Reviews ReviewsRSS FeedFeeds

Review: The Great Tamasha

India via its cricket

A new book by a foreign correspondent based in the country offers a wide range of voices, if not much in terms of fresh perspective

Osman Samiuddin

August 24, 2013

Comments: 8 | Text size: A | A

Cover of <i>The Great Tamasha</i> by James Astill
Enlarge
Related Links
Series/Tournaments: Indian Premier League
Teams: India

Entirely unintended, one of the effects of The Great Tamasha: Cricket, Corruption and the Turbulent Rise of Modern India is a gentle meditation on the place of the foreign correspondent in modern-day journalism. They are not what they used to be, and neither any longer as many as they used to be. In one sense, being a foreign correspondent has always had the in-built limitation that the equally inherent romanticism of the role has swept aside, the one that veteran Pamela Constable once articulated.

"I have always been acutely aware," she confessed, having ticked off over 35 countries in her tour of duty, "that no matter how deeply I burrowed into a society or how many people I interviewed, I was only peeling back the most superficial layers of complex, murky worlds in which people routinely lied, every incident had a contradictory version, and no 1500-word article could possibly do justice to the truth."

Constable operated in a different world. Today, the wandering hack is further emaciated, not least because countries now do a pretty good job of corresponding about themselves. India especially, Pakistan increasingly, now communicate to the world on their own; should you have an internet connection, they are waiting online for you to discover what you want about them.

The deeper picture that once emerged from the vast sweeps of Emma Duncan's Breaking the Curfew or Mark Tully's No Full Stops in India can now be pieced together, local news report by local news report, feature by feature, essay by essay, academic paper by academic paper, tweet by tweet, novel by novel, through the countries' traditional and non-traditional media. So much, in fact, is already out there that books by foreign correspondents about the countries they are stationed in are condemned by a kind of sneering, live-there-know-that wariness: how much did they really get the country they are in?

James Astill was for four years the Economist's South Asia bureau chief, based in New Delhi, a stint that coincided with the birth, rise and stumbling of the Indian Premier League. That momentous and sudden arrival underpins The Great Tamasha, an entrepreneurial tale as purposely observant of Indian cricket as it is of India; India is, therefore is Indian cricket. The scope is wide, Astill arching back and arriving at the IPL, this Indian tamasha, from that English sport.

Much of this territory is as well trodden as a Delhi footpath. Nattily written as it is, Astill's promenading into caste and social class, nationalism and religion is of the sort that has been accomplished with much greater depth and care in Ramachandra Guha's magnificent A Corner of a Foreign Field or Mihir Bose's History of Indian Cricket. In a very different style, Richard Cashman's lesser-cited Patrons, Players, and the Crowd: The Phenomenon of Indian Cricket was a vital study (and surprisingly evocative, somehow, for such a studied, serious text of Hrishikesh Mukherjee's India).

But foreign correspondents retain benefits, particularly in the degree of relatively unfettered access they are sometimes granted. This malaise still hangs over India-Pakistan officialdom that the more foreign the journalist, the more unguardedly they talk. So as Astill moves to more contemporary history he peppers it with some compelling, revealing conversations. Here is Niranjan Shah, kingpin of Saurashtra cricket, and more importantly BCCI vice-president, speaking as dismissively of international cricket - and the ICC - as any current administrator has: "Like in baseball, America is not worried whether other country is playing or not," he tells Astill.

There is PB Vanchi, head of GMR Sports, owners of the Delhi Daredevils, breathing fire on the city of his franchise and the fans it targets. "I've never loved Delhi," Vanchi confides, before concluding that building a fan base in the capital "is very difficult because there is no factor like loyalty in Delhi".

It is in these modern explorations that Astill is most adept and revelatory, in laying bare the disdain the BCCI holds the rest of the world in, or the broader fickleness of the IPL. Would either Shah or Vanchi have spoken so candidly to a local journalist? Unimaginable.

At every step Astill stays apace with the story of India as well, a story he is well placed to recount. But it is mostly a recounting rather than new insight or fresh perspective, though there is an admirably wide range of voices (including a slightly delusional Preity Zinta). And there are just enough errors to reinforce Constable's fears, especially frustrating from a political editor of the Economist with experience in the region: Indira Gandhi's Emergency was imposed in 1975 not 1977, and Lahore's Gaddafi stadium was not named thus in the time of General Zia-ul-Haq but by the leader Zia sent to the noose, Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto.

