The beautiful Test
Amit Varma evaluates both teams after the second test at Chennai
The Wisden Verdict by Amit Varma
12-Jul-2005
![]() |
|
It is a universal duality: the mind that seeks out perfection, the
heart that yearns for beauty. This Chennai Test was not one for the
mind - it was marred by dropped catches, missed
stumpings, nervous errors, and a rained-out day but it was one that will
be remembered fondly for years. Two opponents who respect each other met in
a crucial match and played with passion and fire. They battled the demons
within them and the heat that came from the sun, and refused to wilt. Time
and again this Test match turned, like a spinning top swaying from side to
side but refusing to fall either way. In the end, sadly, it stayed
suspended, as the rain fell, depriving the Test of a result, which it
deserved.
Evaluating Australia
Australia have been far better prepared for this tour than the last one, as
reflected in their willingness to shed the counter-attacking approach that
works against every other side. But they suffered in Chennai because of the
heat. Glenn McGrath looked less than his usual self, and the fielding was
affected as well, with many catches going down. Most of the men in this side
are over 30, and even the finest athletes suffer in conditions that they are
not used to.
But they fought back in an inspired manner. All teams look good when things
are going their way, but it takes something special to bounce back
repeatedly from setbacks, as these men keep doing. Damien Martyn played a sublime innings under great pressure, and that
is not something new to him.
He had the measure of Anil Kumble and Harbhajan Singh during his
second-innings century, displaying an assurance that he hadn't shown in his
previous three innings in this series. His batting is a thing of beauty and
he is a man with great grit. He has proved himself a worthy successor to the
No. 4 position that Mark Waugh had, for so long, made his own.
![]() |
|
Adam Gilchrist batted at No. 3 in the second innings, not out of a tactical
need to get quick runs, but out of responsibility. It will be fascinating to
follow this particular narrative during the series. He is a modern great
whose genius does not find full expression at No. 7, though he has played
some classic innings there. The case against playing him higher up the order
is the burden of wicketkeeping that he also bears. But the case for it is
that at the pace at which he bats, even when he is seemingly taking no
risks, he can swiftly take a match out of the opponents grasp. He has one
more Test before Ricky Ponting returns to the side, and it is a worthwhile
experiment to continue in that game.
Shane Warne had said on the second day that this was
the best he has ever bowled in India, although that is, admittedly,
not saying much. The Indians play him well, but he still ended up with six wickets, though he wasn't quite as potent as he is against other teams. The second term of American presidents is often called the legacy term, and this is Warne's legacy tour of India. He will not tire, and India have reason to be wary of him.
It has become a fashionable cliché to say of Michael Kasprowicz that he is a
'lion-hearted' bowler, but that is doing him a disservice - he has bite to
add to his heart. He bowled some oustanding spells on the second day, and
was unfortunate to have Sourav Ganguly reprieved off his bowling twice. As
had happened to Jason Gillespie on his 2001 tour, the figures don't reflect
how well he bowled. Gillespie, meanwhile, bowled some incisive spells, while
Glenn McGrath will be sharper in cooler climes. The Indians will get no
respite from the Australian bowlers.
The character of this Australian side is different from that of Steve
Waugh's 2001 team in more ways than just cricketing ones. The Ugly
Australians of lore have suddenly become gentlemen Aussies, like a cursed
frog suddenly kissed by a princess. They haven't sledged, they
have walked, and there has been little by way of mental disintegration. Steve Waugh referred to India as the final frontier - regardless of what happens in this series, Australia might just have conquered it.
Evaluating India
![]() |
|
India have the stomach for a fight, and they did not always. There was a
worry, after Bangalore, that India would unravel from there, but now we know
that will not happen, considering that this series is still a contest.
It is hard to decide which to admire more, the seven wickets that Anil
Kumble took on a first-day pitch, or the 47 overs that he bowled in the heat
of unforgiving Chennai sun during Australia's second innings. Kumble almost
won India the Sydney Test, which would have sealed a historic series win for
India in Australia, and if hunger were to decide this series, this man has
more than most. He is on the last lap of a great career, but the fire still
burns in his belly. He also has a luxury that none of the other great
spinners today, Shane Warne or Muttiah Muralitharan, can boast of a spin
partner in Harbhajan Singh who is a matchwinner on his own, and not just a
support act.
Virender Sehwag, as he tends to do every fourth Test or so, made a brilliant
hundred to secure India's advantage. Much has been spoken of his unorthodox
batting, but dissecting Sehwag's technique is like peering at a dancer's
feet to understand her art. He would not have got the results he has, eight
centuries in 25 Tests at 53.9, runs scored all around the world, without
being a darned good batsman. Men like him win you games, because if they
stay a couple of sessions at the crease, they not only score at a brisk
pace, they also demoralise the bowlers. "Look at his foot-movement," they
think, "surely we can get this man out." And then there she goes again, that
wretched ball, towards the ropes that cannot hold her.
Sehwag's success hides a continuing failure, though. He scored almost
two-thirds of the runs made while he was at the crease, and the rest of
India's top five failed. Rahul Dravid had played well in the second innings
at Bangalore, and his 26 here, while not substantial in itself, was part of
a crucial 95-run partnership. He will come good. But Sourav Ganguly, edging
repeatedly, looked as out of place as a piglet in a greyhound race, and VVS
Laxman wasn't his usual graceful self either. Yuvraj Singh still does not
look cut out to open the batting, and India need these men to fire.
A side strain prevented Irfan Pathan from bowling as sharply in the first
innings as at Bangalore, but Zaheer Khan seemed to have got his rhythm back
in the second, with a couple of fiery spells. Indian bowlers however need
more support behind the stumps. Parthiv Patel is a fine talent, but for his
own sake, he should be given a break from international cricket. His basics
have gone to pieces and his mistakes, if we total the runs batsmen made
after being reprieved by him and the byes and penalties he conceded, cost
India almost 200 runs. It tarnished this great contest, but he is a boy
among men, and his time will come.
Amit Varma is managing editor of Wisden Cricinfo in India. He
writes the cricket blog, 23 Yards, for this
site.