April 30, 2011


Why Fletcher isn't right for India

Andrew Hughes
Kapil Dev walks the ramp during the Wills India Fashion Week, New Delhi, October 24, 2009
Kapil's perfect logic: Just by walking the ramp you don't become a model so just because Fletcher coached England doesn't mean he's er a coach  © AFP


Tuesday, 26th April Today Alastair Cook called our attention to the plight of dozens of downtrodden cricket professionals, some of them earning as little as £100,000 per annum, who are forced to fly first-class, to train to a peak of fitness at someone else’s expense and to spend days at a time in five-star hotels. Comrade Cook complained that the modern cricketer doesn’t have enough say and implied that something ought to be done about it, whilst playing John Lennon’s “Power To The People” through his iPod speakers.

As a mood of militancy swept the golf courses, top-quality gymnasia and exclusive nightclubs of the nation, there were rumours that the England team might be about to go on strike. But after urgent talks, the Association of Stodgy Top-Order Grinders, the Federation of Flashy Cameo-Makers and the Union of Bowlers and Twitterers all agreed to cancel the planned industrial action on the grounds that actually they were rather well-paid, had lots of time off and really had very little to complain about.

Thursday 28th April The news that bookmakers have been arrested and some may have confessed to making death threats against Zulqarnain Haider has not gone down well at the PCB. Officials are being instructed to exercise extreme caution in opening newspapers, and in the event of being exposed to suggestions that the match-fixing problem is widespread, have been taught advanced emergency techniques, such as carefully inserting one finger into each ear and making, “la la la la la” noises.

I have had some personal experience in dealing with bookies. Not the kind you might find hanging around a hotel bar, offering leather jackets and well-stuffed envelopes to gullible young sportsmen. No, I’m talking about a different breed. In Pakistan, the bookies may be illegal, but they will at least take a bet. Here in Britain we have the opposite problem. Perfectly legal bookies who are reluctant to entertain the idea of taking your money if they think you might win. Prison’s too good for ‘em.

Friday, 29th April Kapil Dev doesn’t think Duncan Fletcher should be Indian coach on the grounds that he doesn’t really know who the man is and doesn’t remember him doing much as a player. Fortunately, India don’t select their coaches on the basis of whether Kapil has ever bumped into him at a social event or what kind of batting average he ended up with. Greg Chappell was one of the greatest batsmen of all time and Gary Kirsten wasn’t. But which of them is the better coach?

If there is a policy of deliberately not picking an Indian coach, then that of course would be absurd. But since we have no evidence that is the case, we have to assume that the BCCI has fallen back on the old-fashioned method of picking the best candidate from among the applicants. What counts against Fletcher most of all is not his sometimes gruff demeanour, his playing career or the fact that he doesn’t speak Hindi. It’s the fact that John Buchanan thinks he’s the right man for the job.

Be afraid India. Be very afraid.

Andrew Hughes is a writer currently based in England

RSS Feeds: Andrew Hughes

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by Arup Saikia on (May 7, 2011, 9:00 GMT)

Fletcher's surname recalls the occupation of "arrow-maker" - ideal retaliatory tactic against snipers (read past Indian cricketers) and probably mediapersons.

Posted by Andrew Hughes on (May 1, 2011, 8:55 GMT)

Thanks to everyone who took the time to comment. It would be interesting to know if there were any substance behind Gavaskar's claims that there is a policy of not picking Indian coaches.

Arun, I think I was on safe ground in calling Chappell G one of the greatest of all time. On averages, he is the second greatest Australian batsman, ahead of Ponting and makes pretty much any all time Australian XI that has ever been selected. But you have a point about Kirsten, he was a very good player and in trying to make a point, I unfairly underrated his ability.

JackieL, I agree with you, striking does take guts, particularly in those parts of the world where there is little protection for workers who take that step.

Posted by thepostmaster on (May 1, 2011, 7:25 GMT)

Gary kirsten wasnt a great batsman??? And greg chapel was a great batsman??? LOL, ur out of ur mind mate!

Posted by Raj on (May 1, 2011, 6:44 GMT)

"Greg Chappell was one of the greatest batsmen of all time and Gary Kirsten wasn’t. But which of them is the better coach?" - Whose comment is this ?. However it might i am absolutely certain that the person who has given this comment does not know much about cricket.On what grounds do they claim that chappell was a great batsmen and kirsten wasn't?

Posted by harish shetty on (May 1, 2011, 5:56 GMT)

we cannot I understand why the BCCI is preferring foreighn coach, why we don't have players coach our players. at present our team need no coach (technical purpose) is coaching required to players sachin,sehwag,dravid,laxman,dhoni,yuvi,bajji,khan. meaning less. the present requirement is mental booster that to be Indian ex stars like Mohinder amarnath and sundeep patil. because both are alrounders, both cane be useful for batsman and bowlers. These two should be appointed as coach for atleast 3 years with full authority. moreover, all the present cricketers like these two gutys

Posted by amedhora on (May 1, 2011, 5:54 GMT)

Robin Singh is best suited to be the national coach of India

Posted by subram on (May 1, 2011, 3:39 GMT)

It is unfortunate that former Indian cricketers are not being considered. I wonder whether this is the decision of the players or the Board.

Posted by Ajmer Singh Bains on (May 1, 2011, 3:14 GMT)

I am not commenting on Fletcher's suitability at all. What I wish to say here is that there should not be an undeclared prejudice against the coach being an Indian.

John Wright and Gary's shoes will not be filled by long shots.

Posted by Imtiaz on (May 1, 2011, 3:12 GMT)

to become a good coach you dont have to be a great batsmen or bowler. if that was the case sachin or murali should be the coach. but unfortunately this does not work. to be a good coach you should have good cricket knowledge, man management skills, spending time with team, and so on. I personally feel that a younger coach would have been ideal.

we know how so called indian greats trained during there days on fitness.

Posted by arun on (May 1, 2011, 2:47 GMT)

I think that duncan fletcher is too old for the job.

Comments have now been closed for this article


Andrew Hughes
Andrew Hughes is a writer and avid cricket watcher who has always retained a healthy suspicion of professional sportsmen, and like any right-thinking person rates Neville Cardus more highly than Don Bradman. His latest book is available here and here @hughandrews73

All articles by this writer