Apolitical cricket buffs will also wait in line with their aha's. Some might even argue that the use of "tamasha" in the title and as a running theme - "Indians want more tamasha," Astill writes towards the end - is mildly condescending, implying that Indians can only appreciate cricket as some simple, hard-hitting, loud, raucous spectacle.

The Great Tamasha: Cricket, Corruption and the Turbulent Rise of Modern India
by James Astill
Wisden
307 pages (hardback)

Osman Samiuddin is a writer based in the UAE

RSS Feeds: Osman Samiuddin

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by Venkat_Gowrishankar on (August 26, 2013, 22:20 GMT)

Some writing here on "slash and burn "( pun intended) cricket, I wish to ask , how many of you have traveled to India?. Or , how many of you are aware of last season's Ranji trophy winners. Let alone that, how many teams play in the ranji trophy?, how long does it span, what are the different conditions they are played under?, The answer to these questions, India has the longest and the largest First class structure in the world. Now, how come India is neglecting Test cricket?.

Never generalize based on what is reported or what is seen on TV.

Posted by anilkp on (August 26, 2013, 20:06 GMT)

Osman, may it be your commentary on regular day-to-day cricket affairs, match analysis, year-end reviews (full of gut-churning satire), tour diaries or soulful, incisive reports on "cricketive" administrative and political matters, you are being missed on Cricinfo pages. This one is a very good one, offers glimpses into India from a different perspective, and allures me to get a copy. Still, I urge you to write more on these pages; I am sure many Cricinfo-visitors will agree! You are too good to be missed here!

Posted by   on (August 25, 2013, 16:13 GMT)

There been a perception that the Younger Generation of India endorses and follows Slang-Bang Version of 20-20 Cricket, which is really not the case. Indian Youths follow all the three versions and love to see their team faring well, be it any version of the three. They are more passionate and likely to more critical about the teams performance than the other nations. I remember the response they gave to the IPL and the champion league tournaments which came up shortly after the disastrous tours of Australia and England. The responses were cold and it reflected in the TRP ratings too. The reality is majority of the Indians prefer to watch the action in the screens rather than in the stadiums, more so for test cricket the same being a 5 day affair. But you will always see a good crowd on weekends for test matches as well. Admit, Test attendance been a problem in the Metro cities on weekdays as people prefer to follow the game on electronic medias in between their official activities.

Posted by WAKE_UP_CALL on (August 25, 2013, 7:08 GMT)

test cricket will be pumping blood in the big 4 but its awful to see abomination of test cricket in front of cricket paying public whose fault was nothing but to come and expect a contest.It is time for the decision makers of this game to come forward and tighten few things such as over rate,time delaying tactics and dull boring draws.Every test match should have an impact towards the points of test championship so that no team starts playing for draw from the first innings onwards.If fans are not taken seriously by players then the game will be threatened to slide for doom.

Posted by   on (August 24, 2013, 20:27 GMT)

Hmmm, and what about when you cant get an orange anymore? If the three formats went the way of witty's comment, and three separate teams played them, how long would the longest format last? For that matter, why stop there, call it all off in favour of a 20/20 league world wide, where all youngsters aim only to be able to hit 28 off 6 and be a handy bowler able to concentrate for 4 overs. Yes the history of cricket demanded some adjustments and the 1 day was born and later the t20. However at the rate the t20 leagues and internationals are going and with the cash involved, orange season might well no longer be an option. We will instead, be stuck with witty's apples only. Always like a healthy debate:) Cheers witty.

Posted by Nampally on (August 24, 2013, 16:14 GMT)

Let us face it! Whenever there is a great "Tamasha" (Show), the whole world is interested in seeing what it is all about. If the "Tamasha" is good, it attracts crowd who stay with it. This is the very basis of IPL. They have combined the Hollywood magic with Cricket- both the top attractions in Indian masses. The very birth of IPL & its sustainance for 6 years is a stroke of luck & genius of entrepreanual abilities of the Indians. This is the greatest Tamasha at least on the Indian soil for most fans. It provides fun & enjoyment to millions on TV & online besides live show. This is Indian way to enjoy-alternate to Night Clubs, Casinos, Pubs & Bars. Despite all the inherent corruption, India has risen well above expectations of any western imaginations. It is competing strongly with G-8 Powers & will soon displace a few by its growing technology & innovative ideas. New forms of enjoyment such as IPL is one such innovation, even if it appears like a "Tamasha" to the Economist Astill!

