|Photos||Video & Audio||Blogs||Statistics||Archive||Shop||Mobile|
Monty Panesar's performance in Mumbai inspired us to look at England's rich history of excellent (if often eccentric) left-arm spinners
December 3, 2012
In Sydney in 1894-95, the little Lancashire spinner Briggs was the first man to get 100 wickets in Tests - just, beating the Australian "Terror" Turner by a day or two. Once described by CB Fry as "a professor of diddling", Briggs took 15 for 28 (14 bowled and one lbw) in a Test in South Africa in 1888-89, and an Ashes hat-trick three years later. But he was epileptic - some said the strain of striving for that 100th Test wicket took its toll - and suffered increasing ill health. He died in 1902, not long after his 39th birthday.
Vying with Briggs for an England place at the end of the 19th century was his Roses rival, Yorkshire's Peel. A useful batsman (despite once bagging successive pairs in Australia), Peel also passed 100 Test wickets. But a fondness for beer caused him problems - famously in Melbourne in 1894-95, when, after England had followed on, he turned up well-oiled to find his side back in with a chance. He had to bowl 40 overs, and responded with 4 for 77 to help his side to a famous win. Drink eventually led to his dismissal by Yorkshire, although an oft-repeated story about him relieving himself by the sightscreen is now thought not to be true.
The next slow left-armer to reach 100 Test wickets was Colin "Charlie" Blythe, a gentle man who took 15 wickets in a Test against South Africa in 1907, the year after helping Kent win their first official Championship title in 1906. Also in 1907, he took 17 Northamptonshire wickets in a day, still a record. But Blythe, like Briggs, was epileptic, and was eventually thought to be too frail for the rigours of Test cricket (a withdrawal that left one critic wondering how England would ever win another match). He was not felt too frail for war, though, and died near Passchendaele in 1917, aged only 38.
A Test player for more than 30 years, Rhodes was a cunning bowler, and improved his batting enough to move from No. 11 in the England order to No. 1 (and to share a famous stand of 323 with Jack Hobbs in Melbourne). Economical of action and words, Rhodes was not a huge spinner of the ball - but he was canny enough to know that if the batsman thought it was turning, half the battle was won. He was persuaded out of international retirement at 48 for the deciding Test of the 1926 Ashes, and helped England to victory at The Oval with 4 for 44 in the fourth innings. Rhodes went blind some time before his death at 95, but for years he was a regular spectator at Headingley, able to tell whether the batsman was timing it well by the noise of ball on bat.
After all those 100-wicket bowlers, here's one who only played one Test: but Parker made up for that with 3278 first-class wickets, including 108 for Gloucestershire in 1935 when he was 52. Parker should have played more for England, but blotted his copybook by grabbing Pelham Warner by the lapels in a hotel lift and accusing him of ruining his career. Since "Plum" was an MCC grandee, sometime chairman of the Test selectors, and editor of the Cricketer, this was not a wise career move.
It's said that Wilfred Rhodes didn't step down as Yorkshire's senior spinner until he was satisfied a worthy successor had come along: Verity, tall and unassuming, was the man. Verity made his first-class debut in 1930, and collected 64 wickets at 12... by the following year he was playing for England. In 1932 he took 10 for 10 against Nottinghamshire, still the cheapest ten-for in history, and in all claimed 1956 wickets during the 1930s (144 in Tests) at less than 15 apiece. And then war intervened again: Verity was killed in action in Italy in 1943.
The irascible Wardle might have been the greatest chinaman bowler in history - but successive Yorkshire captains thought wristspin was too frivolous, and insisted he bowl orthodox slow left-arm spin. He still took over 1800 wickets before falling out with Yorkshire in 1958, with 102 of them coming in Tests, where he would occasionally give a glimpse of what might have been with some sneaky wristspin. For much of his career Wardle battled for an England place with Tony Lock, Surrey's feisty slow left-armer, who finished up with 174 Test wickets: Wardle and his supporters were unhappy as they felt Lock was a thrower.
