England news April 2, 2013

Morgan's IPL high-wire act leaves England hanging

Rather than getting first-class runs in England in April, Eoin Morgan will be enjoying the heat and glamour of the IPL - and putting his slim Ashes chances on the line

Because of a quirk of fate I'd rather not dwell upon, I found myself following the denouement of the Auckland Test from a cheap hotel in one of the less salubrious parts of Harrow. Don't be fooled by the public school on the hill, it can be a grim spot, especially when you are searching for a pint of decent real ale after a long drive.

It was a reminder of life without Sky TV and, dozing fitfully as England sought to bat out time, cursing that life had not entirely gone according to plan, I awoke occasionally to check the score in the closing session.

When not on ESPNcricinfo's ball-by-ball service, I kept abreast of things in Twitter. It can be rather disconcerting with nine wickets down to read 50 people screaming simultaneously 'Oh, Monty, what have you done!' without anybody thinking to attempt a spot of Neville Cardus in less than 140 characters and actually explaining what had happened, but I got the gist. I have such a wonderful mental image of that dive, I am reluctant to watch the real thing.

Anyway, England clung on and I fell asleep with the satisfying knowledge that after 15 days of Test cricket a 0-0 stalemate was a perfectly fitting conclusion. Not everybody gets it, but then not everybody needs to.

The first thing I wondered when I awoke the next morning was what did Eoin Morgan make of it all? Well, perhaps that was the second thing, after the usual issue of where the bathroom was. Was he entranced by England's heroic escape? Did he mutter that there was nothing to beat Test cricket? Was he consumed by dreams of making his own gloriously unexpected Ashes return this summer?

It would be a peculiar world if everybody was judged by their outpourings on Twitter, but that was where I had passed the early morning so I took a look. There were no tweets to be had on March 26 but on March 27, the day after the Test finished, he had his say. "IPL bound! No more training in the snow," he tweeted and, if you took one look at the accompanying picture - Middlesex's practice bubble at Radlett as temperatures collapsed towards freezing - you had to admit he had a point.

In this spring of all springs, a merciless assault on the build-up to the English season, for a talented and ambitious England cricketer to slip off to IPL excited about the clamour that was about to unfold was perfectly understandable.

Morgan has been full of excitement again today: "Opening ceremony tonight. Pitbull and SRK performing. Should be awesome." He has told a pre-IPL gathering in Kolkata that India is a beautiful country with beautiful people and beautiful food. He even expressed a hope that he could learn to cook it. It is to be hoped that Kolkata Knight Riders will give him a few matches this time. Outside England, nobody quite understands how good he is.

But forget for a moment an English landscape cursed by rain and cold, a landscape in which the trees remain bare and the birds are fighting for survival (you did ask someone to replenish the bird feeder, Eoin?) and substitute an image of the first Ashes Test against Australia at Trent Bridge on July 10. If Morgan's IPL jaunt puts him entirely out of contention, is his decision as wise as it first appears?

Morgan has a clinical mind to rival any England player in history. He can appear as calculating off the field as on, seemingly always in control, measuring his sentences as coolly as he appraises a limited-overs run chase. He is not the sort to find himself in a Harrow guest house when he does not want to be. If he is at the IPL then you can be assured he has examined his options to the nth degree.

On the subject of the Ashes, though, I'm tempted to think he has got it wrong. His analysis has become a self-fulfilling prophecy. He repeatedly indicates that he would come back early to England if the selectors indicated that he was seriously in contention for the Test series against New Zealand and the Ashes to follow. But life is not like that if you are on the Test fringes. It is not England's job to give assurances, it is Morgan's job to make a case.

His positive comments in January caused a little media over-excitement. "I would like to be involved in the IPL again because I have learned a lot from it," he said. "But more so I want to be involved with England this summer. It is two Ashes series and it's what everyone dreams of. But if I am on the fringes things will have to be thought about quite deeply."

"Knowing Morgan, he will fancy he can find an unorthodox route into the Ashes. A successful IPL followed by a triumphant Champions Trophy would be a start"

Then he was not chosen for the New Zealand Test series, thought deeply and decided to throw in his lot with the IPL. Middlesex's managing director of cricket, Angus Fraser, would prefer him at Lord's - and so would England - but Morgan is centrally contracted and the ECB has issued no instructions for him to return early. And anyway, he only averaged 18 for Middlesex in the championship last season. He is a big-match player with a dubious Test technique. He needs to find another way.

Morgan has yet to play a Test against Australia and lost his No. 6 position after a series of failures against Pakistan in the United Arab Emirates last year. Perhaps he regards his chances of an Ashes batting berth as slim. But he was selected for the Test tour of India before Christmas and those more highly favoured - the Yorkshire pair of Joe Root and Jonny Bairstow - have not made their case.

Root is the batsman in possession, but he averages 30 in four Tests and has not made a fifty since his staunch debut against India in Nagpur. He is undoubtedly a player for the future, but as yet he is a batsman of limited range and, as he blocked like a good 'un in England's backs-to-the-wall draw in Auckland, his range was restricting by the minute.

Without Morgan, unless Ravi Bopara suddenly returns to prominence, England will attempt to retain the Ashes with four defensive batsmen in the top six - Alastair Cook, Nick Compton, Jonathan Trott and Joe Root. It is to be hoped that Ian Bell does not go into his shell or England's batting, although potentially remorseless, will find it hard to seize the initiative. The danger is that they could allow Australia to bowl to them.

