June 11, 2010

Best of enemies

Following Sulieman Benn's spat with Chris Gayle, we look at other examples of team-mates falling out on and off the field
25

Gerry Alexander and Roy Gilchrist (West Indies)
Most cricket spats are little more than macho posturing, involving handbags and, very occasionally, fisticuffs. But things turned a little darker during West Indies' tour of India in 1958-59, when the terrifying, unhinged fast bowler Gilchrist allegedly pulled a knife on his captain, Alexander. A mutual enmity that had festered all series exploded when Alexander told Gilchrist he was being sent home for persistently bowling beamers against the orders of his captain; it was then that Gilchrist supposedly pulled out a blade. The incident has never been confirmed, but given Gilchrist's track record, it is not exactly beyond the realms.

Graeme Swann and "a senior paceman" (England)
Never mind who shot JR, English cricket has a mystery all of its own. Swann's spectacular professional and personal fulfilment mean that he can now look back on his debut England tour, as a painfully immature 20-year-old to South Africa in 1999-2000, as a rite of passage rather than something that cost him an international career. He alienated his coach, Duncan Fletcher, bonded with Jack Daniels, and was chinned by a team-mate whose identity has never been formally revealed, although he has been described as one of the "senior pacemen"). And the contenders are...

Billy Bestwick and the rest of the Derbyshire team
All performers are used to being heckled, but not by their own team-mates. That was the absurd scenario at Worcester in 1922, with Derbyshire's Bestwick the man involved. Bestwick, a notorious boozer, had been left at the team hotel after a typically zesty session the night before. Suitably peeved, and armed with hungover fury, he paid to get into the ground and spent the rest of the day abusing his own side.

Shoaib Akhtar and Mohammad Asif (Pakistan)
Shoaib could start a fight in an empty room, so a perpetually combustible dressing room full of cricket equipment was always likely to land him in trouble at some stage. In 2007 he was sent home from the inaugural World Twenty 20 and banned for 13 matches by the PCB after hitting Asif with a bat. Shoaib said that he struck Asif by accident during a fight with Shahid Afridi. "Please don't portray me as a villain," he said. "I am not a villain."

Dermot Reeve and Brian Lara (Warwickshire)
It seemed like the definitive no-brainer: signing the best player in the world, who had just hammered a Test-record 375. But even Brian Lara would also smash the first-class record, scoring 501 not out in his first six weeks at Warwickshire, his relationship with his captain, Reeve - who was exasperated by Lara's assumption that he deserved special treatment - soon took a significant turn for the worse. Their relationship reached a nadir when Reeve called Lara a "prima donna" and Lara walked off the field. Sixteen years on, it seems fair to assume that they are not on one another's Christmas-card lists.

Mike Atherton and Phil DeFreitas (Lancashire)
He eventually became an extremely popular player, but DeFreitas had plenty of fallouts as a brash, egotistical youth. His kit was famously dumped over the Grace Road balcony by Jonathan Agnew in 1987, after DeFreitas had poured the entire contents of a salt cellar over Agnew's lunch. That led to a move to Lancashire, where he had a strained relationship with a young Mike Atherton. DeFreitas didn't get things off on the best footing by introducing himself to his new team-mate with the words "I don't like students". It wasn't exactly the start of a beautiful friendship, in the short-term at least. "More than once our captain, Neil Fairbrother, had to pull us apart (it cost Fairbrother a broken nose once)," wrote Atherton in 2005.

Graham Gooch and David Gower (England)
On the field they complemented each other perfectly, becoming one of England's most productive non-opening partnerships, but off the field the ideological differences between Gooch and Gower were always going to lead to problems. They came to a head during the Ashes tour of 1990-91, most notably when Gower was fined for the Tiger Moth incident. He was dropped but returned briefly in 1992. The same problems remained however: one said tomayto, the other tomahto, and Gooch decided to call the whole thing off.

