June 25, 2014

How do you solve a problem like Alastair Cook?

Just give him four years at the helm and be done with it

"I think this is the face that Twitter expects for #Facepalm #FTW #winning #LOL" © PA Photos

If you read English newspapers you might have formed the impression that handsome batting superhero Alastair Cook is a bit of a disappointment as a leader of men. Headlines such as "Calamity Cook" (Times), "Captain Comedy" (Essex Bugle) and "Cook's Concatenation of Cricket Clangers Causes Cereal Crop Catastrophe" (Farmer's Weekly) suggest that his captaincy skills are not particularly highly rated in his home country.

It isn't just the experts in the press box who feel qualified to point out his failings. Waitresses at the ECB canteen snigger that he leaves the salt too square and fails to move the vinegar in short despite that fact that Ian Bell always has vinegar on his chips. His neighbours shake their heads at the predictable straight lines of his vegetable patch, an orthodox arrangement that the modern slug has no trouble penetrating.

Even the England team coach driver regularly takes to Twitter to criticise Cook's choice of driving music, although with hindsight, his decision to go with Radiohead's "No Suprises" as his rousing pre-Gabba anthem was rather ill-judged.

So everyone agrees Alastair is rubbish. But just how rubbish is he, exactly? We know, for instance, that Phil Tufnell was rubbish at batting and we can quantify exactly how rubbish he was to two decimal places. We know, from looking at the stats, that during the 1989 Ashes series, England's bowlers flung more pies than a steam-powered pie-flinging machine during the 1851 Great Exhibition of Pastry Propulsion.

This is one of the incidental beauties of cricket. You can put a number on everything, then you can crunch the numbers and argue about the patterns that the number crumbs make. But the only captaincy stats out there are wins and losses, which don't tell the whole story, since so much depends on the quality of the players you're lumbered with.

Cook is accused of not being adventurous enough. But how do we measure adventurousness? Could we use the Warne Scale Of Adventure, which runs from 0 (Boycott) through 100 (Indiana Jones) to the full 200 (General Custer)? What about the effectiveness of field settings? Maybe we should introduce the IT Botham Correlation, in which the satisfactoriness of field settings is related to the number of commentary grumbles per minute. And what about those all-important inspirational qualities? Perhaps Alastair could give a team talk to some laboratory mice wired up to monitor their adrenal responses?

In the absence of any real data, all we're left with are the subjective opinions of cricketers. And we all know not to trust the subjective opinions of cricketers. Take this recent quote from Ian Bell, for instance:

"There is absolutely no doubt that Alastair will continue as captain. I don't think the tactics were wrong. I don't think he could have done anything more."

Of course, what he really means is:

"For God's sake don't sack Alastair because I'm next in line and there's no way I want to be leading this bunch of nobodies. I mean, have you seen them bat? Seriously, this team stinks, and I should know. I swear, if you make me captain, I will cry. I mean it. I will just start sobbing right there in the dressing room. Do you want that on your conscience?"

With no reliable way of measuring a captain's ability, the sensible solution is to give them all four years, regardless of results: a fixed-term appointment, like the US President or the Pope or the Queen. You might not think the Queen is up to it anymore, you might be scathing about the Pope's cardinal-selection policy, but tough. You're stuck with them for the duration, so stop whining.

And the good news for England fans is that under the four-year captain rotation policy, you only have another two years, two months and four days of Alastair to go.

Andrew Hughes is a writer currently based in England. He tweets here

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • BradmanBestEver on June 28, 2014, 11:56 GMT

    In recent times, Cook can only make runs against very weak pace attacks. The problem? He does not handle the extra pressure of captaincy well. The solution? Replace him as captain.

    Thank you linesmen, thank you ballboys

  • Praxis on June 27, 2014, 22:53 GMT

    Is there anyway out of this for Cook? I don't remember seeing this much criticism aimed towards any cricket captain in past decade & a half! You gotta feel for the poor guy. As all the pundits saying in article & TV, tactical awareness isn't something a dude's taught with over time, they just gotta have it from the very first. Doesn't make much sense but usual patterns shouldn't apply to a strange game like cricket.

