Peter Roebuck
Peter Roebuck Peter RoebuckRSS FeedFeeds  | Archives
Former captain of Somerset; author of It Never Rains, Sometimes I Forgot to Laugh and other books

Long live the Champions League

The tenacity of the South Africans, the efficiency of the Australians, and the flair of the Caribbean players have made the event an unqualified success

Peter Roebuck

October 21, 2009

Comments: 57 | Text size: A | A

T&T players launch themselves on Kieron Pollard after their four-wicket win, New South Wales v Trinidad & Tobago, Champions League Twenty20, League A, Hyderabad, October 16, 2009
T&T's superb efforts have reminded all and sundry about the attractions of West Indian cricket © Global Cricket Ventures-BCCI
Enlarge
Related Links

Although sated locals seem to regard it as a flop, from further afield the Champions League Twenty20 has been thoroughly enjoyable. Indeed it has been the most compelling event of its sort staged in recent years. Long may it last.

Whereas many tournaments nowadays seem familiar and blunt, the Champions League has been alive and full of sharp edges. Apart from anything else it has evidently mattered significantly to the teams taking part, particularly those not used to competing against unknown sides in far-off places and all under television's exacting scrutiny. Somerset's chairman went so far as to describe his county's early victory as the "greatest night in the club's history", an exuberant remark to be sure, but showing the sort of excitement felt by several teams. As far as Marcus Trescothick was concerned, the Champions League was important enough to lure him back into his old life.

In short, it has been a competition played between ambitious, hungry teams that fought tooth and nail for the right to take part, surviving many challenges, overcoming provincial opponents, holding their nerve in the critical hour. To watch the faces of the support staff on the benches was to get the gist of it. Not a trace of weariness or cynicism could be sensed. To the contrary, all concerned were delighted to be taking part. Because the matches were sincere, they were also satisfying and entertaining. It is important to care. Sport is a passion play.

The Champions League appealed to observers on several fronts. Nothing gave more delight than the sight of Trinidad & Tobago, the Cape Cobras, and for that matter the Diamond Eagles, performing valiantly and surpassing expectations. All of them seemed to relish the occasion. Not the least of the Champions League's qualities is that it has reminded all and sundry that even in cricket, with all its stark isolations, with its exposing confrontations, harsh facts and cold figures, teams cannot be created out of thin air and deep pockets.

Several of the participants surprised on what economists are pleased to call "the upside", and all of them were genuine provincial teams. A fever could be detected in their gait. Inexperienced youngsters and seasoned campaigners alike responded to the clamour and met the challenge. Many of them have spent their entire careers playing in empty stadiums that seem to echo with irrelevance even as they apply themselves to their task with every ounce of skill at their disposal. Don't tell these chaps that the Champions League did not matter.

Meanwhile none of the feared IPL sides advanced to the semi-finals, not even the Deccan Chargers with their array of dashers or the talented collection representing Delhi Daredevils. Unavoidably it was merely another tournament for them. Plain and simple, the outfits with deep roots progressed and makeshift line-ups fell back. Whereas the IPL teams contained stars, veterans and a handful of locals, the visiting sides from Trinidad, South Africa and Australia had played together not for weeks but years turning into decades. By and large the players had emerged from youth teams, working their way through the ranks, making friends, gathering knowledge.

 
 
By all means continue to organise the IPL as it stands, with franchises bought and sold, stars signed and sacked, celebrities running around all over the place, and so on and so forth. But do not send those sides to the Champions League
 

Moreover, the Champions League was a huge opportunity for the unsung to prove their worth, to mix with the mighty, to make a packet. Admittedly it was often a close-run thing, but it's precisely in tight finishes that the teams with strong cores endure. Somehow such collaborations find a way to score those extra few runs or take those last wickets, to get the job done. They depend not on their outstanding abilities but upon each other. Put it down to desperation, will power, shared suffering, the ties that bind, whatever, but the results speak for themselves.

Arguably New South Wales and Victoria had the perfect combination of identity, experience and hunger. Although it was considered, neither state signed any imports. Neither took any shortcuts. New South Wales relied on their youngsters, while Victoria depended on the tried and trusted. Both strategies worked because the teams were united, the policy was clear and consistent and the players full of calibre. Along the way the Australian outfits overpowered some opponents.