Ken Rutherford and Murphy Su'a (New Zealand)
Nobody likes to be dropped, but when that fate befell New Zealand's Samoan seamer Su'a before a one-day international in the early 1990s, he reacted more chippily than most. He refused to train and then allegedly called his captain, Rutherford, a "white honky p****". The two continued to exchange pleasantries for a few minutes before Su'a skulked off. He then tried to change his airline ticket so that he could fly straight home.

Peter Roebuck and Ian Botham, Viv Richards and Joel Garner (Somerset)
One of the saddest of all disputes. In 1986, as Somerset's golden era faded away, the captain, Roebuck, pushed for replacements for Richards and Garner, who he felt were past their best. Botham went with them, branding Roebuck "Judas", and it was clear from the start that these were wounds that would never heal. "Such was my fury with Roebuck," wrote Botham, "that I could quite happily have watched him drowning in the river behind the Taunton ground without feeling any need to pull him out, but the only emotion he inspires in me now is pity." When Botham was knighted, Roebuck said, "With its declining culture and absurd aristocracy, England is welcome to him, deserves him."

Michael Clarke and Simon Katich (Australia)
Hell hath no fury like an Australian cricketer whose baggy green love-in is interrupted. That was most evident when, in Sydney in 2009, Michael Clarke tried to leave the dressing-room to meet his girlfriend before the rendition of the traditional victory song, Under The Southern Cross. After what is invariably described as "a frank exchange of views", Simon Katich grabbed Clarke by the throat and the pair had to be separated by team-mates.

Don Bradman and Bill O'Reilly (Australia)
Great teams often thrive despite rather than because of their team spirit. That was certainly the case with the brilliant Australian side of the 1930s, in which Bradman and O'Reilly, Protestant and Catholic, headed two distinct factions. Though they had total respect for each other's ability, their differences were irreconcilable from the start. Bradman eventually purged O'Reilly from the side and later attributed the success of the 1948 Invincibles partly to the loyalty he was shown in the absence of O'Reilly and Jack Fingleton - both of whom became journalists, with Fingleton, in particular, not at all reluctant to exercise his right of reply. When Bradman was dismissed for a duck in his final Test innings, the press box reverberated to the sound of both men collapsing in hysterical laughter.

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Jambo22 on June 13, 2010, 13:21 GMT

    Did you consider Hadlee and Coney? They played in disharmony for quite a while and were not even on speaking terms. They would use John Wright as a middle man whenever they had something to say to one another, such as a field placement.

  • bommber on June 13, 2010, 9:13 GMT

    clem hill and peter mcallister had a 20 minute fight or wrestle trying to select the side to tour england in 1911.so its gone on for a while!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • david_robbo on June 12, 2010, 12:46 GMT

    I would have included Shane Warne and Scott Muller and the "can't bat, can't bowl" comment that was pinned on Warnie for a bit but that he apparently never made. That one was blown way out of proportion, especially given how poorly Muller was playing!

  • shiva89 on June 12, 2010, 12:14 GMT

    the same goes with azhar and kapil dev. azhar was captain during 1993-94 and don't know what happened to his relations with kapil dev that he made strive for wickets. It was the final series of kapil dev and he was to retire after the test. azhar didn't gave him enough bowling so he could not achieve his landmark (beating hadlee's record tally of 431 scalps). however, in the end kapil dev achieved it, but he had to toil hard for it.

  • george204 on June 12, 2010, 8:06 GMT

    @ Santosh Kudva - good point, I'd forgotten that Botham & Chappell weren't ever team mates, was just thinking about the sheer poisonous longevity of the feud.

    @EddyM - Botham may well be far from perfect, but Roebuck is hardly a paragon of virtue either & behaved fairly atrociously in the incident mentioned in this article.

    Another candidate for the list would be the Yorkshire dressing room of the '70s - basically Boycott & one or two supporters v everyone else!