    When Dhoni was captaining so badly(that 8-0 scoreline in overseas tours), people held back since he had such good record of world cup wins, IPL wins and obviously India's first ever ascension to top rank in test cricket etc. Plus the failure was largely due to lack of frontline seamers & that great,''great'' batting lineup being woefully out of form.

    Promises of rebuilding the team, sacking KP, Moore's employment as coach again & all those stuffs... everyone's run outta patience with Cook's captaincy, except ECB as it seems.

  • on June 25, 2014, 22:48 GMT

    Oh Ian Bell you are a true champion

  • on June 25, 2014, 21:27 GMT

    cook will score heavily against India. Inrian team is very big hearted and has a policy of helping the opposite team members in their hour if need..read Ponting,Pietersen,Younis Khan et al.He will score at least 600 runs against india. ...

  • on June 25, 2014, 20:31 GMT

    Bring on Indian bowling & all batting problems solved................runs runs & lots of runs .....vs Ind Batsmen only get out when they r bored of piling runs or r badly tired

  • on June 25, 2014, 18:36 GMT

    Cook will be boiling by English fans.

  • gmsjgmsj on June 25, 2014, 12:31 GMT

    Alastair will really cook the beans during the India tour. He will make ton of runs alongwith the woeful Prior and middle order batsmen. An almost certainity that Cook will score 650-700 runs, Prior about 400, Bell and Root 350, Broad getting 25 wickets.

    What more do you need to resurrect the flagging career than a series against India! That too a 5 test series... enjoy!

  • Quaker33 on June 25, 2014, 10:18 GMT

    It is not so long ago that Cook was being heaped praises for his excellent batting [down under] and his captaincy [sub-continent]. Clearly he is having a bad patch and it cannot be allowed to continue indefinitely ........but let's not be like the footballers who call for a sacking at the drop of every hat. Doubtless IF he resurrects his batting skills [which are already pretty outstanding] he will once again receive the huge plaudits of the very fickle media. Remember, form is temporary, class is permanent and anyway, supposing he is sacked, who would replace him and is there any evidence to suggest that such a replacement would be any better in the long run?

    Q33

  • Rawal on June 25, 2014, 7:27 GMT

    Hahaha! Quite funny!

    I think responding to Shane Warne´s criticism wasn´t a smart move by Alastair Cook.

  • BradmanBestEver on June 28, 2014, 11:56 GMT

    In recent times, Cook can only make runs against very weak pace attacks. The problem? He does not handle the extra pressure of captaincy well. The solution? Replace him as captain.

    Thank you linesmen, thank you ballboys

  • Praxis on June 27, 2014, 22:53 GMT

    Is there anyway out of this for Cook? I don't remember seeing this much criticism aimed towards any cricket captain in past decade & a half! You gotta feel for the poor guy. As all the pundits saying in article & TV, tactical awareness isn't something a dude's taught with over time, they just gotta have it from the very first. Doesn't make much sense but usual patterns shouldn't apply to a strange game like cricket.

    When Dhoni was captaining so badly(that 8-0 scoreline in overseas tours), people held back since he had such good record of world cup wins, IPL wins and obviously India's first ever ascension to top rank in test cricket etc. Plus the failure was largely due to lack of frontline seamers & that great,''great'' batting lineup being woefully out of form.

    Promises of rebuilding the team, sacking KP, Moore's employment as coach again & all those stuffs... everyone's run outta patience with Cook's captaincy, except ECB as it seems.

  • on June 25, 2014, 22:48 GMT

    Oh Ian Bell you are a true champion

  • on June 25, 2014, 21:27 GMT

    cook will score heavily against India. Inrian team is very big hearted and has a policy of helping the opposite team members in their hour if need..read Ponting,Pietersen,Younis Khan et al.He will score at least 600 runs against india. ...

  • on June 25, 2014, 20:31 GMT

    Bring on Indian bowling & all batting problems solved................runs runs & lots of runs .....vs Ind Batsmen only get out when they r bored of piling runs or r badly tired

  • on June 25, 2014, 18:36 GMT

    Cook will be boiling by English fans.

