Ponting and the over-rate fiasco

'What was in his tea?'

Australia bowled only spinners and part-timers after tea on day four in Nagpur, in an attempt to boost the over-rate, a tactic that just about everyone found inexplicable

ESPNcricinfo staff

November 11, 2008

Text size: A | A



'Let's hurry it up here' © AFP
Enlarge

"In his most embarrassing moment in his 48th Test as Test captain in five years in charge, Ponting opted to worry more about improving Australia's sluggish over rate than going for broke to try and snare a must-win match when a result was clearly on the line."
The Daily Telegraph's Jon Pierik doesn't put too fine a point on it

"The first question you've got to ask is: how the hell can he keep making the same mistake? He has been in that position previously in this series; he has been fined and he has been warned about the slow overs but here we are again… He's the guy who takes up a lot of time talking to his bowlers, talking to his fielders about tactics, changing his field placings - and all of that just takes too long."
Ian Chappell is just about beside himself

"Myself as captain of the Australian cricket team, I feel I have a lot of responsibility to play the game in the right spirit, I have an obligation to try to bowl 90 overs in the day's play… The thing I'm most disappointed about is there seems to be this inference out there that I've put myself totally ahead of the team."
Ponting defends himself

"I might be concerned, I might not be. It depends on getting a clear understanding of the circumstances that ensured that we played the way we did after the tea break… I'd like to understand the situation."
Cricket Australia chief James Sutherland struggles to hide his bemusement

"I don't know what to make of all this. They go into the tea break on a high and come out worrying about over-rates... I am glad Ricky can't read my mind right now because he is not going to like it."
Another former captain, Allan Border, has a earful for Ponting but can't quite deliver it on air

"Whatever Ponting had in his tea, it did not help his judgment afterwards."
Archie Henderson in the Times finds a possible explanation

"I remember when I played it was considered a badge of honour not to have a drink in a session [apart from the scheduled drinks break]. And no one died from dehydration. These days there are far too many drinks breaks. It's ridiculous. But it is just not the captain's fault. It is up to coaches, referees and umpires to keep the show moving."
Steve Waugh joins the chorus of not-in-my-day critics

"It's easy to sit up in the commentary box and poke fire at the captain because of the decisions he's making out there."
Tim Nielsen rises to Ponting's defence

"One could never imagine Ian Chappell making such a decision in his day but if he had, I wonder whether the likes of Dennis Lillee and Jeff Thomson would have taken it with the same apparent grace that Watson and Lee did today."
Glenn Mitchell of the ABC looks to history and finds Ponting wanting

"I always thought he was an ordinary captain and this proves it. His captaincy calculator isn't that brilliant, is it?"
Jeff Thomson is not in a forgiving mood

"To give themselves a chance, the Australians needed to take four wickets in that hour… Did not the dressing room sense the mood? Do they not know that there is a tide in the affairs of men that must be taken at the flood?"
Peter Roebuck wonders at just how Australia lost the plot

"It's not the captain's fault and this was clearly a decision at the weekend made by four or five people."
Stuart MacGill thinks it was a committee decision

"I can't understand why the fast bowlers wouldn't bowl off a short run."
Mark Waugh believes there were other options that could also have helped the over rate

"We were quite happy to get a few runs on the board in that particular time."
MS Dhoni is not one to look a gift horse in the mouth

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

FeedbackTop
Email Feedback Print
Share
E-mail
Feedback
Print
ESPNcricinfo staffClose

'Pietersen plays the innings that matter'

Modern Masters: Many of his tons have been match-defining and his ability to score them quickly has boosted England's chances

    When Bedser bowled the Don for a duck

Ashley Mallett: After receiving a pasting in the first post-war Ashes tour, the England seamer decided he had to think up a new delivery: the legcutter

    Question marks over West Indies' ODI batting

Tony Cozier: The sequence of stuttering starts, with the middle and lower orders picking up the pieces, does not bode well

    Think you're better than the captain?

Cricket Captain 2014 is suited to the hardcore strategist, but its complexities and poor graphics may turn off the casual player

The power of booing

Jonathan Wilson: It has value when used against players who have transgressed - particularly if they have somehow offended the spirit of the game

News | Features Last 7 days

Test cricket's young Fab Four

Kohli, Root, Smith and Williamson will take turns as the No. 1 Test batsman. So far each has shown only one technical weakness

'I couldn't bring myself to set a batsman up by giving him runs'

Glenn McGrath talks about the method behind his metronomic consistency, visualisation, and why aggression isn't about sledging

Dhoni doesn't heed his own warning

Plays of the Day from the second ODI between England and India, in Cardiff

The curse of the Sharmas

Plays of the day from the third ODI between England and India at Trent Bridge

Utseya joins Brandes, Rossouw joins Tendulkar

Plays of the day from the tri-series match between Zimbabwe and South Africa

News | Features Last 7 days