  • RemyLeBeau on June 12, 2010, 2:06 GMT

    How about the whole current pakistan team?! or you can try just focussing on what shoaib malik has been upto these past couple of years (as everyone admitted during the recent inquiry videos)

  • EddyM on June 11, 2010, 21:21 GMT

    george204, it would appear quite apparent that botham is an unpleasant character - an outspoken bully. when he messed about with peter willey, willey retaliated and botham never tried anything on with him again.

    botham thought it was funny to get under the skin of his teamates, as geoff boycott says time and time again in one of his autobioghraphies.

  • on June 11, 2010, 19:16 GMT

    What about famous pakistani stand against Miandad in 1994

  • on June 11, 2010, 18:01 GMT

    @zak123kaif : I think dada was referring to Robin Uthappa; that statement was immediately after the CB series in australia, Dhoni was already a hero by then.

  • Jarr30 on June 11, 2010, 17:39 GMT

    Sidhu & Azhar's spat is well known during England series as it changed history and made careers of 2 of finnest players (Dravid & Ganguly). After Azhar decieded to drop Sidhu for the 2nd test, Sidhu was sooo angry that he stormed of of the dressing room and took the flight back to India and Kambli being injured, Dravid & Ganguly got a chance to play. Ganguly scored a century in that test and Dravid missed his century by 5 runs.There was no looking back for these 2 from thereon.

  • Jambo22 on June 13, 2010, 13:21 GMT

    Did you consider Hadlee and Coney? They played in disharmony for quite a while and were not even on speaking terms. They would use John Wright as a middle man whenever they had something to say to one another, such as a field placement.

  • bommber on June 13, 2010, 9:13 GMT

    clem hill and peter mcallister had a 20 minute fight or wrestle trying to select the side to tour england in 1911.so its gone on for a while!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • david_robbo on June 12, 2010, 12:46 GMT

    I would have included Shane Warne and Scott Muller and the "can't bat, can't bowl" comment that was pinned on Warnie for a bit but that he apparently never made. That one was blown way out of proportion, especially given how poorly Muller was playing!

  • shiva89 on June 12, 2010, 12:14 GMT

    the same goes with azhar and kapil dev. azhar was captain during 1993-94 and don't know what happened to his relations with kapil dev that he made strive for wickets. It was the final series of kapil dev and he was to retire after the test. azhar didn't gave him enough bowling so he could not achieve his landmark (beating hadlee's record tally of 431 scalps). however, in the end kapil dev achieved it, but he had to toil hard for it.

  • george204 on June 12, 2010, 8:06 GMT

    @ Santosh Kudva - good point, I'd forgotten that Botham & Chappell weren't ever team mates, was just thinking about the sheer poisonous longevity of the feud.

    @EddyM - Botham may well be far from perfect, but Roebuck is hardly a paragon of virtue either & behaved fairly atrociously in the incident mentioned in this article.

    Another candidate for the list would be the Yorkshire dressing room of the '70s - basically Boycott & one or two supporters v everyone else!

  • RemyLeBeau on June 12, 2010, 2:06 GMT

    How about the whole current pakistan team?! or you can try just focussing on what shoaib malik has been upto these past couple of years (as everyone admitted during the recent inquiry videos)

  • EddyM on June 11, 2010, 21:21 GMT

    george204, it would appear quite apparent that botham is an unpleasant character - an outspoken bully. when he messed about with peter willey, willey retaliated and botham never tried anything on with him again.

    botham thought it was funny to get under the skin of his teamates, as geoff boycott says time and time again in one of his autobioghraphies.

  • on June 11, 2010, 19:16 GMT

    What about famous pakistani stand against Miandad in 1994

  • on June 11, 2010, 18:01 GMT

    @zak123kaif : I think dada was referring to Robin Uthappa; that statement was immediately after the CB series in australia, Dhoni was already a hero by then.

