Dileep Premachandran
Associate editor, ESPNcricinfo

Beware the IPL's success stories

When a player makes an impact in the IPL, it's no guarantee he's one for the future

Dileep Premachandran

May 10, 2011

Comments: 81 | Text size: A | A

Swapnil Asnodkar smashes it through the off side, Middlesex v Rajasthan Royals, British Asian Cup, Lord's, July 6, 2009
Asnodkar: not quite the real deal © Associated Press
Related Links

Do you remember the Goa Cannon? He's been silent, like an antique one on the rampart of an old fort, a while now. Back in the first season of the Indian Premier League, when it was the Garden of Eden before the scandals and the declining TV ratings, that was the sobriquet Shane Warne gave Swapnil Asnodkar. A franchise expected to bring up the rear stormed to the top of the table and stayed there, and Asnodkar played a huge part with his exuberant and chancy strokeplay.

He finished with 311 runs from nine games and his partnership with Graeme Smith at the top of the order was as pivotal to the Rajasthan Royals' success as Warne's captaincy and skill, Shane Watson's all-round prowess, and Sohail Tanvir's accuracy. Asnodkar was no Twenty20 specialist either. He made 640 runs with a highest of 254 in the domestic season preceding the inaugural IPL - albeit in the Plate division.

His ability to excel across formats convinced selectors to take a chance on him. When A teams from Australia and New Zealand came over later that year for a 50-over tri-series, he was part of a strong Indian squad that included the likes of Suresh Raina, Rohit Sharma, both Pathan brothers and Subramaniam Badrinath. While Yusuf Pathan, his Royals team-mate, capitalised to the tune of 270 runs in five matches, Asnodkar managed 23 in his three outings.

Run out twice and struggling against opposition much superior to any he had faced in the national arena, he was dropped before the final league game. Since then the story has been one of steady decline. When the IPL shifted to South Africa in 2009, he got eight games and scored just 98. Last season, when Naman Ojha did what he had once done, Asnodkar's two outings saw him make five runs.

When the panel of five, MS Dhoni and perhaps Duncan Fletcher assemble to discuss the limited-overs squads for the tour of West Indies, Asnodkar - whose only IPL match of the year has produced nine runs - will not be one of the names bandied about. Neither will Paul Valthaty's, despite the headlines generated by two remarkable back-to-back innings.

Back in 2008, seduced by Lalit Modi's claims about the league being at the cutting edge of cricketing excellence, the selectors got carried away. Manpreet Gony was given a go, despite an average first-class record, and a year later Abhishek Nayar was taken to the West Indies. Before that there was an opportunity for poor Ravindra Jadeja, one of Warne's "rock stars", to become the scapegoat for irate Indian fans as the team crashed out of the World Twenty20.

It's not just the selectors who have learnt the hard way. In the midst of a troubled Champions Trophy campaign in 2009 - the agony before the ecstacy of 2011 - Dhoni, usually the exemplar of calm, snapped at a reporter who questioned Rohit Sharma's omission from the squad, while citing his run-scoring feats in the IPL. The gist of his terse reply was that the IPL was not a benchmark for 50-over selection.

It's not just Indian players who have struggled to bridge the divide between the IPL and international cricket. Kieron Pollard has yet to prove Michael Holding wrong on the big stage against decent opposition. Tanvir never managed to hold down a place in Pakistan's XI, despite the churning caused by bans and scandals.

Is there any reason to believe that someone will leap across the chasm this year and take the international arena by storm? Not really. People often cite Yusuf Pathan as an IPL success story. But while it was his big-hitting heroics for the Royals that made him a household name, those on the circuit were aware of him long before that. For a batsman who plays in that unfettered fashion, his first-class numbers are impressive.

One likely debutant in the West Indies is Ambati Rayudu. But again, the IPL has only resuscitated his career. He was marked for special things long before that, with even the likes of Sunil Gavaskar praising him at the National Cricket Academy nearly a decade ago. Unlike Valthaty, he has a first-class resume as well.