For around 15 years from 1966, England's preferred left-arm spinner was Underwood, who had taken 100 wickets for Kent in his debut season of 1964 when only 19. Quicker through the air than most, Underwood was a particular handful on rain-affected pitches, bowling England to a famous victory over Australia on one such at The Oval in 1968. He was hard enough to contend with on normal tracks, and finished with 297 Test wickets. Underwood's pre-eminence meant few chances for the long-serving Norman Gifford, who played his first Test in 1964 and his maiden one-day international 20 years later, a week shy of his 45th birthday, or Yorkshire's bouncy Don Wilson, who expected to get a wicket with every ball, and looked affronted when he didn't.
Fresh out of Cambridge, floppy-haired Edmonds befuddled the Aussies with 5 for 28 on his Test debut at Headingley in 1975 (the match ultimately ended when the pitch was vandalised). He won 50 more caps over the next dozen years, taking 125 wickets in all, his hair thinning at roughly the same rate as his captains', although they were usually tearing theirs out after another of Phil's theories. He survived the yips (which he overcame by bowling almost from a standing position with no run-up), numerous earnest conversations with his Middlesex skipper Mike Brearley, and a dressing room amused and antagonised in equal measure by his widespread business wheeler-dealing and his wife's bestselling tell-tale tour accounts. Finally Middlesex rejected Edmonds' suggestion that he should play as an amateur, and he turned to business full-time.
Phil followed Phil at Middlesex, although the laddish Tufnell was rarely confused with his lordly predecessor Edmonds. "The Cat" took 121 Test wickets despite few pretensions to batting or fielding, or being thought of as a bit of a liability on tour: his bowling - a classical left-armer's loop from a hop-skip-and-jump run-up - was good enough (and incisive enough on helpful pitches) to make up for that. Tuffers' county career finally ended in 2002 when he nipped off to take part in I'm a Celebrity... Get Me Out of Here, which he won, amid suggestions that some of his former team-mates were voting furiously to keep him in the jungle as long as possible.
Now England's limited-overs coach and Warwickshire's director of cricket, Giles played an unsung part in the 2005 Ashes success, flicking the winning runs in the crucial three-wicket win at Trent Bridge that put England 2-1 up. In all, he took ten wickets and scored 155 runs in that famous series. The previous year, after being slated in the press, he had threaded a classic slow left-armer's delivery through Brian Lara's gate for his 100th Test wicket. In all, despite injuries that famously once led his approach to the crease to be likened to a wheelie-bin, Giles took 143 wickets in 54 Tests before the aches and pains finally won out.
Steven Lynch is the editor of the Wisden Guide to International Cricket 2013Feeds: Steven Lynch
© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.
|Comments have now been closed for this article
Modern Masters: Rahul Dravid and Sanjay Manjrekar discuss Inzy's technique
Habibul Bashar talks about the team's early days, landmark wins, and the current squad
Alan Davidson was a fine allrounder, who has spent his life serving Australian sport in various capacities. By Ashley Mallett
Rob Steen: Who knew the Middle East would one day become the centre of a cricket-lover's universe?
Ahmer Naqvi: For a country torn by internal strife, he offers hope with his magnanimity, humility and cheerful disposition
The serene team culture cultivated by Misbah and his men shouldn't be allowed to be disrupted by a player with a tainted past
An early start to the international season, coupled with costly tickets, have kept the Australian public away from the cricket
The sickening blow that struck Phillip Hughes is a reminder of the ever-present dangers associated with facing fast bowlers, even while wearing a helmet
It is impossible to imagine how Sean Abbott must feel after sending down that bouncer to Phillip Hughes. While the cricket world hopes for Hughes' recovery, it should also ensure Abbott is supported
Why the Indian opener would be well advised to shelve the hook and pull in Australia
Never mind cricket's absence from free-to-air TV - changes in social attitudes, the demands of work, and an individualistic age are all contributing to a decline in participation
Pakistan have notched up some fine wins under Misbah-ul-Haq's leadership, but they haven't yet achieved consistent results outside the UAE
Going out to play cricket today would have been near enough to impossible. Even doing so next week in the nets and at the Gabba for the first Test will be difficult