As far as Indian cricket is concerned, the lessons are obvious. Suppose Delhi had won, what would it signify? By all means continue to organise the IPL as it stands, with franchises bought and sold, stars signed and sacked, celebrities running around all over the place, and so on and so forth. But do not send those sides to the Champions League. Better to arrange a domestic tournament with all provinces, proper teams with histories and traditions and structures, taking part.

It is not a question of effort. All of the overseas players are proud professionals and all of them play with their hearts as well as their heads. Just that theirs is a commitment that cannot be attained overnight. Perhaps, too, the provincial sides were on the rise and the IPL sides, dependent on older players, are in decline. For that matter the results shed doubt upon the standard as opposed to the showmanship on display in IPL. It'll be interesting to see how long IPL teams retain expensive stars unable to produce the expected returns. If they are serious about winning, as opposed to thrilling, then some will be given their cards. But legends are not so easily replaced. Without them, the IPL might lose some of its lustre.

The feats of the minor sides herald the Champions League's second attraction. Not only were the newcomers able to beat their highly regarded opponents, they were also bursting at the teams with fresh and gifted cricketers. Numerous exciting players previously limited to domestic matches were able to stretch themselves and pit themselves against the best in the game. Helped by a format that permits no inhibition, a version that encourages risk, they let loose with thunderous blows or brilliant interceptions in the field, or gasps of wickets or laughter. Quite a few neglected sons will have caught the eye of national selectors interested in their power and response to pressure.

Even old hands like Dirk Nannes informed their selectors that they are alive, well, available and fast. Amongst the Trinidadians, several caught the eye - spinners, speedsters and powerful batsmen. Kieron Pollard's assault on Moises Henriques was memorable but by no means isolated. In the final match before the semis, Adrian Barath, given his first opportunity, let loose an array of some scintillating off-side strokes, while Navin Stewart struck the ball with coruscating power. Established West Indians skulking in their tents might regret their inactivity.


Cornelius de Villiers is mobbed by his team-mates, Eagles v Sussex, Group B, Champions League Twenty20, Delhi, October 13, 2009
Players from South Africa, especially, will go home with a spring in their step © Global Cricket Ventures-BCCI
Enlarge

Provided they are not spoilt by the sudden bulging of their bank accounts, the younger players taking part will return to the domestic ranks bristling with determination and confidence. Obviously it takes more than a few beefy blows in a 20-over tournament to convince selectors that a player has the characteristics needed to thrive in all forms of the game. But it is no small thing to travel overseas and score runs and take wickets in such illustrious company. Players from South Africa, especially, will go home with a spring in their step. Some of the Bloemfontein boys know they can mix it with the mighty, play in front of boisterous crowds and flourish. They know their cricket is not second rate. Moreover, their appetites have been whetted.

T&T's superb efforts served another purpose, reminding all and sundry about the attractions of West Indian cricket and how much has been lost in these days of incompetence, egotism and idleness. T&T, and for that matter the second-string West Indian side that appeared in the Champions Trophy, played with sufficient passion to shame the overwrought incumbents and their headstrong administrators.

Certainly T&T's performance gave frustrated observers food for thought. Daren Ganga's side played as a team partly because they are a team and represent a nation, or at any rate a group of islands that have long been bound together. T&T has an identity, a meaning, a sense of patriotism. Contrastingly West Indies is a cause not a country. In essence it is a cricketing artifice and a broken dream. Those convinced that the only lasting solution to the West Indies' cricketing problems is to break it up and let the islands play as individual nations found in T&T's thrilling display plenty to support their case.

In the shorter term, Ganga's captaincy has surely also put the cat among the pigeons. It was widely and justifiably praised. After all it's been a long time since any West Indian captain coaxed a performance as spirited from his side. Although Ganga's batting might not be quite up to scratch (he's hardly alone in that), the West Indian selectors ought to consider appointing him captain of their team to tour Australia. Apart from anything else it's unlikely that he'll arrive three days before the first Test match, appear disinterested, and spend his time complaining about administrators and money and the rest of it. T&T may have pointed the way forwards. A cause cannot compete with a country, or not for eternity anyhow.