So while the fans of their respective franchises clamour for the likes of Rahul Sharma and Iqbal Abdulla to be included in the touring squad, the selectors are far more likely to give first preference to those who have done their time on the fringes. If it comes down to a choice between Badrinath and Valthaty, or Abdulla and Pragyan Ojha, it's a no-brainer.

While the expansion to 10 teams has seen a drop in quality in the IPL - there simply aren't that many exceptional cricketers - it has also enhanced young Indian players' chances of getting noticed. With 70 locals guaranteed starting places in each round of matches, no one can cite lack of opportunity as an excuse.

What they must be wary of is of going the Asnodkar way. A season or two of the IPL may set you up for life financially, but unless it's backed by prodigious feats in other forms of the game, bigger honours are not going to find you.

Most of all, though, whether a player makes it or not depends entirely on how well they cope with the sophomore blues. According to Kumar Sangakkara, one of the few to have mastered all three formats, one of the biggest lessons that international cricket teaches you is adaptability.

"The first year is easy," he says. "Teams don't have a plan for you and you tend to slip under the radar. Then the fields start to change. You find all your scoring routes blocked and you think: 'How the hell will I score runs now?' I had to go back to the nets and re-tool my game."

Those who can will flourish. Others, like the forgotten Asnodkar, will have to be content with their Andy Warhol minutes.

Dileep Premachandran is an associate editor at ESPNcricinfo

RSS Feeds: Dileep Premachandran

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.

Posted by wambling_future on (May 13, 2011, 14:26 GMT)

No offense but I would like to see IPL get over as soon as possible. Like WC'07, IPL'11 is going on forever...

Posted by   on (May 13, 2011, 5:27 GMT)

With several big guns including Sachin, Sehwag, Yuvraj, Dhoni, Zaheer missing the ODI tour to Windies, I would like to see a 15 member ODI team comprising of Gambhir, Vijay, Rayudu, Kohli, Badrinath, Rohit, Raina, Yusuf, Uthappa, Iqbal Abdullah, Ashwin, Harbhajan, Munaf, Ishant & Sreesanth.

Posted by   on (May 12, 2011, 16:20 GMT)

I do not agree with you...Most of the new talent that the Indian team gets is from the IPL...It is one of the benchmarks today not only for the Indian team but internationally. Yusuf Pathan, Ravindra Jadeja, Murali Vijay, Vinay Kumar, Pragyan Ojha, Ravi Ashwin and many more Even Ashish Nehra made his comeback with a great performance in IPL 3. Otherwise it would have been curtains for his career

Posted by sriramsv81 on (May 12, 2011, 15:25 GMT)

Nice article. One more thing to add is the flat indian pitches. Difficult to predict talent. Sloggers you can. Also the mind set in odi's is different to t20's.

Posted by Naveen30 on (May 12, 2011, 15:23 GMT)

Rayudu Deserves a place. Great talent he is. He must have been in the Indian team 3 to 4 years back.... But unfortunate.. and also dirty politics iin the hyderabad team... good that he is not playing for deccan chargers.... others wise he could not have got this recognition today. thanks to sachin for encouraging this bright talent...... All the best Rayudu.....

Posted by   on (May 12, 2011, 11:39 GMT)

Whatever happens in IPL Badri, Rayadu, M Tiwari, P Oza, Rohit Sharma, Ishant Sharma, Pravin Kumar etc. are automatic choices for WI tour. As most them have already established themselves at national, A level, and international level. I am keen to see Badri and Rayadu as they have done very well in Ranaji. Badri deserves chance else it will now or never situation due to his age. Apart from that I wish fair treatment to P Oza and Ashwin, as they have proved their worth in the past. This is what we can wish only as better expertise and much more political momentum is driving the selection.