  • Jarr30 on June 11, 2010, 17:39 GMT

    Sidhu & Azhar's spat is well known during England series as it changed history and made careers of 2 of finnest players (Dravid & Ganguly). After Azhar decieded to drop Sidhu for the 2nd test, Sidhu was sooo angry that he stormed of of the dressing room and took the flight back to India and Kambli being injured, Dravid & Ganguly got a chance to play. Ganguly scored a century in that test and Dravid missed his century by 5 runs.There was no looking back for these 2 from thereon.

  • Praveen_GK on June 11, 2010, 15:12 GMT

    What about Craig Mcdermott and Alan Border?

  • waspsting on June 11, 2010, 14:57 GMT

    @RajivRadha - you mentioned Marshall and Richards. What was that all about? never heard anything about it

  • on June 11, 2010, 14:52 GMT

    @George 204, while the botham-chappell spat is too well known to be missed, think this particular piece is about teammates locking horns. since u ask, spat between opponents might be just as entertaining as ones between teammates!

  • zak123kaif on June 11, 2010, 13:54 GMT

    If i remember correctly there was a spat between MS Dhoni and Sourav Ganguly when Dhoni after becoming the captain of Indian ODI team dropped Ganguly and then Ganguly told in an interview that "there is a player in the Indian team that has more number of hairstyle changes than runs he has made for India".At that time really Dhoni was indeed doing a lot of experiments with his hairsyle.

  • contrast_swing on June 11, 2010, 13:46 GMT

    what about Rashid Patel and late Raman Lamba?

  • RajivRadha on June 11, 2010, 12:18 GMT

    Please do another list:

    Sidhu & Azzar; Waqar & Wasim; Lillle & Kim Hughes; Gavasaka & Kapi; Butcher & Thrope, after Butch chosen as captain; Mcdermott & Border; Marshall & Richards; Lamb & Gower (read Lamb's autobiog); Shreeshanth & Habajan

  • george204 on June 11, 2010, 8:25 GMT

    Peter Roebuck's sour grapes comments about Botham's knighthood tell you all you need to know about his character, as do Ian Chappell's (though his character has been manifestly clear for years). Come to think of it, Ian Chappell v Ian Botham would have meritted inclusion in this list.

    But it looks to me as if the list has avoided the really easy ones - Lillee & co v Hughes, any Pakistan player v any other Pakistan player & Chapell v Botham would have been far too obvious!

  • on June 11, 2010, 7:40 GMT

    What about Harbhajan and Sreesanth? More melodrama than family soaps, I guess!

  • bschandramohan on June 11, 2010, 6:51 GMT

    navjot singh sidhu and Azharadin had a great spat too. Remember sidhu walking out of the Indian tour to England?

  • on June 11, 2010, 6:15 GMT

    and what abt the spat azhar and sidhu had during an england tour....can u throw some light on this issue as well and the one between kapil dev and sunil gavaskar plz

  • on June 11, 2010, 6:13 GMT

    i excpectd wasim and waqar to be mentioned here along wid a long list of pakistani players lol..

  • NeilCameron on June 11, 2010, 5:49 GMT

    12. Graeme Yallop and Rodney Hogg. Yallop was appointed captain during the 1977/78 season against England in a depleted lineup due to World Series Cricket. Young Victorian fast bowler Rodney Hogg was also chosen and he scythed through the England lineup on numerous occasions that series. Yet Hogg pretty much determined when he bowled and argued with Yallop when pressed to continue bowling. Things got to a head to the point where Hogg suggested that they continue their disagreement "behind the sheds".

  • nakihunter on June 11, 2010, 4:45 GMT

    I can think of a few more - Bradman & Keith Miller, Jardine & Nawab of Patawdi Sr, Kim Hughes & Rodney Hogg, Farookh Engineer & Abid Ali, Lala Amarnath & Vizzi, Richard Hadlee & Jeremy Coney, Manoj Prabhakar & Manninder Singh (I think one was chasing the other with a bat)

  • jazzaaaaaaaa on June 11, 2010, 3:48 GMT

    A couple of other incidents I'd throw in would be in the Australian side in the early 80s where it would be Lillee, Marsh and Chappell against Kim Hughes. Marsh felt that when Chappell wasn't playing that he should be the captain. Dennis Lillee, being his best mate backed him up and so a lot of the time there were disputes between those guys and Hughes. I was watching highlights of a one day match from around 1981 with Hughes as captain, Lillee clearly showed his dislike for the field Hughes set, its actually on youtube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ufzOqIqP7no There's also other incidents such as in the 93 Ashes, with Border giving McDermott a massive tirade. Shane Warne's dislike for John Buchanan, etc.

