Bashir, Jacks in frame as England mull taking the pink for a spin

Around 20 punters watched England's first evening net at the Gabba ahead of the day-night Ashes Test starting on Thursday.

The outdoor facilities at this historic but ageing colosseum are the most amenable in the world for observers, offering a behind-the-batter view of what it's like to face the fiercest bowlers going. There were plenty of eyes on the lane closest to Main Street, as Jofra Archer, Brydon Carse and Gus Atkinson steamed in with the pink Kookaburra ball.

But it was the net furthest away that had the most immediate interest ahead of the second Test. Both Shoaib Bashir and Will Jacks were bowling their offspin to England captain Ben Stokes, duking it out for what seems, at this juncture, the last available spot in the XI.

Mark Wood has been ruled out - England are optimistic his heavily strapped left knee will get adequate rest to ensure he is back in the mix for Adelaide - but the other 10 starters from the defeat in Perth are likely to be rolled out again.

Josh Tongue is the most like-for-like replacement if the tourists want to repeat their all-pace attack from Perth. But they are understood to be trending more towards spin in their bid to come back from 1-0 down, with the expectation that the pink Kookaburra will soften earlier than the red one.

The pair have had very different routes to these Ashes. Bashir has been the captain's go-to spinner since a shock call-up to the India tour at the start of 2024, with 68 wickets in 19 caps to date. His traits - a high release-point, revs coming from over the top of the ball - were deemed better suited to Test pitches (particularly Australian ones) compared to traditional English, doorknob-turning finger spinners.

Jacks, an allrounder, was the first conventional offspinner picked by Stokes, drafted on the tour of Pakistan in the winter of 2022 for his only two Test caps after developing as Surrey's primary spin option. He took 6 for 161 in his first go on debut - the first Test at Rawalpindi - and showed his dexterity as a batter by slotting in at No. 3 in the second innings of the next Test in Multan to give Ollie Pope extra rest after keeping. That he is on this tour owes as much to his batting - destructive qualities, and comfort filling in any top six position - and his tall action and ambition with the ball.

Bashir is understood to be the one in pole position, though it was Jacks who seemed to have the better of it on Monday night, before padding up. Nets can only tell you so much, of course. Stokes and the rest of England's batters were focused on getting attuned to the shift from day to night, and then how the floodlights transformed the grass beneath their feet. They will have one more hit in similar conditions on Wednesday before they get going in their attempts to square the series.

Visiting spinners have had very little success with the pink ball over here, collectively managing just 28 wickets at 64.03. Joe Root's three in the Adelaide Test on the 2021-22 tour has him joint-second on that list (with Yasir Shah); Dawid Malan is joint-fourth with two picked up from that same game. R Ashwin sits top with six at 20.66.

England would not be wrong to look at Nathan Lyon's impressive record of 43 dismissals at 25.62 from his 13 day-night home Tests and surmise spin is a must. But they may take more meaningful notes from Kevin Sinclair's cameo in Australia's one and only pink ball defeat.

That came here at the Gabba last year. Sinclair - also an offspinner - struck a vital 50 and then 14 not out, both from No. 7. He bowled just eight overs, all in Australia's first innings which sandwiched his batting efforts, but was able to snare Usman Khawaja for 75. Replicating Sinclair's impact rather than Lyon's is a far easier task and would favour Jacks.

It will be these cues from day-night affairs in Australia, and England's own learnings from the seven they have played, that will continue to be disseminated among the group over the coming days. The entire top five played in England's last pink-ball Test - against New Zealand at Mount Maunganui in 2023 - but Jamie Smith, for instance, will be playing his first of any kind.

"We've spoken with the guys who have played some pink-ball games, and had a look at some of the pink-ball games that have been played in Australia in the past four or five years," Carse said. His only day-night match happened to be in this country for England Lions against Australia A at Melbourne in January 2020.

"On an evening, it does seem to do a little bit more, especially if you have a slightly newer ball, which I'm sure we'll take into consideration throughout the game. It's going to be exciting. I'm expecting a massive crowd, a hostile crowd. The guys are really looking forward to it.

"I think looking back at a couple of highlights of previous games played in Australia, it's certainly very admirable how their new-ball bowling goes. You know, they strike early and I think that's going to be important, whether that's certain lines we'll be bowling or maybe bowling a touch fuller to let it swing. They've played some really good cricket with a pink ball. So, yeah, I'd like to say that we've had a look at some of the stuff that they've done over the previous years."