Middle order April 19, 2010

Pakistan's strongest suit

The country's greatest batsman, the gutsiest, a dashing rescuer, and others make up the middle-order shortlist

The engine room of Pakistan's batting has forever been the middle order. Good openers have come, even a couple of greats, but the real stories have been written by those who come in once the openers have gone. Over the years, memories are brightest of the great triumvirates or quartets that have formed the belly of the line-up: Zaheer Abbas, Javed Miandad, Asif Iqbal, Mushtaq Mohammad through the 70s; Younis Khan, Inzamam-ul-Haq, Mohammad Yousuf through the 2000s.

How spoilt Pakistan is for choice here shows in that nine names suggest themselves automatically, and probably others will add a couple more at least. Wasim Raja and Ijaz Ahmed, for example, despite their outstanding records against the leading pace attacks of their time (West Indies and Australia respectively) might have made it in some other lists.

The other dilemma is how many to have, of course. Should there be four specialist batsmen in the middle order, to shore up what is Pakistan's weaker suit? Or does the guaranteed presence of one of the world's greatest allrounders soften that need?

And one of the beauties of middle-order batsmen here has been there flexibility: barring a couple of names, most of the nominees have played at several positions in the middle order, with success. Ensuring the right order is critical to Test match success and that makes this selection trickier still, and one that will likely be most open to debate.

The contenders

Zaheer Abbas
Not for nothing was he called the Asian Bradman. Abbas had a monstrous appetite for big runs; four of his 12 Test tons were doubles, and he is the only Asian batsman to hit 100 first-class hundreds. He was beautiful to watch too.

Javed Miandad
Few would disagree that Miandad is Pakistan's greatest batsman. He was a free-spirited, full-stroked attacker when he began but became such a calculating mastermind thereafter that nobody minded. His Test average never fell below 50, from day one to the end, and he remains the highest Test run-getter for Pakistan. The nurdles and nudges, his presence at the crease, and an incredible brain, which made batting a form of sledging - no match was ever lost while Miandad was at the crease.

Mohammad Yousuf
A direct descendent of Abbas in more ways than are immediately apparent. Like Abbas, he is fond of scoring big, and like Abbas, his range of strokes is as vast as it is elegant, constructed from a high back-lift, quick hands, stillness and lazy feet. In 2006 he was, without doubt, the best batsman in the world, during a record-breaking year. But for many eyes his batting was never as beautiful and productive as during a bewitching Melbourne Boxing Day hundred in 2004-05 against two of the greatest bowlers the game has seen.

Not much separates the standings of Miandad and Inzamam at the very top of Pakistani batting. Like Miandad, Inzamam was a pure match-winner, often at his best with his side at its worst; but with many more strokes than Miandad. The best Inzamam innings are the ones he led Pakistan to a win in, and there are plenty. His bulky frame brought power, but a sharper mind than always apparent also allowed a surprising dexterity of touch.

Saleem Malik Though tainted, the wristy and ever versatile Malik was one of the finest batsmen this country produced, much more than the flat-track bully Imran Khan accused him of being. Three technical masterpieces in Headingley in 1987 and 1992 - when Headingley was still Headingley - should have told Imran as much. His mastery of Shane Warne in 1994, when he became the first man to really dominate Warne, should have convinced his other detractors.

Mushtaq Mohammad
A cheeky, innovative and aggressive batsman, Mushtaq was not as gifted as a couple of his brothers, but his personality and will saw him through to greater success. In a long career he ended with a batting average just under 40 - a proper benchmark in those days - and was, till the end, a fine lower-order organiser. His batting and captaincy were instrumental in Pakistan's rise in the mid-70s, and he wasn't a bad legspinner either.

Younis Khan
Pakistan's gutsiest batsman currently, Younis, after a shaky start, has become one of Pakistan's best one-downs (some achievement, given the openers he has had). Though he can be technically awkward, he is solid, and his fearlessness makes up for the rest. On tougher wickets around the world, he is probably Pakistan's most well-equipped batsman, with a range of shots not entirely orthodox but not entirely unorthodox either.

Asif Iqbal
A dashing rescuer of hopeless causes, Iqbal epitomised much of Pakistan's punch through the 70s. It took a legendary 146 at The Oval - made from No. 9 - to convince others he was a batsman first. Alongside Mushtaq, he ensured the lower middle order was not only robust but fairly enterprising; he revolutionised the role of running between the wickets.

Saeed Ahmed
Pakistan's first No. 3 of genuine quality, Saeed scored over 500 runs in his debut Test series in the Caribbean. He was a particularly fluent driver in the "v", and when he got in, big scores were on the cards. Three of his five hundreds are 150-plus and to end with an average of over 40 in the time he played is to suggest considerable ability and success.

