India July 13, 2011

Fletcher's grumble pie

The India coach is up to his old tricks again
14

Sunday, 10th July One series in and Duncan is already hitting his grumpy straps. After the Dominica Test, he came to the media party, stepped up to the plate, picked up the plate and helped himself to a steaming portion of grumble pie. Old chubby cheeks was in the firing line because his new team had offended a certain section of Indian fandom by settling for a draw. Having explained to the gentlemen of the press that he thought it was the right thing to do, he was most put out to have to repeat himself and it kind of went downhill from there. Good to see that Fletch hasn’t lost his PR touch.

But was a draw so bad? The blessed Australians are often invoked at such times, but I don’t recall AB’s team risking a series win with a brave run-chase. We would all like cricket to be played in the spirit of the Golden Age, by characters out to entertain, for whom cricket is a pleasant diversion from more serious pursuits like fox-hunting, gambling and partying. But we are in the era of the drab professional and results are everything. Those are the rules. It’s not Duncan’s fault.

Monday, 11th July Shahid Afridi is unhappy and is promising to unmask the people who are running a smear campaign against him. This is a touch melodramatic. And superfluous. When the smearing is carried out in an interview with a major newspaper, unmasking is not required. Even if the smearer had been wearing a Batman mask, and had given his name as Jazzy B Hutt, we would still have known who was behind it.

And besides the odd smear, as you might expect, Mr Butt’s interview had its share of crimes against logic. For example, the man who appointed Afridi as captain (for it was he) apparently thinks Afridi isn’t captaincy material. And then there was this:

“In my opinion, which may be considered by some people wrong,* he is responsible for losses in the fourth and fifth one-day internationals.”

Really? He may not have had the best of games in Guyana and Barbados, but he was ably assisted by at least ten other suspects, all of whom should have been in the frame for the blame. And oh yes, he won the series. Not to mention reaching the World Cup semi-final. Clearly the man was a failure. Let us hope that when Shahid becomes Chairman of the PCB in around 2031, he too has learned the art of logic abuse.

Tuesday, 12th July Mitchell Johnson doesn’t want anything to do with the BBL. My first reaction to this news was to ask my computer what the Brett Geeves was the BBL? The Big Brother Love-in? The Baked Bean Luge? The Board of Banal Linguistics? Then I remembered. Of course! It’s the Big Bash League, Australia’s answer to the question, “Is there anything we can do to make the world a more irritating place.”

That Johnson has decided to spend time learning how to hold a cricket ball rather than perform for the Perth Ponderers is refreshing, but it isn’t really news. The news is that, apparently, Cricket Australia is encouraging its players to take part in this superfluous franchised-up PR stunt. And why? Because if the top Aussie pros join in, it will help ensure the success of the competition. Clearly the financial viability of the Big Banana League is priority number one for the administrators of the world’s fifth-ranked Test nation.

* Perish the thought, sir

Andrew Hughes is a writer currently based in England

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Going South on July 14, 2011, 15:50 GMT

    I am a regular reader of The Long Handle and this is one of those very good posts from you Andrew. For BCCI, the job description for a coach is little different from the usual, with more importance on him being a good PR man that follow the company line that avoids controversy [rather than attracting it]. Thus DF is a very good fit. LOL@Big Banana League, if ACB keep giving more importance to BBL over everything else, they might end up even below that fifth rank.

  • viper on July 14, 2011, 5:13 GMT

    well, one solution is force a result from tests too...for the 2nd innings of the team batting second, if the duration remaining is less than a certain amount (perhaps based on the average time per innings), let D/L kick in and let it be a run-chase to the finish.

    this will force the team batting first to think strategically - to put up a large score or to put up a fast score. surely, there are refinements of this idea that they will need to work on...this is just a thought starter.

  • Alfred on July 14, 2011, 0:21 GMT

    We would all like cricket to be played in the spirit of the Golden Age, by characters out to entertain, for whom cricket is a pleasant diversion from more serious pursuits like fox-hunting, gambling and partying - Classic!!!

  • Vinay on July 14, 2011, 0:13 GMT

    The team that doesn't believe they can bat 10 or 15 overs after being 5 or 6 down is not really a champion as far as I'm concerned. I think India still had at least a couple more wickets to Gamble safely enough with before concluding it was too risky to chase.