  • on June 11, 2010, 3:41 GMT

    Expected Wasin Akram and Waqar Younis to find a mention here. Nevertheless. Was "entertaining".

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • on June 11, 2010, 3:41 GMT

    Expected Wasin Akram and Waqar Younis to find a mention here. Nevertheless. Was "entertaining".

  • jazzaaaaaaaa on June 11, 2010, 3:48 GMT

    A couple of other incidents I'd throw in would be in the Australian side in the early 80s where it would be Lillee, Marsh and Chappell against Kim Hughes. Marsh felt that when Chappell wasn't playing that he should be the captain. Dennis Lillee, being his best mate backed him up and so a lot of the time there were disputes between those guys and Hughes. I was watching highlights of a one day match from around 1981 with Hughes as captain, Lillee clearly showed his dislike for the field Hughes set, its actually on youtube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ufzOqIqP7no There's also other incidents such as in the 93 Ashes, with Border giving McDermott a massive tirade. Shane Warne's dislike for John Buchanan, etc.

  • nakihunter on June 11, 2010, 4:45 GMT

    I can think of a few more - Bradman & Keith Miller, Jardine & Nawab of Patawdi Sr, Kim Hughes & Rodney Hogg, Farookh Engineer & Abid Ali, Lala Amarnath & Vizzi, Richard Hadlee & Jeremy Coney, Manoj Prabhakar & Manninder Singh (I think one was chasing the other with a bat)

  • NeilCameron on June 11, 2010, 5:49 GMT

    12. Graeme Yallop and Rodney Hogg. Yallop was appointed captain during the 1977/78 season against England in a depleted lineup due to World Series Cricket. Young Victorian fast bowler Rodney Hogg was also chosen and he scythed through the England lineup on numerous occasions that series. Yet Hogg pretty much determined when he bowled and argued with Yallop when pressed to continue bowling. Things got to a head to the point where Hogg suggested that they continue their disagreement "behind the sheds".

  • on June 11, 2010, 6:13 GMT

    i excpectd wasim and waqar to be mentioned here along wid a long list of pakistani players lol..

  • on June 11, 2010, 6:15 GMT

    and what abt the spat azhar and sidhu had during an england tour....can u throw some light on this issue as well and the one between kapil dev and sunil gavaskar plz

  • bschandramohan on June 11, 2010, 6:51 GMT

    navjot singh sidhu and Azharadin had a great spat too. Remember sidhu walking out of the Indian tour to England?

  • on June 11, 2010, 7:40 GMT

    What about Harbhajan and Sreesanth? More melodrama than family soaps, I guess!

  • george204 on June 11, 2010, 8:25 GMT

    Peter Roebuck's sour grapes comments about Botham's knighthood tell you all you need to know about his character, as do Ian Chappell's (though his character has been manifestly clear for years). Come to think of it, Ian Chappell v Ian Botham would have meritted inclusion in this list.

    But it looks to me as if the list has avoided the really easy ones - Lillee & co v Hughes, any Pakistan player v any other Pakistan player & Chapell v Botham would have been far too obvious!

  • RajivRadha on June 11, 2010, 12:18 GMT

    Please do another list:

    Sidhu & Azzar; Waqar & Wasim; Lillle & Kim Hughes; Gavasaka & Kapi; Butcher & Thrope, after Butch chosen as captain; Mcdermott & Border; Marshall & Richards; Lamb & Gower (read Lamb's autobiog); Shreeshanth & Habajan