:31 GMT)

I can see lot of different opinions here supporting both the parties, which is nice, why is that when it comes to Kerala, it seems everyone voicing their comments.Kerala cine stars first approached IPL for team Kochis franchise. suddenly Mr Modi`s hiked up the bidding which everyones is aware, why this is not done for others, when BCCI cautioned the commissioner he reduced the amount, he thinks he can do anything he wants, this is high time THE GOVT should involve and appoint people like TN Seshan to govern IPL. where everything will come to light all hanky panky business from all the members. Tharoor is the first minister to tweet which has increased focus on him, mind you all he has done a very good job at the UN, he would have been UN Sec Gen, if Europe has not blocked the candidate from India.. keep up the good work Mr Tharoor.

Proud Southindian

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
ESPNcricinfo staffClose
Tournament Results
Super Kings v Mum Indians at Mumbai - Apr 25, 2010
Super Kings won by 22 runs
RCB v Chargers at Mumbai - Apr 24, 2010
RCB won by 9 wickets (with 37 balls remaining)
Super Kings v Chargers at Mumbai - Apr 22, 2010
Super Kings won by 38 runs
RCB v Mum Indians at Mumbai - Apr 21, 2010
Mum Indians won by 35 runs
KKR v Mum Indians at Kolkata - Apr 19, 2010
KKR won by 9 wickets (with 15 balls remaining)
More results »
News | Features Last 3 days
News | Features Last 3 days
Sponsored Links

Why not you? Read and learn how!