Ponting steps down as captain March 29, 2011

Clarke is as ready as he'll ever be

Few captains have enjoyed an apprenticeship as lengthy as Michael Clarke's, and the coming months will reveal whether the apprenticeship has been as thorough as it has been longwinded
16

Having waited so long to hear his path to the Australian captaincy was no longer blocked by the seemingly ageless Ricky Ponting, Michael Clarke was caught off-guard by the moment. Clarke's first reaction to Ponting's morning phone call was to say that he wished he had known of the senior man's intentions a little earlier, so better to help with his leader's final days at the World Cup on the subcontinent.

There were portents of good about this, for it conveyed Clarke's innate desire to help his team and teammates, an attitude enjoyed by the players who have sampled Clarke's captaincy in Twenty20 and one day matches.

But there was also the sobering realisation that from this day forward, Clarke cannot afford to be caught off-guard - anytime, anywhere.

Few captains have enjoyed, or endured, an apprenticeship as lengthy as Clarke's. Ponting himself was never completely sure of becoming Test skipper until the moment it was announced, as first Shane Warne, and then Adam Gilchrist, also had persuasive claims. Instead of worrying about something that was out of his hands and perhaps never going to land in them, Clarke has trained, played and toured with the ever-present knowledge that he was highly likely to be next. At the start of the Ashes summer, chairman of selectors Andrew Hilditch stated flatly to the Cricket Australia board that there was no-one near Clarke in the race to become the next leader, and no-one likely to be. Vacating the position, Ponting offered an endorsement every bit as conclusive as that of Hilditch.

Clarke has long shown a natural flair for the captaincy, and an ability to elicit strong responses from those players placed under him. Revered by younger teammates if not always loved by older ones, Clarke has boundless energy and plenty of tactical ideas, plus an affinity for spin bowling that Ponting was never able to grasp. There is curiosity in the fact that widespread popular affection has eluded Clarke so far, but it is a truism of leadership that the best do not overly concern themselves with opinion polls. He will need to be far more preoccupied by the task of extracting the very most from the players under him. They are not the copiously talented and supremely confident bunch that Ponting inherited in 2004, having rather more in common with the struggling souls Allan Border took command of, in the wake of a tearful Kim Hughes, 20 years ago.

One problem with Clarke's long wait for the job is that, unlike Border, there is some suspicion his batting may have begun to wither on the vice-captain's vine. Clarke's Ashes series was every bit as wretched as Ponting's, and before that he floundered in two Tests in India, previously known as the scene of an ebullient century on his 2004 debut. Even now, the weight that can be ascribed to Clarke's apparent batting resurgence in limited overs matches in 2011, is questionable next to a lack of recent Test match runs. Apart from his earlier days when vibrant strokes were offset by inconsistency, Clarke is not a batsman with the sort of presence often seen among Australian captains. In paring back his strokeplay to pursue a steadier runs return, Clarke lost some of his earlier verve, and chronic back problems have also conspired against him at times across his career.

Counterbalancing this is the fact that Ponting's exit has been timed with the maximum consideration for Clarke, allowing him to ease himself towards leadership with a three-match limited overs series in Bangladesh and then a four-month spell at home to grasp the complexities of the job. Clarke will need every second of this, because his captaincy skills are to be tested most severely by back-to-back tours of Sri Lanka and South Africa. On his team's return home they will face a New Zealand side no doubt hoping to capitalise on tour fatigue, before there is the small matter of a four-match Test series against current world No. 1 India, followed by a trip to the Caribbean. This calendar will be either the making or the breaking of Clarke, and the ultimate measure of whether his apprenticeship has been as thorough as it has been longwinded.

Daniel Brettig is an assistant editor at ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Meety on March 30, 2011, 23:03 GMT

    @TEST_CRICKET_ONLY - pretty sure S Waugh was booed as ODI captain against Oz A when we had 4 cornered ODI tournaments about 10yrs ago. @ xylo - well he inspired a battered & bruised Oz team to a 6-1 series win over the Poms, & his ODI & T20 record as captain is very good.

  • xylo on March 30, 2011, 18:31 GMT

    How do you expect a non-performer to inspire the team? This is almost like the Windies appointing Sammy as captain only to flip the coin.

  • on March 30, 2011, 4:03 GMT

    this is going 2 b in intensely interesting time in Australian cricket. but at least the older guys will b sticking around for a bit longer . I wish them all the best

  • notvery on March 30, 2011, 2:47 GMT

    @Mac Mason. here is your comparison. Ponting - Great batsman, ordinary leader but dragged average team further than it should go through sheer tenacity(the recent team is better than it should be....). Clarke- Gen Y, metro. Will probably be the greatest batsman ever...at Rickyponting Cricket on the X-Box.