Posted by danieltcardoso on (May 12, 2011, 4:40 GMT)

each IPL throws up a likely superstar, If it was Asnodkar and Jadeja in the 1st edition, while Asnodkar failed on the bouncier tracks of S. Africa,and lost confidence therafter he has ben given a few oppurtunities. S. Afracan edition threw up Manish Pandey as the next big thing, then came M.Vijay, but failed in ODIs, Now its P Valthaty this year and Rahul Sharma, are they just shooting stars? in this IPL the result is known by the tenth over and seldom have we had close finishes,the increase in teams has diluted the quality of IPL-4

Posted by   on (May 12, 2011, 4:06 GMT)

Too long an article for too short a message which could have been conveyed in a one-liner! Yes, Dileep, its a no-brainer that IPL successes do not mean that the cricketer can play all formats successfully.

Posted by sweetspot on (May 11, 2011, 18:17 GMT)

It is only the players who are good in traditional formats that have shown consistency even in T20s. Look at the bowling and batting leaders - all are regular players! IPL may help to give a stage and an opportunity, but only true class can come out of it and express itself elsewhere. That is what DP is saying here and he is absolutely right. Where is Paul Flashthaty even now? Unfair to question his ability so soon, but seriously, without doing the hard yards, we won't find the good players.

Posted by sweetspot on (May 11, 2011, 18:03 GMT)

A lot of people imagine the IPL is indeed some sort of bar for the long term potential test of a cricketer. It simply isn't. It shows how some people's skills can come off looking great until a plan is forged against them. The true greats are those who survive and thrive beyond all plans made against them by the best peers in the world.

Comments have now been closed for this article

Email Feedback Print
Dileep PremachandranClose
Dileep Premachandran Associate editor Dileep Premachandran gave up the joys of studying thermodynamics and strength of materials with a view to following in the footsteps of his literary heroes. Instead, he wound up at the Free Press Journal in Mumbai, writing on sport and politics before Gentleman gave him a column called Replay. A move to MyIndia.com followed, where he teamed up with Sambit Bal, and he arrived at ESPNCricinfo after having also worked for Cricket Talk and total-cricket.com. Sunil Gavaskar and Greg Chappell were his early cricketing heroes, though attempts to emulate their silken touch had hideous results. He considers himself obscenely fortunate to have watched live the two greatest comebacks in sporting history - India against invincible Australia at the Eden Gardens in 2001, and Liverpool's inc-RED-ible resurrection in the 2005 Champions' League final. He lives in Bangalore with his wife, who remains astonishingly tolerant of his sporting obsessions.

Hangovers and headaches

2014 in review: Embarrassing defeats, a beleaguered captain, a bitter former star, alienating administrators - England's year was gloomy. By George Dobell

Ten years later

Gallery: Efforts by Surrey have helped transform a coastal village in Sri Lanka devastated by the December 26 tsunami

    'We did not drop a single catch in 1971'

Couch Talk: Former India captain Ajit Wadekar recalls the dream tours of West Indies and England, and coaching India

Sachin to bat for life, Lara for the joy of batting

Modern Masters: Rahul Dravid and Sanjay Manjrekar discuss the impact of Lara's batting

I bowled to them, look where they are now

Roger Sawh: Ever get the feeling you're sharing in the success of a top-level cricketer you may have played with growing up?

News | Features Last 7 days

Watson's merry-go-round decade

In January 2005, Shane Watson made his Test debut. What does he have to show for a decade in the game?

Why punish the West Indies players when the administration is to blame?

As ever, the West Indies board has taken the short-term view and removed supposedly troublesome players instead of recognising its own incompetence

Power to Smithy, trouble for Dhoni

Australia's new captain admirably turned things around for his side in Brisbane, leading in more departments than one

India's attack: rare intensity before regular inanity

For the first hour on day three, despite the heat and the largely unhelpful pitch, India's fast bowlers showed a level of intensity and penetration rarely seen from them; in the second hour, things mostly reverted to type

Bowlers in waiting

Bowlers who have been around for plenty of time but haven't played in cricket's biggest show

News | Features Last 7 days