Peter Roebuck is a former captain of Somerset and the author, most recently, of In It to Win It

RSS Feeds: Peter Roebuck

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by U.A.1985 on (October 24, 2009, 7:47 GMT)

Fully agree with redneck. Beautifully put!!

Posted by JimDavis on (October 23, 2009, 12:58 GMT)

Mr Roebuck, in all seriousness, the team that represents the West Indies is no more a collection of disparate countries than the team that represents England. At least the West Indies' players are able to go back and play for their respective countries any time they like, unlike the Irish or the Scots (or any player from an Associate nation for that matter) who get picked on a whim for England only to be discarded for the next X-factor winner, never able to return to play for their own country.

Posted by JimDavis on (October 23, 2009, 12:29 GMT)

The tornament needs just a couple of small change - Include clubs from all the major cricket nations to aid diversity. Give it a specific 2 weeks each year or two on the ICC tours list. Move it to the West Indies and leave it there. (the various nations can share it round) Remember it is a TV sport this one, so make the cost to local spectators minimal or even free to as many as possible as full houses always look better on TV.

Posted by silverpie on (October 23, 2009, 11:57 GMT)

There is a third possibility in the case of India--the five zonal teams (a 20/20 Duleep would be the effective qualifier). That is really what the South African "franchises" seem to be in effect--regional teams composed of multiple traditional state/county/etc. teams.

Posted by redneck on (October 23, 2009, 0:47 GMT)

BangaloreKid, my friend! its 20twenty, most of the australian public dont care! its good to see nsw and vic do well but even if they didnt no one here really cares! the australian team bring people through the gate, thats where cricket supporters loyalty lies here! and the baggy green is still the ultimate goal for any aussie cricketer, hence why clarke, johnston or haddin have declined to take part in ipl for the first 2 years as their priority was being fit and refreshed for australian commitments! i fail to see how australia are second priority at all!

Posted by TwitterJitter on (October 22, 2009, 18:55 GMT)

Just how rubbish is CLT20? Bravo plays for T&T in Caribbean. Then he plays in Australia for Big Bash followed by IPL and may be for Cape Cobras and Somerset in future. Take your pick. Depending on who qualifies he will play champions leage for them. Utter rubbish! This is making mockery of fans and viewing public. No loyalties, nothing! Cameron White signs up for BRC and then captains for VB against BRC! Nothing wrong with him playing for VB where he played most of his cricket. But then I would tell him to get the heck out of BRC. The players and administrators pretend their phony loyalties to IPL clubs by mixing and matching teams every other day and we are somehow supposed to cheer for them because they told us to. If somebody plays for BRC, I expect them to play for no other club other than BRC. That is how you build loyalty - win or loose.

Posted by TwitterJitter on (October 22, 2009, 18:46 GMT)

@chinmayD- Utter rubbish. You seem to have your logic backwards. It is the job of state associations affiliated with BCCI to groom players, not IPL teams. The franchises in turn pay BCCI lots of money each year for first 10 years as part of buying a team. If the domestic talent is not there, blame state associations who get the divided share of the booty from BCCI, not the franchises. They will get to use players from BCCI's talent pool whom they buy during auction and are only available to them for 6 weeks of IPL and during CL, if they make it. Ranji teams will fare even worse. Having 25-30 ranji teams only dilutes quality. Franchises buy players for a 6-week window. Thats it. They have no rights on players after that. The bigger problem is some state associations like Rajasthan have not contributed a national player in long time but still get 1/25th share of money from BCCI. CLT20 where a player signs up for 6 clubs in 6 nations is utter rubbish and does not get any loyalty from fans

Posted by Rahulbose on (October 22, 2009, 18:27 GMT)

Celebrity Players vs Team players is a relevant debate given the results. Thanks for highlighting this key fact. Although, this issue is not limited to IPL, even soccer leagues like Real Madrid have gone the road of IPL teams and suffered. The organizers of IPL obviously hope their teams one day will enjoy similar loyalty and pride from its players and fans. But so far this champions league has been similar to the World XI vs Aus series.

