Matches (16)
IPL (4)
County DIV1 (3)
County DIV2 (4)
WT20 QUAD (in Thailand) (2)
OMA-W vs BAH-W (1)
CZE-W vs CYP-W (1)
Women's Tri-Series (SL) (1)
The List

Pretty bridesmaids

Batsmen and bowlers who turned in top-notch performances only to be outdone


Sorry, mate: Kumar Sangakkara's top score of 287 came in the Test where Mahela Jayawardene scored 374 © Getty Images
 
Two firsts were achieved during the third Test between India and Australia at the Feroz Shah Kotla in Delhi: Gautam Gambhir and VVS Laxman became the first Indian pair to score double-centuries in the same innings, and it was the first time Australia had had double-hundreds made against them. Laxman's unbeaten 200, though, was second-best, at least in numbers, to Gambhir's maiden double.
Double-centuries and ten-wicket match hauls are special feats, but often players have found themselves having achieved the mark only to be outdone by a team-mate, or an opponent, in the same match. For others such as Jim Laker, the competition was with oneself: he bettered his 9 for 37 when he took all ten against Australia at Old Trafford in 1956. This week The List looks at the innings and bowling spells that were bettered in the same match.
In recent years there have been three instances when two Sri Lankan batsmen have gone past 200 in the same innings. Kumar Sangakkara's top score in Tests, 287 against South Africa at the SSC in Colombo in July 2006, turned out to be the second-best in the Test, and the innings, since his team-mate Mahela Jayawardene scored 374, the top Test score by a right-hander. They even did the bulk of the scoring in unison: Jayawardene and Sangakkara added 624, a world-record stand that beat the 576 put on by Sanath Jayasuriya (340) and Roshan Mahanama (225) against India in 1997.
Besides Sangakkara and Jayawardene, only once have two batsmen gone past 250 in the same innings; only four times has it happened in the same Test. When Garry Sobers made his record-breaking 365 not out against Pakistan in Kingston, Conrad Hunte scored 260. The list also includes the two double-centuries in India's famous win over Australia in Adelaide in 2004: Rahul Dravid's 233 set up the victory, and Ricky Ponting's 242 still remains the highest Test score in a losing cause.
Highest second-best scores in a Test innings
Team Score BestRuns Second-bestRuns Opposition Ground Start DateScorecard
SL 756/5d DPMD Jayawardene374 KC Sangakkara287 v SA Colombo (SSC) Jul 27, 2006Test 1810
WI 790/3d GS Sobers 365*CC Hunte260 v Pak Kingston Feb 26, 1958 Test 450
SL 713/3d KC Sangakkara 270 MS Atapattu249 v Zim Bulawayo May 14, 2004 Test 1699
Aus 701 WH Ponsford 266 DG Bradman244 v Eng The Oval Aug 18, 1934 Test 237
Aus 659/8d SG Barnes 234 DG Bradman234 v Eng Sydney Dec 13, 1946 Test 280
Pak 581/3d Javed Miandad 280* Mudassar Nazar231 v India Hyderabad (Sind) Jan 14, 1983 Test 946
SA 583/7d GC Smith 232 ND McKenzie226 v Ban Chittagong (CDS) Feb 29, 2008 Test 1865
SL 952/6d ST Jayasuriya 340 RS Mahanama225 v India Colombo (RPS) Aug 2, 1997 Test 1374
Pak 555/3 Qasim Umar 206 Javed Miandad203* v SL Faisalabad Oct 16, 1985 Test 1026
WI 543/5d WW Hinds 213 S Chanderpaul203* v SA Georgetown Mar 31, 2005 Test 1745
Aus 650/6d WM Lawry 210 RB Simpson201 v WI Bridgetown May 5, 1965 Test 589
Eng 652/7d MW Gatting 207 G Fowler201 v India Chennai Jan 13, 1985 Test 1008
Pak 594 Ijaz Ahmed 211 Inzamam-ul-Haq200* v SL Dhaka Mar 12, 1999 Test 1450
India 613/7d G Gambhir 206 VVS Laxman200* v Aus Delhi Oct 29, 2008 Test 1891
Pak 674/6 Qasim Umar 210 Mudassar Nazar199 v India Faisalabad Oct 24, 1984 Test 996
Aus 674 DG Bradman 201 AL Hassett198* v India Adelaide Jan 23, 1948 Test 294
WI 563/8d GS Sobers 226 FMM Worrell197* v Eng Bridgetown Jan 6, 1960 Test 485
India 675/5d V Sehwag 309 SR Tendulkar194* v Pak Multan Mar 28, 2004 Test 1693
Eng 554/8d DCS Compton 208 WJ Edrich189 v SA Lord's Jun 21, 1947 Test 286
Pak 561 Imtiaz Ahmed 209 Waqar Hasan189 v NZ Lahore Oct 26, 1955 Test 414
Click here for the top second-best scores in a Test.
