India need their big three more than ever as tougher tests await

India are approaching the halfway mark of their Women's World Cup campaign and their performances have not lived up to the promise they displayed in the lead up to the tournament. They haven't come close to playing the perfect game, and Australia await on Sunday.

India's most severe problem is that their star-studded top five has been reduced to rubble and their innings has needed a lower-order rescue in all three games. They managed to recover well enough to win their first two matches but fell short against their toughest opponents yet, South Africa.

The trend in this tournament has been for most teams to lose five or six wickets by around 25 overs, but India's struggle stands out because none of their senior trio of Smriti Mandhana, Harmanpreet Kaur and Jemimah Rodrigues has made a half-century.

When compared to the other seven teams at the World Cup, India's top five averages 23.13, lower than all the other serious semi-finalist contenders England, New Zealand, Australia and South Africa. Among teams that have played at least two games, India are the only ones without a 50-plus score from their top five. It terms of run rate, India's top five is third from the bottom.

During the previous game against South Africa, Mandhana broke a 28-year record held by Belinda Clark and is on track to become the first woman to score 1000 ODI runs in a year. She has eight hundreds since the start of 2024; the most recent of those - 125 off 63 balls against Australia last month - was the second fastest in the format.

In the World Cup, however, she has made only 8, 23, and 23 so far. What was hard to believe was that her scratchiest innings - against South Africa - came on the flattest pitch India have played on to date. She was beaten frequently in Visakhapatnam and struggled against the swing of Marizanne Kapp before eventually holing out against left-arm spinner Nonkululeko Mlaba.

It would have been even harder to believe for the Indian camp because in their two training sessions in Visakhapatnam, Mandhana batted like she did during that century against Australia: taking apart the swing of Renuka Singh, middling aerial shots against anyone who bowled to her, and shuffling around her crease to hit anywhere she wanted to.

Mandhana's close friend Rodrigues was not far behind before this World Cup. She scored her first two ODI centuries in 2025 and her strike rate in a year was more than a run a ball for the first time. She had found success at No. 5, a position given to her only in 2023 after she spent her early years in the top order.

To be fair to Rodrigues, the first delivery she faced in her maiden ODI World Cup is a contender for the ball of the tournament: Sri Lanka's left-arm spinner Inoka Ranaweera used drift and turn from around the wicket to hit off stump. Rodrigues, however, fell to left-arm spin in India's next two games, too. She was lbw to Pakistan's Nashra Sandhu and lbw to South Africa's Chloe Tyron, missing the sweep on both occasions. Her highest score so far is 32 off 37 against Pakistan, but she might have not even got that far had Diana Baig not overstepped when she was on 2.

Harmanpreet hasn't had a magical year so far, but she's the sort of batter who can play a blinder out of nowhere, especially against India's next opponents Australia. She played a cameo against Sri Lanka when India needed more, struggled for rhythm against Pakistan, and got totally stuck against South Africa, crawling to 9 off 23 before mistiming an on-the-up push to point that drew instant criticism from Anjum Chopra for getting through the shot too early against the left-arm spin of Tyron.

You can bet on Harmanpreet raising her game against Australia, though, especially on the biggest stages. After her match-winning 171 not out in the 2017 World Cup semi-final, she nearly took India to the gold medal at the 2022 Commonwealth Games, nearly secured a place in the 2023 T20 World Cup final, and ran them close in the 2024 T20 World Cup, too.

Harmanpreet had hoped that the WPL, now three seasons old, would prepare India's lower order to handle crunch situations better than they have in the past. The previous three games have proved that India's Nos. 6 to 9 can dig the team out of a deep hole. The onus is now on Mandhana, Harmanpreet and Rodrigues to ensure they don't find themselves in one, as the race to the semi-finals heats up with tough fixtures against Australia and then England.