We'll be publishing an all-time Pakistan XI based on readers' votes to go with our jury's XI. To pick your middle-order batsmen click here

Osman Samiuddin is Pakistan editor of Cricinfo

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • Dummy4 on April 28, 2010, 10:46 GMT

    it should like this best 11 (Imran Khan Captain)

    Saeed Anwar Mustaq Muhammad Zaheer Abbas Javeed Miandad Inzi Imran Khan Mion Khan/Rashid Latif as they are good batsman Shahid Afradi/Abdul Razzaq Wasim Akram Waqar Younis Saqlain Mushtaq

  • Arfan on April 22, 2010, 19:55 GMT

    1. Majid Khan 2. Aamir sohail 3.Inzamam ul Haq 4. Zaheer Abbas 5. Javed Miandad 6. Imran Khan (C) 7. Rashid Latif (Wk) 8. Wasim Akram 9. Waqar Younis 10. Shoaib Akhtar 11. Abdul Qadir

  • Razeen on April 22, 2010, 11:58 GMT

    My XI: 1. Imran Khan 2. Wasim Akram 3. Waqar Younis 4. Shoaib Akthar 5. Mohammed Sami 6. Umar Gul 7. Mohammed Ameer 8. Rana Naveed Ul Hassan 9. Azhar Mahmood 10. Aqib Jaweed 11. Sohail Tanvir

  • Tahir on April 22, 2010, 8:42 GMT

    My ALL Time XI 1)Hanif Muhammad 2)Saeed Anwar 3)Zaheer Abbas 4)Inzamam-ulHaq 5)Javed Miandad 6)Asif Iqbal/Muhammad Yousuf 7)Imran Khan 8)Moin Khan 9)Wasim Akram 10)Abdul Qadir 11)Fazal Mehmood/Waqar Younis

    For me Number 6 and Number 11 spots are too difficult to select.

  • Akhtar on April 22, 2010, 1:29 GMT

    For ysfcapricorn and cricketchopper. Please do not judge a player on personal likes and dislikes. Look at the records and performances of a player before judging. Zaheer abbas has never won a test match for Pakistan abroad with his century. All his winning centuries(5) were scored in Pakistan on docile wickets. Asif Iqbal was a man of crisis for some, but how many test he won for Pakistan with his centuries. Just three with two outside pakistan. Now look at Younis' performances. He scored six winning centuries outside Pakistan. Pakistan won 22 matches when Younis was in the team(14 abroad). During Asif's period Pakistan won just 10 matches(only 4 abroad). Zaheers period,Pakistan won 22(only 6 abroad) and he played a lot more matches than Younis but scored less runs. So Younis proves to be a better man of crisis than either Asif or Zaheer. Furthermore Younis played in the era of two all time great spinners, Warne and Murli. If you want more details I would be glad to provide.

  • Mohammed on April 21, 2010, 23:51 GMT

    Chosing eleven players for an all-time XI will become harder with each passing year. In Pakistan's case to pick 11 players in the period 1952-2010 is a tough ask. Although Younis Khan is not everyone's cup of tea, he has been and still remains an accomplished batsman. Given the right administrative backing, he could rescue Pakistan cricket with a brilliant mix of courage, unorthodox batting technique, and animated humour on the forthcoming tour of England in the summer of 2010. A great team man with a presence to go with positive outlook. Pakistan Zindabad.

  • Mohammed on April 21, 2010, 22:50 GMT

    Having followed Pakistan cricket since P VS WI 1974-75, I would like to see the following 11 players representing the country in a Test match. 1. Hanif Mohammad (Rock solid), 2. Saeed Anwar (the best match-winning innings by an opener at Calcutta 1998-99), 3. Inzamam-ul-Haq (proven match-winner), 4. Javed Miandad (a genius but actually impossible to describe in words), 5. Mushtaq Mohammad (under-rated all-rounder), 6. Asif Iqbal (Dashing Man of Crisis), 7. Imran Khan (obvious captain). 8. Rashid Latif (the best stumper). 9. Wasim Akram (easily the greatest left-arm pace bowler in the history of the game). 10. Waqar Younis (Mr. 110% in every game he played). 11. Mushtaq Ahmed (an ideal temperament for a spinner). The above team will rise to teh occasion in any given condition against any opposition. Pakistan Zindabad.

  • Dummy4 on April 21, 2010, 22:25 GMT

    i thnk it wud inzi , zaheer abbas n younis khan .... duno bout yousuf cuz he scord runz only in 2006 n otha dn tht duno..

  • shafeen on April 21, 2010, 19:51 GMT

    oh well, cricinfo - your not listening.

    it says pick 4 players, and then selection panel only has three choices - do you think someone could actually look at this stuff and fix/address stuff???

    4- zaheer, inzamam, yousuf and miandad. 3 - (for which i can see no reason as far as balance goes) - the last three named.

    Imran Khan, Wasim Akram and Waqar Younis plus one spinner (i'd go with quadair) is a good enough attack, not significantly improved by the inclusion of a 5th at the expense of a batsmen - so I'd go with 6 bats and 4 bowlers. I don't even know what the selection bias is on this team that we're being offered right now

  • sharjeel on April 21, 2010, 19:16 GMT

    I never saw a rescuer better then Asif Iqbal. I never saw a batsman having more strokes and being more wristy then Zaheer Abbas. I never saw a batsman more stylish then Majid Khan.I never saw a batman more clever then Jawaid Miandad.

  • No featured comments at the moment.