Posted by Witty365ca on (August 24, 2013, 14:18 GMT)

Good Article. Do not agree with comments of "F" that smash'n'go cricket is detrimental and is today a sad state of affairs. A well fought century in tough conditions as well as 29 or 36 runs in 5 or 6 balls are equally creditworthy in different forms of cricket. If I like an Apple; does NOT mean that Orange is bad. It is just an individual choice especially in todays world compared to yester years where 5 days of boring test cricket draws did not allow the game of cricket to prosper at all. No game (one game) in any form of sports today lasts for 5 days (with a rest day in the past) and many turning into a draw. Cricket would have died by now if ODIs were not introduced about more than 2-3 decades ago or T20 introduced few years ago. Very soon we might have 3 diefferent national teams for 3 forms of cricket and "F" could watch only Test cricket if he/she choses to do so.

Posted by   on (August 24, 2013, 10:09 GMT)

smash'n'go cricket in on the rise which in my opinion is detrimental in so many ways...and no one has embraced it quiet like India, bar the Caribbean. Sad state of affairs when 29 off six balls is celebrated with more fervor than a well faught century in tough conditions.....

Comments have now been closed for this article

FeedbackTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
Osman SamiuddinClose
Osman Samiuddin Osman spent the first half of his life pretending he discovered reverse swing with a tennis ball half-covered with electrical tape. The second half of his life was spent trying, and failing, to find spiritual fulfillment in the world of Pakistani advertising and marketing. The third half of his life will be devoted to convincing people that he did discover reverse swing. And occasionally writing about cricket. And learning mathematics.

    Dhoni wins the first round in the captaincy battle

Ian Chappell: Both Dhoni and Cook have made some inexplicable blunders, but India's captain pulls ahead slightly

    TV contracts dictate daytime scheduling of Caribbean matches

Tony Cozier: It's unlikely that fans in West Indies will ever get to enjoy five-day cricket in the evening

    Why isn't Ashwin playing?

Martin Crowe: It's hard to understand how India's best spinner is being left out in favour of bits-and-pieces players

    Gower savours life in the last chance saloon

Rewind: David Gower was on the verge of being dropped for good in 1990 when he made a charismatic century against India

Coming back to win from hopeless first-innings situations

Anantha Narayanan: A look at some of the most thrilling victorious fightbacks in Tests

News | Features Last 7 days

India look for their Indian summer

Billboards are calling the series England's Indian Summer, but it is India who are looking for that period of warmth, redemption after the last whitewash, for they have seen how bleak the winter that can follow is

South Africa face the Kallis question

Accommodation for a great player like Jacques Kallis should be made with careful consideration and South Africa cannot get carried away with sentiment

India's bowling leader conundrum

The present Indian bowling line-up will tackle its first five-Test series without the proven guidance of Zaheer Khan, their bowling captain. India had unravelled without him in 2011. Will they do better this time around?

Five key head-to-heads

From two embattled captains to the challenge for India's openers against the new ball, ESPNcricinfo picks five contests that could determine the series

Packed tours, and Shiv's late stumping

Also, best post-war win/loss record, most runs in two calendar years, most ducks in a Test, and brothers with similar numbers

News | Features Last 7 days

    India look for their Indian summer (87)

    Billboards are calling the series England's Indian Summer, but it is India who are looking for that period of warmth, redemption after the last whitewash, for they have seen how bleak the winter that can follow is

    South Africa face the Kallis question (56)

    Accommodation for a great player like Jacques Kallis should be made with careful consideration and South Africa cannot get carried away with sentiment

    Why isn't Ashwin playing? (52)

    It's close to inexplicable how India's best spinner is being left out in favour of bits-and-pieces players

    India's bowling leader conundrum (44)

    The present Indian bowling line-up will tackle its first five-Test series without the proven guidance of Zaheer Khan, their bowling captain. India had unravelled without him in 2011. Will they do better this time around?

    Five key head-to-heads (33)

    From two embattled captains to the challenge for India's openers against the new ball, ESPNcricinfo picks five contests that could determine the series