  • sivaraman on July 13, 2011, 22:02 GMT

    Wonderful Article...Even if India would have been brave and chased and if we would have won the test match at Dominica, ICC ranking does not give great points...We are number one and we stay so...We should be happy with the 1-0 win Vs WI....if there is something to Blame it should be the weather which spoiled our chances in this series so much...Sammy has said they will finish in top 5 by 2015....let us see if they stay in the Test playing Nations list by then....

  • Faldo on July 13, 2011, 19:19 GMT

    Well, I'm sure those actually doing the job on the field knew best and in their wisdom decided that risking a series win was not called for. Point taken. However, could they not have tried to give the West Indians a scare, in attempting a chase at least during the start of their innings? It would have given them a better idea of how much they could be stretched if they faced a similar situation, say against a more formidable opposition.

  • CollisKing on July 13, 2011, 19:17 GMT

    Will the Aussie 'big bash league' find new ways to out-ad the IPL in their TV coverage?* We already have ads at the end of every over, ads at the fall of every wicket, ads at drinks. How about ad breaks at the beginning of the bowler's run-up, an ad break while the umpire is thinking about it before the finger goes up, compulsory ad break during all-run 4's etc. etc. and of course extended ad-breaks when the umpire needs the evidence for tight run-outs and did he or didn't he drag it back in time diving to save that boundary ?

    *so they tell me, as a cricket fan I have never watched a T20 game in my life.

  • Jingle Bell on July 13, 2011, 18:14 GMT

    Haha...chubby cheeks!!!!! very nice post.

  • praxis on July 13, 2011, 15:46 GMT

    I followed that test match for 5 days, went crazy when Kirk Edwards almost ran himself out on 99, waited Chanders to score his century, then at late night when I was preparing myself with half a liter of turkish coffee in my stomach for the final hour expecting a miraculous collapse in Indian batting order, then...well, you all know what happened. Maybe Dhoni & co was right with that decision but for most of us who were watching it was very frustrating. But I think that many Indian fans are making a huge deal out of it. "The blessed Australians are often invoked at such times", as Andrew Hughes writes here is quite unnecessary. India surely sits at the top of ranking but they aren't a great side as WI or Australia were.

  • crazykric on July 13, 2011, 10:54 GMT

    Fantastic read. Loved the part about Afridi and Butt.

    Afridi is realling thinking everyone a fool when he said he will unmask the people who are running a smear campaign against him. It's like defending the PCB chariman even when the Butt is tarnishing his reputation. Rather than pointing directly at him, Afridi is blaming anonymous people. I seriously hope he doesn't now say that it's actually the US or Israel which is behind his smear campaign.

  • Going South on July 14, 2011, 15:50 GMT

    I am a regular reader of The Long Handle and this is one of those very good posts from you Andrew. For BCCI, the job description for a coach is little different from the usual, with more importance on him being a good PR man that follow the company line that avoids controversy [rather than attracting it]. Thus DF is a very good fit. LOL@Big Banana League, if ACB keep giving more importance to BBL over everything else, they might end up even below that fifth rank.

  • viper on July 14, 2011, 5:13 GMT

    well, one solution is force a result from tests too...for the 2nd innings of the team batting second, if the duration remaining is less than a certain amount (perhaps based on the average time per innings), let D/L kick in and let it be a run-chase to the finish.

    this will force the team batting first to think strategically - to put up a large score or to put up a fast score. surely, there are refinements of this idea that they will need to work on...this is just a thought starter.

  • Alfred on July 14, 2011, 0:21 GMT

    We would all like cricket to be played in the spirit of the Golden Age, by characters out to entertain, for whom cricket is a pleasant diversion from more serious pursuits like fox-hunting, gambling and partying - Classic!!!

  • Vinay on July 14, 2011, 0:13 GMT

    The team that doesn't believe they can bat 10 or 15 overs after being 5 or 6 down is not really a champion as far as I'm concerned. I think India still had at least a couple more wickets to Gamble safely enough with before concluding it was too risky to chase.

  • sivaraman on July 13, 2011, 22:02 GMT

    Wonderful Article...Even if India would have been brave and chased and if we would have won the test match at Dominica, ICC ranking does not give great points...We are number one and we stay so...We should be happy with the 1-0 win Vs WI....if there is something to Blame it should be the weather which spoiled our chances in this series so much...Sammy has said they will finish in top 5 by 2015....let us see if they stay in the Test playing Nations list by then....

