July 27, 2014

Boards must take a more serious view of on-field misbehaviour

Like many other governing bodies, the CPL has let off with a fine players who engaged in ugly confrontations, damaging the integrity of the tournament

If there was any racial abuse, the penalties must be much higher
If there was any racial abuse, the penalties must be much higher © LatinContent/Getty Images

When Shane Warne, the legendary Australian legspinner, and Marlon Samuels, the stylish if not-so-legendary West Indies batsman, angrily fronted up to each other on the pitch at the Melbourne Cricket Ground in January 2013, Cricket Australia's chief executive officer James Sutherland saw it as "something that only inspires a greater rivalry between two Melbourne teams and creates interest in the Big Bash League".

It is presumably not a view publicly shared by other officials regarding the subsequent high-profile on-field clashes between players. They would rather deal with such matters hurriedly and move on.

So it was when Barbados and West Indies fast bowler Tino Best and Pakistani batsman Shoaib Malik fronted up to each other after Best had knocked back Malik's leg stump in the Caribbean Premier League match between Best's St Lucia Zouks and Malik's Barbados Tridents at Kensington Oval on Wednesday night.

Television coverage beamed, according to CPL chief executive Damien O'Donohue, to over 200 million sets worldwide, showed Best's feisty celebrations carrying through until he was within touching distance of Malik. Whatever was said, it prompted Malik to turn back and meet Best face to face. Against the regulations, he shoved him on his shoulder.

Umpires Gregory Brathwaite and Joel Wilson, two of the West Indies' best, stepped in. They later made a report to match referee, the Jamaican Denavon Hayles. Zouks' captain Darren Sammy intervened to placate his rampant bowler.

That was not the end of it. There was a further flare-up between Best and Tridents' captain Kieron Pollard on the teams' return to the Hilton Hotel, their base for the Barbados leg of the tournament. Credible eyewitnesses said that it was so heated they feared it would come to blows. Eventually, as the media reported, the two were separated by Sammy. Again enhancing his standing as a strong leader, Sammy then escorted Pollard onto the beach and met with Best separately.

It would not have been a straightforward task. As their records show, Best's more clearly than Pollard's, both are combustible characters in the heat of the contest.

The issue was further intensified by tweets from Malik's wife, the Indian tennis player Sania Mirza, and Lendl Simmons, the Trinidad and Tobago batsman playing with the Guyana Amazon Warriors franchise.

Mirza raised the always contentious issue of race. Simmons simply taunted Best, against whom he has had his battles in regional cricket over the years.

Mirza's message read: "Racial abusing on a cricket field? Disgusting. I know [Shoaib] didn't hit him but now I wish he would have."

It was a serious charge at a time when all sporting bodies, among them the ICC, have introduced strict anti-racism regulations. Here was an opportunity for the CPL, in its second year of operation, to publicly state in unequivocal terms that it would not stand for such behaviour in its tournament. It would have been a precise, positive message to players and public alike.

Instead, citing the West Indies board's code of conduct and the governing code for the CPL, it simply announced the following day that both players had been fined for their on-field clash. It also stated that it was investigating the "incident" at the team hotel but dismissed it as "minor and no one was hurt".

Malik was docked 50% of his match fee for breaching the code relating to "inappropriate and deliberate physical contact between players in the course of play"; Best lost 60% of his match fee for two separate offences.

The second was far more serious and cost him 50%. It charged Best with violating the clause in the code relating to "using language or a gesture(s) that is seriously obscene, seriously offensive or of a seriously insulting nature to another player". So was this what Malik's wife meant by "racial abusing on a cricket field"? It was a question the CPL left unanswered. It stated only that both players pleaded guilty to the charges against them so that the match referee was not required to hold any hearings into the incident.