  • gmsjgmsj on June 25, 2014, 12:31 GMT

    Alastair will really cook the beans during the India tour. He will make ton of runs alongwith the woeful Prior and middle order batsmen. An almost certainity that Cook will score 650-700 runs, Prior about 400, Bell and Root 350, Broad getting 25 wickets.

    What more do you need to resurrect the flagging career than a series against India! That too a 5 test series... enjoy!

  • Quaker33 on June 25, 2014, 10:18 GMT

    It is not so long ago that Cook was being heaped praises for his excellent batting [down under] and his captaincy [sub-continent]. Clearly he is having a bad patch and it cannot be allowed to continue indefinitely ........but let's not be like the footballers who call for a sacking at the drop of every hat. Doubtless IF he resurrects his batting skills [which are already pretty outstanding] he will once again receive the huge plaudits of the very fickle media. Remember, form is temporary, class is permanent and anyway, supposing he is sacked, who would replace him and is there any evidence to suggest that such a replacement would be any better in the long run?

    Q33

  • Rawal on June 25, 2014, 7:27 GMT

    Hahaha! Quite funny!

    I think responding to Shane Warne´s criticism wasn´t a smart move by Alastair Cook.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • Rawal on June 25, 2014, 7:27 GMT

    Hahaha! Quite funny!

    I think responding to Shane Warne´s criticism wasn´t a smart move by Alastair Cook.

  • Quaker33 on June 25, 2014, 10:18 GMT

    It is not so long ago that Cook was being heaped praises for his excellent batting [down under] and his captaincy [sub-continent]. Clearly he is having a bad patch and it cannot be allowed to continue indefinitely ........but let's not be like the footballers who call for a sacking at the drop of every hat. Doubtless IF he resurrects his batting skills [which are already pretty outstanding] he will once again receive the huge plaudits of the very fickle media. Remember, form is temporary, class is permanent and anyway, supposing he is sacked, who would replace him and is there any evidence to suggest that such a replacement would be any better in the long run?

    Q33

  • gmsjgmsj on June 25, 2014, 12:31 GMT

    Alastair will really cook the beans during the India tour. He will make ton of runs alongwith the woeful Prior and middle order batsmen. An almost certainity that Cook will score 650-700 runs, Prior about 400, Bell and Root 350, Broad getting 25 wickets.

    What more do you need to resurrect the flagging career than a series against India! That too a 5 test series... enjoy!

  • on June 25, 2014, 18:36 GMT

    Cook will be boiling by English fans.

  • on June 25, 2014, 20:31 GMT

    Bring on Indian bowling & all batting problems solved................runs runs & lots of runs .....vs Ind Batsmen only get out when they r bored of piling runs or r badly tired

  • on June 25, 2014, 21:27 GMT

    cook will score heavily against India. Inrian team is very big hearted and has a policy of helping the opposite team members in their hour if need..read Ponting,Pietersen,Younis Khan et al.He will score at least 600 runs against india. ...

  • on June 25, 2014, 22:48 GMT

    Oh Ian Bell you are a true champion

  • Praxis on June 27, 2014, 22:53 GMT

    Is there anyway out of this for Cook? I don't remember seeing this much criticism aimed towards any cricket captain in past decade & a half! You gotta feel for the poor guy. As all the pundits saying in article & TV, tactical awareness isn't something a dude's taught with over time, they just gotta have it from the very first. Doesn't make much sense but usual patterns shouldn't apply to a strange game like cricket.

    When Dhoni was captaining so badly(that 8-0 scoreline in overseas tours), people held back since he had such good record of world cup wins, IPL wins and obviously India's first ever ascension to top rank in test cricket etc. Plus the failure was largely due to lack of frontline seamers & that great,''great'' batting lineup being woefully out of form.

    Promises of rebuilding the team, sacking KP, Moore's employment as coach again & all those stuffs... everyone's run outta patience with Cook's captaincy, except ECB as it seems.

  • BradmanBestEver on June 28, 2014, 11:56 GMT

    In recent times, Cook can only make runs against very weak pace attacks. The problem? He does not handle the extra pressure of captaincy well. The solution? Replace him as captain.

    Thank you linesmen, thank you ballboys