  • Faldo on July 13, 2011, 19:19 GMT

    Well, I'm sure those actually doing the job on the field knew best and in their wisdom decided that risking a series win was not called for. Point taken. However, could they not have tried to give the West Indians a scare, in attempting a chase at least during the start of their innings? It would have given them a better idea of how much they could be stretched if they faced a similar situation, say against a more formidable opposition.

  • CollisKing on July 13, 2011, 19:17 GMT

    Will the Aussie 'big bash league' find new ways to out-ad the IPL in their TV coverage?* We already have ads at the end of every over, ads at the fall of every wicket, ads at drinks. How about ad breaks at the beginning of the bowler's run-up, an ad break while the umpire is thinking about it before the finger goes up, compulsory ad break during all-run 4's etc. etc. and of course extended ad-breaks when the umpire needs the evidence for tight run-outs and did he or didn't he drag it back in time diving to save that boundary ?

    *so they tell me, as a cricket fan I have never watched a T20 game in my life.

  • Jingle Bell on July 13, 2011, 18:14 GMT

    Haha...chubby cheeks!!!!! very nice post.

  • praxis on July 13, 2011, 15:46 GMT

    I followed that test match for 5 days, went crazy when Kirk Edwards almost ran himself out on 99, waited Chanders to score his century, then at late night when I was preparing myself with half a liter of turkish coffee in my stomach for the final hour expecting a miraculous collapse in Indian batting order, then...well, you all know what happened. Maybe Dhoni & co was right with that decision but for most of us who were watching it was very frustrating. But I think that many Indian fans are making a huge deal out of it. "The blessed Australians are often invoked at such times", as Andrew Hughes writes here is quite unnecessary. India surely sits at the top of ranking but they aren't a great side as WI or Australia were.

  • crazykric on July 13, 2011, 10:54 GMT

    Fantastic read. Loved the part about Afridi and Butt.

    Afridi is realling thinking everyone a fool when he said he will unmask the people who are running a smear campaign against him. It's like defending the PCB chariman even when the Butt is tarnishing his reputation. Rather than pointing directly at him, Afridi is blaming anonymous people. I seriously hope he doesn't now say that it's actually the US or Israel which is behind his smear campaign.

  • Ryan on July 13, 2011, 9:32 GMT

    Let's say that India had tried for it and lost a few wickets cheaply causing them to shut up and abandon the chase. Let's imagine that when the match is called off the score is say 130 for 6. Let's suppose that WI would then be delighted with a draw and claim a moral victory ......Oh wait , different scenario, same results.....

  • rob heinen on July 13, 2011, 9:02 GMT

    I can remember David Lloyd saying on Sky that T20 was supposed to be fun. It drew great crowds to stadiums that were empty up until then. This was going to be the money maker........Except for the fact that the crowd drawn is of the I-want-it-and-I-want-it-now kind which is by default a crowd of none-stayers. Which is exactly what happened to T20 in the UK. The numbers that pass the turnstile are dwindling. T20 in the UK is dead and the ones not recognizing this are the ECB, the investors and Sky. Oh, and obviously all fun is gone. Not only for the spectators. They already found a new 'fun'. There's no more fun for the players as well. It's become a serious matter. But what else can you expect from professional sportsmen. They are hired for their attitude of always wanting to win.

  • ravi Shankar on July 13, 2011, 8:43 GMT

    Hey, i loved this piece. I mean the humour in the information !! Great. But... oh isnt there always a but..why are cricket writers, the 'gurus' and a lot of the rest of us, saying that Dhoni along with his coach, didnt want to play for broke ?? Well, my take is he could have given it a big go and then if it didnt work,after losing a few wickets clamp down !! period .....you could have tried to win but that doesnt mean you would alos loose.

  • Sunil on July 13, 2011, 8:34 GMT

    And people wonder why test matches are such a bore. If you have watched 5 days of test cricket and the end result is an early finish and a draw, why bother watching in the first place. What if England and Sri Lanka in Cardiff had the same attitude in the first test. If test cricket really wants to survive in the 21st Century then more risks need to be taken. Try and explain to a young 9 year old why the match ended in a draw is difficult in the world of T20 and one day internationals. By the end of the century unless attitudes change, Test Matches RIP.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • Sunil on July 13, 2011, 8:34 GMT

    And people wonder why test matches are such a bore. If you have watched 5 days of test cricket and the end result is an early finish and a draw, why bother watching in the first place. What if England and Sri Lanka in Cardiff had the same attitude in the first test. If test cricket really wants to survive in the 21st Century then more risks need to be taken. Try and explain to a young 9 year old why the match ended in a draw is difficult in the world of T20 and one day internationals. By the end of the century unless attitudes change, Test Matches RIP.