Surely it was the CPL's responsibility to undertake a thorough examination of what is a sordid issue with the potential to tarnish the reputation it has established. O'Donohue asserted on the tournament's website on Friday: "We take our responsibility to ensuring that we protect and promote the integrity of the tournament and the game itself very seriously." His comment was in relation to the arrest of three unnamed individuals for "suspicious behaviour at CPL games over the course of the tournament so far". Behaviour on the field of play is even more critical to ensuring the integrity of the tournament.

Not that the CPL is alone in its approach to controversy.

When Mitchell Starc, the left-arm Australian swing bowler, and Pollard engaged in an ugly confrontation in an IPL match in Mumbai last May they were penalised by match referee Andy Pycroft with match-fee fines - 75% for Pollard, 50% for Starc - and things moved on.

This was no ordinary spat. Starc, of Royal Challengers Bangalore, had peppered Pollard with short-pitched bowling. "Words were exchanged", to use the accepted jargon, after Pollard had to hurriedly evade one bouncer. As Starc was on his approach for the next ball, Pollard pulled out of his stance. The Aussie responded by hurling the ball past him to the keeper, prompting a furious Pollard to throw his bat towards Starc. They paid their fines and played on - as Best and Malik will do here.

Tony Cozier has written about and commentated on cricket in the Caribbean for 50 years

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • on July 27, 2014, 15:23 GMT

    I agree with Arvind Sankar. I would also say looking at the Trident game I really don't think what the Pakistani did would come close to a shove.Best needs to be roped in and that is why I respect Sammy.

  • on July 27, 2014, 11:38 GMT

    Arvind Sankar is correct (about Pollard throwing his bat, that is); further, it was not Starc's short pitched bowling which incited Pollard, but his words after the bouncer. Both players were wrong re: their own field behavioural displays, though...

  • on July 27, 2014, 11:31 GMT

    there should be a strick law for it

  • jw76 on July 27, 2014, 8:10 GMT

    Well said, Tony. It all starts with allowing sledging, send-offs and other insulting behaviour on the field, and it just grows. I am sure Anderson v Jadeja would never have happened if the umpires (who may not feel backed by the authorities) were prepared to step in and put a stop to it, as the likes of Dickie Bird and David Shepherd did in the past. As it is, we have a dangerous growing culture of hatred in Test cricket.

  • subcontinent-expert on July 27, 2014, 7:45 GMT

    On field behaviour needs to be within the limits. Though as a cricketer I can understand that while playing even the best friends can have some ugly conversations but that happens during the flow of a game where a bowler hates being HIT (even when he bowls a bad ball) and a batsman hates when he fails to HIT a bowl he wants to.... In all there cannot be Friendship between a bowler and a batsman (ideal condition) but being an International cricketers, players needs to understand their responsibilities towards the next generation which emulates what their seniors do on field...

    However new/young players should look up to players like Rahul/Sachin/Gilly/Kallis/Laxman/Younis/Misbah/Dhoni/Sanga rather than the players discussed in the article...

  • Bilal_Choudry on July 27, 2014, 7:01 GMT

    it was heat of the moment and its understandable ... Tino should apologize and life should go on

  • on July 27, 2014, 5:24 GMT

    I believe there is a misleading statement towards the end of this article. Pollard never and still to this day has never thrown his bat at Starc. He simply threw his bat on the ground closer to himself than to anyone else. Starc was not even in close vicinity of where the bat was thrown. I still find it hard to believe that the IPL were completely oblivious to the truth and still decided to fine Pollard for this.

  • on July 27, 2014, 15:23 GMT

    I agree with Arvind Sankar. I would also say looking at the Trident game I really don't think what the Pakistani did would come close to a shove.Best needs to be roped in and that is why I respect Sammy.

  • on July 27, 2014, 11:38 GMT

    Arvind Sankar is correct (about Pollard throwing his bat, that is); further, it was not Starc's short pitched bowling which incited Pollard, but his words after the bouncer. Both players were wrong re: their own field behavioural displays, though...

