Grim prophecy fulfilled
David Frith on the controversial 'underarm' incident of 1981 between Australia and New Zealand
David Frith
01-Feb-2006
![]() |
![]()
|
'I have been waiting, with trepidation, for the moment when, with six runs needed off the final ball and a lot of money at stake, the bowler informs the umpire of a change of action and rolls the ball along the ground.'
Those grimly prophetic words appeared in these columns twenty months
ago, when the 'Brian Rose Affair' was being debated. But it was never
envisaged that the cool, proud and dignified Australian captain Greg
Chappell would be the perpetrator. When his brother, Trevor, rolled
the final ball of the match along the Melbourne pitch to New Zealand
batsman Brian McKechnie, who needed to hit a six to level the scores,
the game of cricket plumbed new, dark depths.
Such was the sense of outrage that the Prime Ministers of both
countries issued statements, Robert Muldoon of New Zealand calling the
underarm delivery 'an act of cowardice' and smearing the entire
Australian XI with the assertion that it was appropriate that they
were playing in yellow clothing -- notwithstanding that wicketkeeper
Rod Marsh, for one, reportedly disapproved of his skipper's
'underhand' plan when it was put to him. Following the Kiwi Premier's
aspersion, the Australians took legal advice. The Australian Cricket
Board, for their part, refrained from taking action against Chappell,
since he had broken no written law or regulation.
Shock-waves touched all corners of the cricket world and beyond.
Political cartoonists adapted the Chappells' derelict act for their
drawings. News-papers found it sufficiently profound to script it into
their leaders -- one of them headed 'Unfair dinkum'.
Greg Chappell later expressed regret, explaining that the decision was
hatched in the heat of the moment. The ACB admonished him and outlawed
underarm bowling for the rest of the series. It should have been
forever. In England, underarm bowling in limited-overs cricket was
banned two years ago.
Australia clinched the Benson & Hedges World Series Cup -- and the bag
of gold that went with it -- in the following match, steered home by...Greg Chappell (87).
So Chappell's name joins those of other stigmatized engineers of
evolution, such as 'Shock' White, whose sprawling bat-blade prompted
control of the breadth of the bat; John Willes, William Lillywhite,
Jem Broadbridge and Edgar Willsher, principal figures in the roundarm
and overarm revolutions; E. B. Shine and C. M. Wells, whose deliberate
wides and byes forced modifications to the follow-on rules; Douglas
Jardine, whose exploitation of Bodyline bowling led to restrictive
legislation, elastic though it may have proved to be; Sid Barnes,
whose absurdly frequent appeals against the light helped drive the
authorities into finding an alternative system; Brian Rose, who dared
to declare at 1 for 0 in a statistically-complicated limited-overs
match to safeguard his team's top position. Instrumental, all of them,
in altering the written codes of conduct. Disappointing, most of them,
to their friends and supporters.
The lesson, it must be accepted, however reluctantly, is that nothing
can any longer be left to 'the spirit of the law'. We live in an age
when the sharper individuals in our midst are devoted to the
exploitation of loopholes for financial gain.
We shall not this time hazard any guesses as to the next lucrative
piece of gamesmanship. That would be tempting the fates.
This article first appeared in the March edition of the 1981 Wisden Cricket Monthly