  • ravi Shankar on July 13, 2011, 8:43 GMT

    Hey, i loved this piece. I mean the humour in the information !! Great. But... oh isnt there always a but..why are cricket writers, the 'gurus' and a lot of the rest of us, saying that Dhoni along with his coach, didnt want to play for broke ?? Well, my take is he could have given it a big go and then if it didnt work,after losing a few wickets clamp down !! period .....you could have tried to win but that doesnt mean you would alos loose.

  • rob heinen on July 13, 2011, 9:02 GMT

    I can remember David Lloyd saying on Sky that T20 was supposed to be fun. It drew great crowds to stadiums that were empty up until then. This was going to be the money maker........Except for the fact that the crowd drawn is of the I-want-it-and-I-want-it-now kind which is by default a crowd of none-stayers. Which is exactly what happened to T20 in the UK. The numbers that pass the turnstile are dwindling. T20 in the UK is dead and the ones not recognizing this are the ECB, the investors and Sky. Oh, and obviously all fun is gone. Not only for the spectators. They already found a new 'fun'. There's no more fun for the players as well. It's become a serious matter. But what else can you expect from professional sportsmen. They are hired for their attitude of always wanting to win.

  • Ryan on July 13, 2011, 9:32 GMT

    Let's say that India had tried for it and lost a few wickets cheaply causing them to shut up and abandon the chase. Let's imagine that when the match is called off the score is say 130 for 6. Let's suppose that WI would then be delighted with a draw and claim a moral victory ......Oh wait , different scenario, same results.....

  • crazykric on July 13, 2011, 10:54 GMT

    Fantastic read. Loved the part about Afridi and Butt.

    Afridi is realling thinking everyone a fool when he said he will unmask the people who are running a smear campaign against him. It's like defending the PCB chariman even when the Butt is tarnishing his reputation. Rather than pointing directly at him, Afridi is blaming anonymous people. I seriously hope he doesn't now say that it's actually the US or Israel which is behind his smear campaign.

  • praxis on July 13, 2011, 15:46 GMT

    I followed that test match for 5 days, went crazy when Kirk Edwards almost ran himself out on 99, waited Chanders to score his century, then at late night when I was preparing myself with half a liter of turkish coffee in my stomach for the final hour expecting a miraculous collapse in Indian batting order, then...well, you all know what happened. Maybe Dhoni & co was right with that decision but for most of us who were watching it was very frustrating. But I think that many Indian fans are making a huge deal out of it. "The blessed Australians are often invoked at such times", as Andrew Hughes writes here is quite unnecessary. India surely sits at the top of ranking but they aren't a great side as WI or Australia were.

  • Jingle Bell on July 13, 2011, 18:14 GMT

    Haha...chubby cheeks!!!!! very nice post.

  • CollisKing on July 13, 2011, 19:17 GMT

    Will the Aussie 'big bash league' find new ways to out-ad the IPL in their TV coverage?* We already have ads at the end of every over, ads at the fall of every wicket, ads at drinks. How about ad breaks at the beginning of the bowler's run-up, an ad break while the umpire is thinking about it before the finger goes up, compulsory ad break during all-run 4's etc. etc. and of course extended ad-breaks when the umpire needs the evidence for tight run-outs and did he or didn't he drag it back in time diving to save that boundary ?

    *so they tell me, as a cricket fan I have never watched a T20 game in my life.

  • Faldo on July 13, 2011, 19:19 GMT

    Well, I'm sure those actually doing the job on the field knew best and in their wisdom decided that risking a series win was not called for. Point taken. However, could they not have tried to give the West Indians a scare, in attempting a chase at least during the start of their innings? It would have given them a better idea of how much they could be stretched if they faced a similar situation, say against a more formidable opposition.

  • sivaraman on July 13, 2011, 22:02 GMT

    Wonderful Article...Even if India would have been brave and chased and if we would have won the test match at Dominica, ICC ranking does not give great points...We are number one and we stay so...We should be happy with the 1-0 win Vs WI....if there is something to Blame it should be the weather which spoiled our chances in this series so much...Sammy has said they will finish in top 5 by 2015....let us see if they stay in the Test playing Nations list by then....