  • Meety on March 30, 2011, 1:15 GMT

    Squad for Tests v Sri Lanka, (not necessarily Sth Africa or home v India/NZ). 1. Hughes, 2. Watson, 3. Khawaja, 4. Clarke (c), 5. Ponting, 6. Butterworth, 7. Haddin (vc), 8. O'Keefe, 9. Johnson, 10. Hauritz, 11. Copeland, 12th Smith, 13th Katich, 14th Ferguson, 15th Voges, 16th Coulter-Niles, 17th Lyon, 18th Harris/Bollinger if fit, if not Cummins. Its an extended squad, but I think Cric Oz need to dig deep into their pockets & come up with an extra budget to give 'fringe' players a crack at experiencing a FULL Test tour. I'd consider swapping Lyon for Bailey. I think Butterworths outstanding summer needs to count for something, & with Watto, they are good pace support for MJ & Copeland, (another season & a bit of excellence rewarded).

  • Meety on March 30, 2011, 0:05 GMT

    Good article. I think Pup will make a far better captain then Punter. The only question I have is whether his form will be good enough to be an automatic selection. There is evidence to suggest it will, his ODI stats show that he averages significantly better when captain. As far as his captaincy is concerned, I think he has a bit of Warney, (the greatest Oz Test captain that never was), about his style. He WILL be better for the likes of Hauritz, Doherty, Krezja AND Smith. Proof was in the pudding when Smith was bowled a lot more in the bilateral series v England then what White or Punter have done. If he can maintain his good test average (47ish), I think he will lead Oz well against the fairly formidable challenges he has ahead of himself. Hopefully he will have a fully fit & mentally switched on in-form Punter batting at 5 or 6 to help him.

  • TEST_CRICKET_ONLY on March 30, 2011, 0:00 GMT

    Clarke hasn't been appointed yet, but if he is the majority of the Australian cricketing public will heave a collective groan. He is a very poor choice for captain, and his recent form suggest he shouldn't even be in the team. Of course he does have the distinction of being the only Australian captain to have been booed onto the field by a home crowd.

  • NewYorkCricket on March 29, 2011, 14:03 GMT

    Not sure if he is in the same league as Ponting.

  • marcs on March 29, 2011, 12:48 GMT

    Gonna be a tough first year in office for Mr.pup. Clarke can however take pride of rebuilding the australian side (like border did in 80's) which is presently battered and bruised by the loss of few greats like gilly, hayden, Glenn and shane. good luck

  • on March 29, 2011, 12:12 GMT

    and NOW we will see the magic and majesty of Maestro Michael Clarke.

    a great pity we could not have rid ourselves of boring Ponting a couple of seasons ago.

    i REALLY look forward to a comparison a couple of years from now :)

  • Meety on March 30, 2011, 23:03 GMT

    @TEST_CRICKET_ONLY - pretty sure S Waugh was booed as ODI captain against Oz A when we had 4 cornered ODI tournaments about 10yrs ago. @ xylo - well he inspired a battered & bruised Oz team to a 6-1 series win over the Poms, & his ODI & T20 record as captain is very good.

  • xylo on March 30, 2011, 18:31 GMT

    How do you expect a non-performer to inspire the team? This is almost like the Windies appointing Sammy as captain only to flip the coin.

  • on March 30, 2011, 4:03 GMT

    this is going 2 b in intensely interesting time in Australian cricket. but at least the older guys will b sticking around for a bit longer . I wish them all the best

  • notvery on March 30, 2011, 2:47 GMT

    @Mac Mason. here is your comparison. Ponting - Great batsman, ordinary leader but dragged average team further than it should go through sheer tenacity(the recent team is better than it should be....). Clarke- Gen Y, metro. Will probably be the greatest batsman ever...at Rickyponting Cricket on the X-Box.

  • Meety on March 30, 2011, 1:15 GMT

    Squad for Tests v Sri Lanka, (not necessarily Sth Africa or home v India/NZ). 1. Hughes, 2. Watson, 3. Khawaja, 4. Clarke (c), 5. Ponting, 6. Butterworth, 7. Haddin (vc), 8. O'Keefe, 9. Johnson, 10. Hauritz, 11. Copeland, 12th Smith, 13th Katich, 14th Ferguson, 15th Voges, 16th Coulter-Niles, 17th Lyon, 18th Harris/Bollinger if fit, if not Cummins. Its an extended squad, but I think Cric Oz need to dig deep into their pockets & come up with an extra budget to give 'fringe' players a crack at experiencing a FULL Test tour. I'd consider swapping Lyon for Bailey. I think Butterworths outstanding summer needs to count for something, & with Watto, they are good pace support for MJ & Copeland, (another season & a bit of excellence rewarded).

  • Meety on March 30, 2011, 0:05 GMT

    Good article. I think Pup will make a far better captain then Punter. The only question I have is whether his form will be good enough to be an automatic selection. There is evidence to suggest it will, his ODI stats show that he averages significantly better when captain. As far as his captaincy is concerned, I think he has a bit of Warney, (the greatest Oz Test captain that never was), about his style. He WILL be better for the likes of Hauritz, Doherty, Krezja AND Smith. Proof was in the pudding when Smith was bowled a lot more in the bilateral series v England then what White or Punter have done. If he can maintain his good test average (47ish), I think he will lead Oz well against the fairly formidable challenges he has ahead of himself. Hopefully he will have a fully fit & mentally switched on in-form Punter batting at 5 or 6 to help him.

