India in England 2014 August 18, 2014

Bhuvneshwar dragged down by the rest

India's marks out of ten after their 3-1 defeat in the Tests against England
70

Play 04:37
Laxman: 'Hope India look after Varun Aaron'

7.5

Bhuvneshwar Kumar
Bowled his heart out. Stayed accurate and skilful. Took 19 wickets at 26.63. Scored 247 runs. Saved Trent Bridge, won Lord's. Couldn't have done much more with his physique and strength.

6.5

Ishant Sharma
Rare India bowler who could cause discomfort with pace and bounce. Added accuracy and perseverance to his spirit. Won India Lord's with a hostile spell despite pain in his leg. Loses half a mark for getting injured at the wrong time. Fourteen wickets at 27.21 in three Tests.

6

M Vijay
Began superbly at Trent Bridge and at Lord's, deserved a century in India's victory. Left, left and left until the bowlers bowled at him. Lost his focus in the last three Tests, a soft run-out in the second innings in Southampton his low point.

Ajinkya Rahane
Least celebrated among the India batsmen, yet their batting's backbone. His Lord's hundred took the game away from England. A little loose outside off, which he will need to watch over the rest of his career.

5

MS Dhoni
Showed his specialist batsmen you don't always need a proper technique to score runs. Mental strength, discipline, hunger and bloody-mindedness can be enough. Took many a blow on his body but never gave up his wicket. Same couldn't be said of his keeping, which degenerated after Lord's. His keeping was almost poor.

Varun Aaron
Should have played when Ishant first broke down, but showed good pace and aggression despite having gone through a few stress fractures. Could be a handful if he becomes accurate and stays fit.

4.5

Ravindra Jadeja
Played an important hand in the Lord's win, but remained ineffective with the ball and in the slips. His bowling will have to improve a lot for him to be seen as a Test player outside Asia.

R Ashwin
Got only two chances, and then had to bowl with fewer than 200 on the board. Yet good signs were there: he has gone more side on, has been flighting the ball more, and has used fewer variations. Batting remains good as ever.

3.5

Stuart Binny
A noble experiment, but shouldn't have continued for three Tests. Bowling not good enough for a bowling allrounder. Batting not much better, yet he played a part in saving Trent Bridge.

Pankaj Singh
Desperately unlucky in his first Test but didn't bowl enough good balls for a man his pace; and didn't bowl fast enough for a man his build.

Cheteshwar Pujara
Got starts early in the tour but failed to convert them. Then when the starts weren't forthcoming, couldn't break out of the rut. Needs to work on his technique, get the back foot to move and the bat to come down straighter.

2

Mohammed Shami
Came to England as India's brightest fast-bowling hope. Didn't have the same zip as earlier, kept giving away loose balls down the leg side. Bowling coach Joe Dawes said he had lost his run-up. They couldn't correct it and he was dropped.

Virat Kohli
India's big batting hope, the one man who could dominate once he got going. But he was exposed outside off and couldn't find a way either to hit or grind his way out of poor form. Needs work on his technique.

Shikhar Dhawan
The jack in the box refused to come out. Kept being dimissed poking outside off. Was hoped to play the Sehwag kind of role; was dropped after three Tests.

Rohit Sharma
Looked decent in the first innings of his only Test of the series, but threw it away with a poorly timed shot. Wasn't played again.

1

Gautam Gambhir
Looked a pale shadow of the batsman he had once been, never threatening to build a longish innings. Played four innings, scored 25 runs; some said an average of 6.25 flattered him.

Sidharth Monga is an assistant editor at ESPNcricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • dummy4fb on August 22, 2014, 9:35 GMT

    Binny is a batting all-rounder. He's played that role in his entire career. Please do not confuse with this Dad, Roger, who was a bowling all-rounder @ the international level.

  • dummy4fb on August 22, 2014, 7:49 GMT

    I disagree with Ashwin. As you said, he bowled well and batted better. Only reason he didnt make more of an impact was because he didnt get a chance.

    I was going to say Gautum should get a 0, but he actually deserves a point since this performance should hopefully mean he will now never play for India ever again.

  • dummy4fb on August 21, 2014, 10:45 GMT

    Pretty harsh on Ashwin I think he was worth at least 6. Added runs a few times when his team were in real trouble and bowled pretty tidily if not very dangerously.

  • dummy4fb on August 20, 2014, 12:32 GMT

    Well said fans.......its time to move on...dhoni should nt be in test team.unlike others dhoni s nt a proper testbatsmen.captaining and wicketkeeping has earned his test place which now has been diminished.Its better dhoni 2 have another worldcup in his hand in Australia for us instead in test team.

  • TRAM on August 19, 2014, 20:22 GMT

    I wouldn't want MSD as a pure batsman in the team. I dont think he is going to field well in any position. So lets bring Saha, the best keeper in India (those who dont know please watch his keeping in videos). Saha has also recently proven as good batsman and scoring fast, if that matters. Nothing wrong in bringing up Sanju Samson, but it would be too early for him and also his keeping is not as good as Saha. So keep him as backup/T20s.

  • dummy4fb on August 19, 2014, 18:11 GMT

    The worrying thing is the fact that India had a lot of match practice, now that is a continuity of streak of poor performances in NZ, SA and Aus. It is unacceptable to say that Indian batters are inexperienced, problem is skill wise I deem. Moreover, spinners just don't click it was amazing that R Ashwin got a test wicket outside India after August 2012!! Sums up the scenario.

  • John_Mil on August 19, 2014, 17:47 GMT

    I believe India should have had Test specialist as Australia used to do earlier.Specialist like Shewag,Wasim Jaffer,Badrinath,Pujara,Dinesh Karthik,Irfan Pathan,Gambir (Though he did not well in this series could be used) and could be used with other players like Virat Koli (Though he failed in entire series) Rahane,Dhawan,Vijay,Rohit Sharma,Naman Ohja.Dhoni is a Good player and Captain.But in Test I believe some expert can lead the side and Dhoni can be ratained for 20/20 and 50 over match.India should have given a chance some senior players earlier for the test instead of testing the Young team completely.Young team good but this is not the time to experiment.if you want to experiment should be mixed with youth and experienced at least for the test.

  • jam-11 on August 19, 2014, 17:33 GMT

    Bhuvi 6.5,vijay,ishanth,rahane 6,dhoni 5,aron 4, ashwin,binny 3.5,jaddu ,pujara 3,pankaj 2.5,shami 2,dhawan 1.5,kohli 0.5,gambir 0.0

  • mensan on August 19, 2014, 16:50 GMT

    Did kohli and dhawan deserved 2?

  • jo_n on August 19, 2014, 15:16 GMT

    Suresh raina should bat and bowl well for indias sucess in 2015 WC.

  • No featured comments at the moment.