Fifty-one: that's the number of times two bowlers have taken five-wicket hauls in the same innings. The last of those instances was in 2006, when Steve Harmison and Monty Panesar took five-fors to send Pakistan hurtling to an innings defeat at Old Trafford.
Bobby Peel's 5 for 18 is the top second-best bowling performance in a Test innings: George Lohmann took 5 for 17 in the same innings as Australia were bowled out for 42 by England in the 1888 Sydney Test - the lowest Test total till then. Thrice in the Triangular Tournament of 1912, Sydney Barnes took a five-wicket haul along with a Frank: on two occasions it was Woolley, and once Foster. In Johannesburg the next year Barnes had figures of 9 for 103 and 8 for 75 in the same Test.
Click here for the second-best bowling figures in a Test innings.
For two debutants, Narendra Hirwani and Bob Massie, their two best innings hauls of their Test careers came in their first Test, against West Indies in Chennai, and England at Lord's.
Many double-acts account for the best and second-best innings figures in a Test, such as Johnny Briggs' astounding figures of 15 for 28 against South Africa in Cape Town in 1889, and Lohmann's 15 for 45 against the same team in 1896. Most bowlers who have had the best and second-best innings analyses in the same Test are from the pre-World War I era. The list is bookended by the performances of opposition bowlers in the famous Faisalabad Test of 1990. Both Chris Pringle and Waqar Younis took seven wickets in an innings - Pringle later admitted he tampered with the ball as he thought Pakistan's bowlers were doing the same - but Waqar's 12 for 130 overshadowed Pringle's 11 for 152, and Pakistan claimed a close win.
Two bowlers have taken ten wickets in a match in 20 Tests, though in none of these instances have both been from the same team. On 16 occasions when an Australian bowler has taken a ten-wicket match haul, an opposition bowler has also done the same.
Best second-best innings bowling in a Test
Best BBI Second-best BBI Match Ground Start Date Scorecard
JC Laker (Eng) 10/53 JC Laker (Eng) 9/37 Eng v Aus Manchester Jul 26, 1956 Test 428
SF Barnes (Eng) 9/103 SF Barnes (Eng) 8/56 SA v Eng Johannesburg Dec 26, 1913 Test 131
ND Hirwani (India) 8/61 ND Hirwani (India) 8/75 India v WI Chennai Jan 11, 1988 Test 1089
RAL Massie (Aus) 8/53 RAL Massie (Aus) 8/84 Eng v Aus Lord's Jun 22, 1972 Test 699
J Briggs (Eng) 8/11 J Briggs (Eng) 7/17 SA v Eng Cape Town Mar 25, 1889 Test 32
LC Braund (Eng) 8/81 H Trumble (Aus) 7/28 Aus v Eng Melbourne Mar 5, 1904 Test 82
GA Lohmann (Eng) 8/7 GA Lohmann (Eng) 7/38 SA v Eng Port Elizabeth Feb 13, 1896 Test 47
C Blythe (Eng) 8/59 C Blythe (Eng) 7/40 Eng v SA Leeds Jul 29, 1907 Test 94
NA Foster (Eng) 8/107 Imran Khan (Pak) 7/40 Eng v Pak Leeds Jul 2, 1987 Test 1077
RG Barlow (Eng) 7/40 FR Spofforth (Aus) 7/44 Aus v Eng Sydney Jan 26, 1883 Test 12
FR Spofforth (Aus) 7/44 FR Spofforth (Aus) 7/46 Eng v Aus The Oval Aug 28, 1882 Test 9
AV Bedser (Eng) 7/44 AV Bedser (Eng) 7/55 Eng v Aus Nottingham Jun 11, 1953 Test 372
W Rhodes (Eng) 8/68 W Rhodes (Eng) 7/56 Aus v Eng Melbourne Jan 1, 1904 Test 79
H Verity (Eng) 8/43 H Verity (Eng) 7/61 Eng v Aus Lord's Jun 22, 1934 Test 234
BJT Bosanquet (Eng) 8/107 FJ Laver (Aus) 7/64 Eng v Aus Nottingham May 29, 1905 Test 83
MS Kasprowicz (Aus) 7/36 PCR Tufnell (Eng) 7/66 Eng v Aus The Oval Aug 21, 1997 Test 1377
FR Spofforth (Aus) 7/62 T Emmett (Eng) 7/68 Aus v Eng Melbourne Jan 2, 1879 Test 3
RR Lindwall (Aus) 7/43 R Benaud (Aus) 7/72 India v Aus Chennai Oct 19, 1956 Test 431
W Bates (Eng) 7/28 W Bates (Eng) 7/74 Aus v Eng Melbourne Jan 19, 1883 Test 11
C Pringle (NZ) 7/52 Waqar Younis (Pak) 7/76 Pak v NZ Faisalabad Oct 26, 1990 Test 1153
Click here for the second-best bowling figures in a Test.