Posted by cowcornerDOTorg on (October 22, 2009, 17:20 GMT)

This great tourney proves the contention that all the BS we put up with is caused by the footy crowd that has to see a "great man". Those that love the sport don't give a flyin' flip who's playing if it's good cricket.

So you have teams that have cherry picked the popular world talent, and they have been driven into the turf by squads of county veterans.

All of you that say...but it needs the money, note how all that money was naught against a side with a decent mental concept of what T20 is about.

Posted by shashreekroy on (October 22, 2009, 16:59 GMT)

The champions league T20 has shown very clearly that teams are made out of players who know each other well and play with each other. A team comprises players with good mutual understanding, players who are willing to put their hand up for each other. The failure of the IPL teams showed that merely putting a bunch of stars into a playing eleven doesn't make a successful team. The one team that has stood out in the tournament has been Trinidad and Tobago with their ability to play as one unit and their passion and spirit generated by their captain Darren Ganga. The other thing this champions league has done is thrown light on players like C.de villiers, Pollard, Holland, and Barath most of whom were unknown to the masses. These players have really turned the heads of both spectators and selectors. The champions league has really opened a whole new world of cricket.

Comments have now been closed for this article

FeedbackTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Peter RoebuckClose
Peter Roebuck He may not have played Test cricket for England, but Peter Roebuck represented Somerset with distinction, making over 1000 runs nine times in 12 seasons, and captaining the county during a tempestuous period in the 1980s. Roebuck acquired recognition all over the cricket world for his distinctive, perceptive, independent writing. Widely travelled, he divided his time between Australia and South Africa. He died in November 2011

    'It's scary to think I actually have a Test hat-trick'

New Zealand allrounder James Franklin remembers all his stats, and likes to take his five-year-old to watch football and rugby

Pup gets a grilling

The Cricket Monthly: Do cricketers know what they did last summer (and before)? We put Michael Clarke to the test

    'I didn't have the D/L sheet during the Durban World Cup game'

Shaun Pollock talks to Alison Mitchell about career highs and lows

    From support act to lead role

Numbers Game: Over the last four years, Rangana Herath has become Sri Lanka's strike bowler

The Phillip Hughes debate never ends

Russell Jackson: He makes buckets of runs but cannot hold his place in the Test side. What needs to work for him going forward?

News | Features Last 7 days

How bad must a defeat be to be unacceptable?

A gutting loss to England, after leading the series 1-0, has thrown up some glaring inadequacies in the Indian team but there is little being said or done in terms of improvement

Time to liberate MS Dhoni

After 8-0, MS Dhoni could look forward to building a team from scratch; now, there is nothing left for him to contribute. Free him from the Test captaincy and he could yet give back in other ways

Dhoni's control test

For all MS Dhoni's many trophies and accomplishments, Test cricket continues to resist his magic and indefinitely postpone his motorbike ride into the sunset

Perfect Herath leads SL dominance

Sri Lanka's marks out of 10 following their 2-0 series win against Pakistan

'You should not be embarrassing your country'

Former players react to India's humiliating 1-3 series defeat in England

News | Features Last 7 days

    How bad must a defeat be to be unacceptable? (142)

    A gutting loss to England, after leading the series 1-0, has thrown up some glaring inadequacies in the Indian team but there is little being said or done in terms of improvement

    Time to liberate MS Dhoni (116)

    After 8-0, MS Dhoni could look forward to building a team from scratch; now, there is nothing left for him to contribute. Free him from the Test captaincy and he could yet give back in other ways

    Dhoni's control test (75)

    For all MS Dhoni's many trophies and accomplishments, Test cricket continues to resist his magic and indefinitely postpone his motorbike ride into the sunset

    The two faces of James Anderson (60)

    Why does the man who is possibly England's greatest fast bowler occasionally turn into Mr Hyde on the field?

    One-day barrier to Indian Test progress (56)

    With too great an emphasis on limited-overs cricket, MS Dhoni's side have a set of skills and a level of concentration that are not commensurate with the necessities of Tests