Knowing Morgan, he will fancy he can find an unorthodox route into the Ashes. A successful IPL followed by a triumphant Champions Trophy would be a start - as would be a deepening of England's uncertainty about who should bat at No. 6 when they face New Zealand in the two May Tests. There would be a precedent for him guesting for Somerset against Australia in a pre-Trent Bridge warm-up and, assuming he misses out at Trent Bridge, he has time to face Warwickshire at Uxbridge before the second Ashes Test.

It sounds too much like the best of both worlds. It would be a high-wire act audacious enough to impress Philippe Petit. It might well come to naught. But do not assume that Eoin Morgan has not already considered the percentages.

David Hopps is the UK editor of ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • P on April 7, 2013, 11:21 GMT

    Morgan promises a lot, but has not yet delivered consistently enough to be even close to KP in impact. He knows this, and is doing what is best for him- if I can't make enough runs for England, let me then make enough money for myself.

  • John on April 4, 2013, 17:47 GMT

    @Georgerarnold on (April 4, 2013, 8:40 GMT) To be fair he's done little to help himself. Yes Bell and KP even were worse than Morgan in UAE but I suppose they went on past form a little and Morgan never has had a run of decent form in the longer formats. On being dropped after UAE , EM made the right noises but all he did last season was play a handful of games for Middx and had a paid holiday in India. It was hardly the actions of a player hungry to get back in the Eng set up

  • George on April 4, 2013, 8:40 GMT

    I've been feeling a bit sorry for Morgan recently. During the last ashes, while Paul Collingwood was fading out of the England side, Morgan was in the touch of his life but carrying the drinks. He had 1 bad series in Pakistan (just as bad as pretty much the whole England team *Ian Bell*) and he's toast. The amount of time England persisted with people like Owais Shah or Bopara makes me feel like there's a mischief happening here. Cricket need entertaining players like Morgan, give the boy a run.

  • John on April 4, 2013, 4:40 GMT

    @o-bomb on (April 3, 2013, 14:57 GMT), "I doubt I'd have him as high as 3rd in the pecking order.": The fact that he was picked for the India tour suggests that he's still well up the list but I think that he may well have been there as much for his experience in India as anything else. "It's a couple of months away still, but there will be players scoring runs in the county championship by then. Unless they're clearly not right for the test arena I would select someone from that category ahead of someone who isn't playing first class cricket.": Exactly, which is why Morgan should play first class cricket rather than the IPL if he wants his prospects of a Test place to improve or even not worsen. If he was playing first class cricket and doing well then he would still be in contention but I see him dropping further down the pecking order if he doesn't prioritise first class cricket.

  • John on April 3, 2013, 17:02 GMT

    @Junaid Dawjee on (April 3, 2013, 9:42 GMT) Morgan has been very hit and miss for Eng for a while - possibly like a lesser KP. The facts are that if someone else - whether it be Jonny,Root,Woakes , Taylor or whoever does well in the 4 day game it automatically will put them ahead of Morgan. Listen , I don't begrudge him of the money/adulation at all and unless he gets injured I see him as nailed on for our shorter formats - even though guys like Wright and Hales are knocking hard on the OD door. However I don't see a good run in the IPL/Champions trophy etc doing him any favours re getting into the test side and neither should it. You wouldn't put guys like Trott , Compton or Cook in the T20 side after showing a run of form in the test side just like you wouldn't put the likes of Wright/Jos and Hales in the test side because they've knocked up some quickfire 50s in T20s

  • John on April 3, 2013, 17:01 GMT

    @IndiaNumeroUno on (April 3, 2013, 9:16 GMT) I thought Wright and Dimitri were both from England and both in IPL franchises the last time I looked but congratulations on another piece of inspirational wit and wisdom in words there.

    @Ennigmaa on (April 3, 2013, 10:59 GMT) This article isn't bigging up/hyping anyone so what's the point in your comment?

  • Adrian on April 3, 2013, 14:57 GMT

    @jmcilhinney - I doubt I'd have him as high as 3rd in the pecking order. Even if Root and Bairstow got injured I would explore other options before Morgan. It's a couple of months away still, but there will be players scoring runs in the county championship by then. Unless they're clearly not right for the test arena I would select someone from that category ahead of someone who isn't playing first class cricket. Either way as much as Morgan says he wants to play test cricket, those words don't mean much if he keeps going to the IPL. As you quite rightly point out though - that is his priority and nobody should hold that against him.

  • Nicholas on April 3, 2013, 14:52 GMT

    Morgan should never be in contention for tests. He is a short-format specialist IMO. England should not make the same mistakes as Australia and consider short-format specialists like Warner and Hughes for tests. Why worry about a series that you're never realistically going to be picked for? Horses for courses please David.

  • Robert on April 3, 2013, 14:28 GMT

    We seem all to be in agreement that Morgan (or at least his agent) has an exceedingly shrewd financial mind. Looked at from this angle, his brief and inconclusive flirtation with an England shirt has done its job - given him sufficient exposure and prominence to be a big fish in the IPL auctions; Kevin Pietersen has had the same logic in his chequered career - but he, of course, is ten times the batsman Morgan could even dream of being.

  • John on April 3, 2013, 14:11 GMT

    I must stress that I have no issue with Morgan choosing to play IPL. If that's what he wants to do then good luck to him. I don;t see him as the best option for Test cricket anyway but, from his point of view, if he wants to get back into contention then he is doing himself no favours. It's all about priorities. If the IPL is his priority then that's fine but if Test cricket is his priority then he's got to commit himself to it. He may still not make it but that's the risk you take and he apparently is not prepared to take that risk.