When Brendon McCullum and James Marshall scored 166 and 161 against Ireland in July this year, they became the first opening pair with 150-plus scores in the same ODI innings. Only twice in an innings, and thrice in an ODI, have two batsmen scored more than 150 each.
The days on which Rahul Dravid came up with his two best ODI scores - 153 in Hyderabad and 145 in Taunton - his team-mates achieved their peaks as well: Sourav Ganguly scored a career-high 183 in Taunton, and Sachin Tendulkar an unbeaten 186 in the other game - the best by an Indian batsman. On both occasions Dravid was involved in 300-plus partnerships, the only two such stands in ODIs.
In the famous Johannesburg ODI in 2006, Ricky Ponting's 164 pushed Australia to 434, the highest ODI total then, but Herschelle Gibbs' 175 helped South Africa achieve what most thought impossible.
In only one ODI has four centuries been scored; 14 have featured three. In 2006, Marcus Trescothick's 121 set Sri Lanka a formidable 322 to win, but centuries for Sanath Jayasuriya (152) and Upul Tharanga (109) in a record opening stand helped their team win at a canter.
On a few occasions two centurions have been surpassed by an opposition batsman. Gary Kirsten's 133 not out guided South Africa to victory at the Wanderers in October 2001 after Sourav Ganguly and Sachin Tendulkar scored hundreds for India; and Chris Gayle saw West Indies home with his unbeaten 132 at Lord's in July 2004 after the Andrews - Strauss and Flintoff - made centuries.
Highest second-best scores in an ODI
Best Runs Second-best Runs Match Ground Start Date Scorecard
HH Gibbs (SA) 175 RT Ponting (Aus) 164 SA v Aus Johannesburg Mar 12, 2006 ODI 2349
BB McCullum (NZ) 166 JAH Marshall (NZ) 161 Ire v NZ Aberdeen Jul 1, 2008 ODI 2727
SR Tendulkar (India) 186* R Dravid (India) 153 India v NZ Hyderabad (Decc) Nov 8, 1999 ODI 1523
SC Ganguly (India) 183 R Dravid (India) 145 India v SL Taunton May 26, 1999 ODI 1463
CH Gayle (WI) 152* JH Kallis (SA) 139 SA v WI Johannesburg Feb 4, 2004 ODI 2096
MS Dhoni (India) 183* KC Sangakkara (SL) 138* India v SL Jaipur Oct 31, 2005 ODI 2290
HH Gibbs (SA) 143 SP Fleming (NZ) 134* SA v NZ Johannesburg Feb 16, 2003 ODI 1955
Inzamam-ul-Haq (Pak) 137* Aamer Sohail (Pak) 134 NZ v Pak Sharjah Apr 20, 1994 ODI 911
NS Sidhu (India) 134* RA Smith (Eng) 129 India v Eng Gwalior Mar 4, 1993 ODI 813
BC Lara (WI) 153 Basit Ali (Pak) 127* Pak v WI Sharjah Nov 5, 1993 ODI 845
G Kirsten (SA) 133* SC Ganguly (India) 127 SA v India Johannesburg Oct 5, 2001 ODI 1752
Saeed Anwar (Pak) 140 SC Ganguly (India) 124 India v Pak Dhaka Jan 18, 1998 ODI 1279
ND McKenzie (SA) 131* G Kirsten (SA) 124 SA v Kenya Cape Town Oct 22, 2001 ODI 1763
A Symonds (Aus) 151 RT Ponting (Aus) 124 Aus v SL Sydney Feb 12, 2006 ODI 2328
CH Gayle (WI) 132* A Flintoff (Eng) 123 Eng v WI Lord's Jul 6, 2004 ODI 2140
CH Gayle (WI) 132 HH Dippenaar (SA) 123 WI v SA Bridgetown May 11, 2005 ODI 2243
KO Otieno (Kenya) 144 DN Chudasama (Kenya) 122 Kenya v Ban Nairobi (Gym) Oct 10, 1997 ODI 1239
DJ Cullinan (SA) 124 JN Rhodes (SA) 121 Pak v SA Nairobi (Gym) Sep 29, 1996 ODI 1121
KJJ van Noortwijk (Neth) 134* JF Kloppenburg (Neth) 121 Namib v Neth Bloemfontein Mar 3, 2003 ODI 1978
ST Jayasuriya (SL) 152 ME Trescothick (Eng) 121 Eng v SL Leeds Jul 1, 2006 ODI 2389
Gary Cosier and Greg Chappell are the only bowlers to evenly share all ten wickets in an ODI innings, against England at Edgbaston in 1977. Cosier took 5 for 18, and Chappell's 5 for 20 is the best second-best bowling performance in a match. Surprisingly, Australia lost the game, dismissed for 70 chasing 172.
