February 19, 2016

Adaptable, inspirational, inconsistent

Brendon McCullum made 1000-plus Test runs from three batting positions, but 21% of his Test aggregate came from just six innings

Brendon McCullum's Test career has been a memorable one, even if the numbers don't do it complete justice © ESPNcricinfo Ltd

The stats for McCullum were updated after his last Test, which ended on February 24.

No other player has played 100 successive Tests from debut; only one New Zealand batsman has made more Test runs than him; none has as many 200-plus scores; no batsman has hit as many sixes in Tests, or scored a century in fewer balls; plus, he has been an inspirational captain for their team and a wicketkeeper. Brendon McCullum may not have a huge career average, but his resume in Test cricket is impressive nonetheless.

What also lends heft and more value to his career is the sheer number of roles he has performed for the team. When New Zealand didn't have a strong Test opener, McCullum moved up from his No. 5/6/7 slot, and made a success of it too, scoring more than 1300 runs as opener at an average of almost 40. He is one of only two New Zealand openers - Glenn Turner is the other - to score two double-centuries as a Test opener.

McCullum also made 1000-plus Test runs from two other positions - Nos. 5 and 7. That makes him one of only four batsmen to make 1000-plus Test runs as an opener, and also from at least two other slots. The others who achieved this were Colin Cowdrey, Alec Stewart and AB de Villiers. Both Cowdrey and Stewart scored 1000-plus from three positions other than opening.

Overall, McCullum batted at each of the top nine positions in both Tests and ODIs, the only player to do so in international cricket.

McCullum's best batting positions in Tests
Position Inngs Runs Average SR 100s/ 50s
 Opening  35  1316  39.87  60.70  2/ 6
 No. 5  44  1887  43.88  74.85  4/ 5
 No. 7  48  1751  38.91  63.55  5/ 7

Over a career spanning 12 years, though, McCullum struggled to achieve the sort of consistency in his batting numbers that would have taken his stats to another level. His career average of 38.64 is the result of some average years interspersed with a few strong ones. In the period between 2008 and 2010 his average rose to almost 43, thanks to a double-century in India, but thereafter he only had one really strong year in Tests - 2014, when he renewed his love affair with India's bowlers and milked them for a double and triple-hundred within a fortnight. He also got 190-plus scores against Sri Lanka and Pakistan in that year, but otherwise, he remained a batsman who could thrill for brief periods, but seldom converted those starts into really substantial scores.

Brendon McCullum's Test career
Period Tests Runs Average SR 100s/ 50s
 Till Dec 2007  27  1226  30.65  61.73  2/ 6
 Jan 2008 to Dec 2010  28  2006  42.68  62.22  4/ 11
 Jan 2011 to Dec 2013  27  1452  31.56  58.10  1/ 11
 Jan 2014 onwards  19  1769  52.02  77.58  5/ 3
 Career  101  6453  38.64  64.60  12/ 31

Given all those big hundreds he made against India, it's hardly surprising that they are the team against whom he made the most runs (1224) and averaged the highest (68). In fact McCullum is the only New Zealand batsman to score 1000-plus Test runs against India - the next-highest aggregate is 964, by Graham Dowling. McCullum scored 1000-plus Test runs against only one other team - 1041 against England - but needed 30 innings to get those, compared to 1224 in 19 against India.

The opposition teams he didn't favour much at all - till his last Test, at least - were Australia and South Africa: in 54 innings against them he scored only two centuries - though one of them was a jaw-dropping effort - and averaged 27.62. He only scored 185 more runs against them in 54 innings than he did in 19 against India.

Similarly, his stats in specific countries are also skewed. He has enjoyed playing at home, and also in India, the UAE, Bangladesh and Zimbabwe, but not so much elsewhere. All of his 12 Test hundreds have come in those countries, where he averages almost 49 from 66 Tests, but in other countries his average drops to less than half that number. In 35 Tests in Australia, South Africa, England, Sri Lanka and West Indies, he averages only 23.74, with a highest of 97 from 68 innings. In 15 series in these countries, he has averaged more than 35 only twice, and never more than 42. Ten of those 15 series consisted of only two Tests, though, which means batsmen get little opportunity to recover from a poor start to a series.

McCullum's Test stats, by opposition
Opposition Inngs Runs Average SR 100s/ 50s
 Aus, SA  54  1409  27.62  57.27  2/ 8
 B'desh, Zim, Ind, Pak  50  2720  57.87  64.43  8/ 8
 Eng, SL, WI  72  2324  33.68  70.25  2/ 15
McCullum's Test stats, by host country
Host country Inngs Runs Average SR 100s/ 50s
 Aus, SA, Eng, SL, WI  68  1591  23.74  57.74  0/ 10
 NZ, Ind, UAE, B'desh, Zim  108  4862  48.62  65.82  12/ 21

McCullum's inconsistency comes through in another stat: among the 31 batsmen who have made three or more 200-plus scores, his career average is the poorest. The next lowest is Marvan Atapattu's 39.02, while none of the others have averages lower than 40.

A break-up of McCullum's scores also reveals a career of very high peaks but fairly low troughs as well. His six highest Test scores - 302, 225, 224, 202, 195, and 185 - accounts for 20.66% of the total Test runs he has scored. It's unusual for 21% of the total runs in long career coming from just 3.5% of a batsman's innings: for most top batsmen it is in the 13-16% range.