  • on July 27, 2014, 11:31 GMT

    there should be a strick law for it

  • jw76 on July 27, 2014, 8:10 GMT

    Well said, Tony. It all starts with allowing sledging, send-offs and other insulting behaviour on the field, and it just grows. I am sure Anderson v Jadeja would never have happened if the umpires (who may not feel backed by the authorities) were prepared to step in and put a stop to it, as the likes of Dickie Bird and David Shepherd did in the past. As it is, we have a dangerous growing culture of hatred in Test cricket.

  • subcontinent-expert on July 27, 2014, 7:45 GMT

    On field behaviour needs to be within the limits. Though as a cricketer I can understand that while playing even the best friends can have some ugly conversations but that happens during the flow of a game where a bowler hates being HIT (even when he bowls a bad ball) and a batsman hates when he fails to HIT a bowl he wants to.... In all there cannot be Friendship between a bowler and a batsman (ideal condition) but being an International cricketers, players needs to understand their responsibilities towards the next generation which emulates what their seniors do on field...

    However new/young players should look up to players like Rahul/Sachin/Gilly/Kallis/Laxman/Younis/Misbah/Dhoni/Sanga rather than the players discussed in the article...

  • Bilal_Choudry on July 27, 2014, 7:01 GMT

    it was heat of the moment and its understandable ... Tino should apologize and life should go on

  • on July 27, 2014, 5:24 GMT

    I believe there is a misleading statement towards the end of this article. Pollard never and still to this day has never thrown his bat at Starc. He simply threw his bat on the ground closer to himself than to anyone else. Starc was not even in close vicinity of where the bat was thrown. I still find it hard to believe that the IPL were completely oblivious to the truth and still decided to fine Pollard for this.

  • No featured comments at the moment.

  • on July 27, 2014, 5:24 GMT

    I believe there is a misleading statement towards the end of this article. Pollard never and still to this day has never thrown his bat at Starc. He simply threw his bat on the ground closer to himself than to anyone else. Starc was not even in close vicinity of where the bat was thrown. I still find it hard to believe that the IPL were completely oblivious to the truth and still decided to fine Pollard for this.

  • Bilal_Choudry on July 27, 2014, 7:01 GMT

    it was heat of the moment and its understandable ... Tino should apologize and life should go on

  • subcontinent-expert on July 27, 2014, 7:45 GMT

    On field behaviour needs to be within the limits. Though as a cricketer I can understand that while playing even the best friends can have some ugly conversations but that happens during the flow of a game where a bowler hates being HIT (even when he bowls a bad ball) and a batsman hates when he fails to HIT a bowl he wants to.... In all there cannot be Friendship between a bowler and a batsman (ideal condition) but being an International cricketers, players needs to understand their responsibilities towards the next generation which emulates what their seniors do on field...

    However new/young players should look up to players like Rahul/Sachin/Gilly/Kallis/Laxman/Younis/Misbah/Dhoni/Sanga rather than the players discussed in the article...

  • jw76 on July 27, 2014, 8:10 GMT

    Well said, Tony. It all starts with allowing sledging, send-offs and other insulting behaviour on the field, and it just grows. I am sure Anderson v Jadeja would never have happened if the umpires (who may not feel backed by the authorities) were prepared to step in and put a stop to it, as the likes of Dickie Bird and David Shepherd did in the past. As it is, we have a dangerous growing culture of hatred in Test cricket.

  • on July 27, 2014, 11:31 GMT

    there should be a strick law for it

  • on July 27, 2014, 11:38 GMT

    Arvind Sankar is correct (about Pollard throwing his bat, that is); further, it was not Starc's short pitched bowling which incited Pollard, but his words after the bouncer. Both players were wrong re: their own field behavioural displays, though...

  • on July 27, 2014, 15:23 GMT

    I agree with Arvind Sankar. I would also say looking at the Trident game I really don't think what the Pakistani did would come close to a shove.Best needs to be roped in and that is why I respect Sammy.