In the course of his short, injury-plagued international career, Shane Bond's best figures of 6 for 23 nearly derailed Australia during the 2003 World Cup, before a late fightback and Brett Lee's 5 for 42 ensured a win for the eventual champions.
Two bowlers who took five-fors in the 1983 World Cup ended on the losing side. Ashantha de Mel had figures of 5 for 39 against Pakistan, but Abdul Qadir's 5 for 44 clinched a 11-run win. Kapil Dev's best ODI bowling figures, 5 for 43, weren't enough for India to win a league game against Australia at Trent Bridge: Ken MacLeay's 6 for 39 sealed an emphatic 152-run win.
Best second-best bowling performances in an ODI
Best BBI Second-best BBIMatch Ground Start Date Scorecard
GJ Cosier (Aus) 5/18 GS Chappell (Aus) 5/20 Eng v Aus BirminghamJun 4, 1977 ODI 43
PW Jarvis (Eng) 5/35 J Srinath (India)5/41 India v Eng Bangalore Feb 26, 1993 ODI 809
SE Bond (NZ) 6/23 B Lee (Aus) 5/42 Aus v NZPort Elizabeth Mar 11, 2003 ODI 1986
KH MacLeay (Aus) 6/39N Kapil Dev (India) 5/43 Aus v India Nottingham Jun 13, 1983 ODI 207
ALF de Mel (SL) 5/39 Abdul Qadir (Pak) 5/44 Pak v SLLeeds Jun 16, 1983 ODI 211
N Chopra (India) 5/21M Dillon (WI) 5/51 India v WI Toronto Sep 14, 1999 ODI 1499
CM Old (Eng) 4/8 RGD Willis (Eng) 4/11 Eng v CanManchester Jun 13, 1979 ODI 67
GD McGrath (Aus) 4/8A Symonds (Aus) 4/11 Aus v India Sydney Jan 14, 2000 ODI 1540
MS Kasprowicz (Aus) 4/14 JN Gillespie (Aus) 4/15 Aus v USASouthampton Sep 13, 2004 ODI 2172
IK Pathan (India) 5/27AB Agarkar (India) 4/18 Zim v India Harare Aug 29, 2005 ODI 2274
SM Pollock (SA) 5/20 AR Caddick (Eng) 4/19 SA v EngJohannesburg Feb 13, 2000 ODI 1560
AME Roberts (WI) 5/22CL King (WI) 4/23 Eng v WI Adelaide Jan 16, 1980 ODI 84
JDP Oram (NZ) 5/26 J Srinath (India) 4/23 NZ v IndiaAuckland Dec 26, 2002 ODI 1926
Waqar Younis (Pak) 6/30GR Larsen (NZ) 4/24 NZ v Pak Auckland Mar 13, 1994 ODI 894
HH Streak (Zim) 4/8 CE Cuffy (WI) 4/24 WI v ZimSydney Jan 23, 2001 ODI 1675
A Flintoff (Eng) 4/21DL Vettori (NZ) 4/24 Eng v NZ Adelaide Jan 23, 2007 ODI 2482
ARC Fraser (Eng) 4/22 GD McGrath (Aus) 4/25 Aus v EngMelbourne Jan 10, 1995 ODI 969
AM Stuart (Aus) 5/26Wasim Akram (Pak) 4/25 Aus v Pak Melbourne Jan 16, 1997 ODI 1164
Mushtaq Ahmed (Pak) 4/22 RD King (WI) 4/25 WI v PakPort of Spain Apr 23, 2000 ODI 1595
SC Ganguly (India) 5/34AB Agarkar (India) 4/25 India v Zim Kanpur Dec 11, 2000 ODI 1659
Click here for the full tables.
If there's a particular List that you would like to see, email us with your comments and suggestions.

Travis Basevi is the man who built Statsguru. Mathew Varghese is sub-editor (stats) at Cricinfo