  • TEST_CRICKET_ONLY on March 30, 2011, 0:00 GMT

    Clarke hasn't been appointed yet, but if he is the majority of the Australian cricketing public will heave a collective groan. He is a very poor choice for captain, and his recent form suggest he shouldn't even be in the team. Of course he does have the distinction of being the only Australian captain to have been booed onto the field by a home crowd.

  • NewYorkCricket on March 29, 2011, 14:03 GMT

    Not sure if he is in the same league as Ponting.

  • marcs on March 29, 2011, 12:48 GMT

    Gonna be a tough first year in office for Mr.pup. Clarke can however take pride of rebuilding the australian side (like border did in 80's) which is presently battered and bruised by the loss of few greats like gilly, hayden, Glenn and shane. good luck

  • on March 29, 2011, 12:12 GMT

    and NOW we will see the magic and majesty of Maestro Michael Clarke.

    a great pity we could not have rid ourselves of boring Ponting a couple of seasons ago.

    i REALLY look forward to a comparison a couple of years from now :)

  • on March 29, 2011, 11:23 GMT

    well class is permanent with ponting I doubt about clark yet be filling ponting shoes as a aussie captain, his credentials are also doubtfull, whenever team needs him he failed and now captency things will get tougher for him...thats why cricket is called glorious game of uncertinites..aussies use to say breeding grounds of world champions..seems breeding has stoped after glen,shane,ponting etc

  • StarveTheLizard on March 29, 2011, 11:17 GMT

    Wishful thinking Daison? There might be some flaws in the Australian system at the moment. The country is still a cricketing powerhouse. It will be pressing the top teams again before too long.

  • on March 29, 2011, 10:34 GMT

    Wooooo what an article! Go Clarkey oh yeah!

  • Melzu on March 29, 2011, 10:32 GMT

    please bring Dav Warner this time for bangladesh tour.. he is a very good an capable player in all formats of the game.. all the best for our new captain

  • DaisonGarvasis on March 29, 2011, 10:06 GMT

    The headline says it all. Clarke is as ready as he will ever be. To expect a Steve Waugh from Clarke is simply not on. Australian stock of great players have come to and end a while earlier and now they wont even have a good Captian. A few years from now we will see a team like NZ under the Baggy Green Caps - Good Competitors and good Sledgers but not enough fire power to back it up.

  • Something_Witty on March 29, 2011, 9:23 GMT

    Pup has done nothing wrong. There is no evidence to suggest he will not make a great captain. Best of luck to him.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • Something_Witty on March 29, 2011, 9:23 GMT

    Pup has done nothing wrong. There is no evidence to suggest he will not make a great captain. Best of luck to him.

  • DaisonGarvasis on March 29, 2011, 10:06 GMT

    The headline says it all. Clarke is as ready as he will ever be. To expect a Steve Waugh from Clarke is simply not on. Australian stock of great players have come to and end a while earlier and now they wont even have a good Captian. A few years from now we will see a team like NZ under the Baggy Green Caps - Good Competitors and good Sledgers but not enough fire power to back it up.

  • Melzu on March 29, 2011, 10:32 GMT

    please bring Dav Warner this time for bangladesh tour.. he is a very good an capable player in all formats of the game.. all the best for our new captain

  • on March 29, 2011, 10:34 GMT

    Wooooo what an article! Go Clarkey oh yeah!

  • StarveTheLizard on March 29, 2011, 11:17 GMT

    Wishful thinking Daison? There might be some flaws in the Australian system at the moment. The country is still a cricketing powerhouse. It will be pressing the top teams again before too long.

  • on March 29, 2011, 11:23 GMT

    well class is permanent with ponting I doubt about clark yet be filling ponting shoes as a aussie captain, his credentials are also doubtfull, whenever team needs him he failed and now captency things will get tougher for him...thats why cricket is called glorious game of uncertinites..aussies use to say breeding grounds of world champions..seems breeding has stoped after glen,shane,ponting etc

  • on March 29, 2011, 12:12 GMT

    and NOW we will see the magic and majesty of Maestro Michael Clarke.

    a great pity we could not have rid ourselves of boring Ponting a couple of seasons ago.

    i REALLY look forward to a comparison a couple of years from now :)

  • marcs on March 29, 2011, 12:48 GMT

    Gonna be a tough first year in office for Mr.pup. Clarke can however take pride of rebuilding the australian side (like border did in 80's) which is presently battered and bruised by the loss of few greats like gilly, hayden, Glenn and shane. good luck

  • NewYorkCricket on March 29, 2011, 14:03 GMT

    Not sure if he is in the same league as Ponting.

  • TEST_CRICKET_ONLY on March 30, 2011, 0:00 GMT

    Clarke hasn't been appointed yet, but if he is the majority of the Australian cricketing public will heave a collective groan. He is a very poor choice for captain, and his recent form suggest he shouldn't even be in the team. Of course he does have the distinction of being the only Australian captain to have been booed onto the field by a home crowd.