McCullum's high percentage contribution from a few innings also indicates he hasn't scored enough from his other innings, which suggests an approach far too risky to deliver a high rate of success. His aggression and his audacity in strokeplay was breathtaking at times and led to some amazing innings, but equally, his approach was so fraught with risk that the percentages weren't in his favour. Fifty times he was dismissed before reaching 10, and 75 times before 20. Consistency wasn't his forte, but that unpredictability was also what made him so exciting to watch.

Lowest averages, among batsmen with 3 or more 200+ scores
Batsman 200+ scores Runs Inns Dis Ave
 Brendon McCullum  4  6453  176  167  38.64
 Marvan Atapattu  6  5502  156  141  39.02
 Stephen Fleming  3  7172  189  179  40.07
 Sanath Jayasuriya  3  6973  188  174  40.07
 Chris Gayle  3  7214  182  171  42.19
McCullum's spread of scores in Tests
Score range No. of inngs
 0 to 9*  50
 10 to 19*  25
 20 to 49  51
 50 to 99  31
 100 to 180  5
 180 and above  6
* Excludes unbeaten innings

And then there is McCullum the captain. He finished with a 11-11 win-loss record, though the losses column mounted towards the end with four defeats in five Tests against Australia; only Fleming, among all New Zealand captains, has won more Tests. In the two years from January 2014 to December 2015, New Zealand won nine out of 17 Tests, all of them with McCullum as captain. It's their highest win percentage over two successive calendar years, and the first time they've won more than 50% of Tests played during this period.

The back-to-back Test series against Australia didn't go to plan in terms of results, but McCullum still signed off in style, scoring the fastest Test hundred. And his last scoring shot typified McCullum the batsman: a pull for six, the 107th of his Test career. There could be no better illustration of going out on your own terms.

NZ's highest win % in Tests in a two-year period*
Years Won Lost Drawn Mats Win %
 2014-2015  9  5  3  17  0.53
 1982-1983  4  4  1  9  0.44
 2001-2002  7  3  6  16  0.44
 1998-1999  8  5  6  19  0.42
* In two successive calendar years

S Rajesh is stats editor of ESPNcricinfo. Follow him on Twitter

Comments have now been closed for this article

  • amit on February 21, 2016, 3:05 GMT

    To judge a player, consider the multiple roles he is playing into. As of 2nd day of his last test, B Mac averages 34.18 in 52 tests as wicket keeper. Judge him on the standards of a WK batsman. Among those WK scoring above 2000 runs in cricket, BMc is at no. 9. Among his contemporaries, he is exceeded by ABD, Sanga, Gilli, prior, and Alec stewart, andy flower are others. but, He is ABOVE his other contemporaries like Kamran Akmal, Brad Haddin(this is for the aussies), Ramdin, jaywardene, Mushfiqur Rahim, and MARK boucher (this is for the SA). So his exploits as WK batsman is decent, and pretty good. As a pure batsman, he averages, 43.15 which is pretty good and far more than more celebrated English batsmen achieved. That shows his value. Judge a player by the roles he performed. A WK batsman should never be judged amongst pure batsman. Put the context of his Wicket keeping to get the true picture.

  • bilal on February 20, 2016, 14:35 GMT

    A meaningless analysis. lowest average for 200 plus, highest percentage in 6 innings blah blah .... I don't know if that proves anything. McCullum was a entertaining player and will be missed .Lets leave it at that.

  •   Jonathan Geddes-mcclure on February 20, 2016, 12:14 GMT

    Data doesn't lie does it. A risk-taker and a gambler who could be relied upon not to come off more often than not. The word 'Legend' is overused hugely these days, but this article just about nails it on the head. What does make him stand out though is the impeccable way he's conducted himself as a professional cricketer and ambassador for New Zealand. The fact that he's come off in his final test against those most dismal of sportsmen is a fitting finale to his career

  • Cricinfouser on February 20, 2016, 10:46 GMT

    HENRYPORTER What a killjoy you are. I wonder what makes you so great that you can pass such disparaging remarks?! BMac is and always will be a NZ legend of cricket. What will you be?

  • rob on February 20, 2016, 5:24 GMT

    To finish up with an average close to 39 when you played well over half your career as a wicket keeper is very impressive. He is only just shy of Fleming's average and no one would dispute Fleming's quality as a batsman. Some would argue that McCullum's stats show how much he under performed relative to his talent but he has probably done more for NZ cricket in the last two years than has achieved by any of the greats of the NZ game. Hats off to him and glad that he is retiring while he is still at the top of his game and can earn himself and his family a very secure retirement in lucrative T20 cricket.

  • Rohan on February 20, 2016, 3:11 GMT

    Lara scored some 20% of his career aggregate in 9 innings ( 3.8% of total inn. played)..players who constantly attack seem to have these type of stats . When things go their way they make it really count and juice it for all its worth.

  • Stu on February 20, 2016, 0:09 GMT

    McCullum has done wonders for NZ. You can pick holes in any batsman, but when you consider his contribution across the board, he is one of the greats of NZ. Sad to see him go.

  • Gary on February 19, 2016, 21:20 GMT

    The Best article on Brendan McCullum yet.

  • Henry on February 19, 2016, 20:43 GMT

    I wish I could admire him more, but these are such average numbers with just a few moments in the sun. 4 man-o-match awards (2 in draws) over >10 years & 100 tests, pretty much says it all.

  • No featured comments at the moment.